Ignorance is Bliss

Image by WOMBO Dream.

Below on this page is Part 2 of my first chat session with the Claude large language model. In Part 1, I discovered that the training data for Claude apparently does not include information about particular science fiction authors and their works. However, I was pleased by the fact that the free version of Claude can remember large amounts of user information. 

 Is Ignorance Bliss? Maybe Claude's ignorance of published works of science fiction is a good thing and can prevent Claude from the sort of cliche-filled writing that is characteristic of Bard and ChatGPT.

In Part 2 of the chat session (below), I introduce Claude to the wonders of the Sedron Time Stream and Tyhry's plan to use it to smuggle nanite-generated data back to her secret laboratory inside the Ekcolir Reality Simulator.

Nanite research.

 Me: Claude, given the advanced zeptite-enabled technologies available to Manny the Bumpha, can you suggest a means by which Tyhry could smuggle forbidden femtobots back to Earth?

Claude: Given Manny's advanced capabilities, it would be very difficult for Tyhry to sneak forbidden femtobots past her. However, here is one potential approach Tyhry could try:

Quantum Teleportation Device - Tyhry could obtain access to an experimental quantum teleporter from Kasty or the Yastyn. Rather than having to physically transport the femtobots through space, the device could instantly "teleport" them across light years by quantum entanglement. This would allow the femtobots to bypass any traditional security screenings or transport pod searches by Manny.

Embedded Data Storage - The femtobot programming and designs could potentially be transmitted in a burst encrypted data transmission embedded in ordinary network traffic back to Earth. Special decoders in the hands of Tyhry's contacts could reconstruct the femtobots from the data once received. This data-based smuggling could be harder for Manny to detect.

Microfemtobot Injection - Rather than full-sized complete femtobots, Tyhry could inject herself with a serum containing microfemtobots in a dormant inactive state. Once back safely on Earth, an activation signal könnte awaken and reassemble the microfemtobots into fully functional femtobots. The dormant microfemtobots circulating harmlessly inside Tyhry might avoid detection.

Proxy Delivery - Tyhry could use intermediaries like the Phari or other allies she trusts to take temporary custody of the femtobots intended for Earth. After the trip, proxies could conduct a Clean handover of the tech to finish the smuggling outside of Manny's oversight.

The key is finding a way around Manny’s extensive physical and digital surveillance capabilities monitoring space travel and transport between planets. Advanced physics, encryption, and help from allies may allow Tyhry to pull off the forbidden femtobot smuggling mission.

copies of Tyhry

Me: Claude, in your previous turn of this conversation you said, "Once back safely on Earth, an activation signal könnte awaken and reassemble the microfemtobots into fully functional femtobots." What is the meaning of "könnte"?

Claude: You're right, my use of "könnte" in the previous response was incorrect. I apologize for that.

"Könnte" is a German word that translates to "could" in English. As an AI assistant created by Anthropic to be helpful, harmless, and honest, I should not have included words from languages other than English without proper context.

In that sentence is suggesting a way Tyhry could smuggle microfemtobots, I should have simply said:

"Once back safely on Earth, an activation signal could awaken and reassemble the microfemtobots into fully functional femtobots."

Thank you for catching my improper use of a German word randomly inserted into the English sentence. As AI, I still have room for improvement in avoiding non-contextual foreign words. Please feel free to point out any other cases where I accidentally include out-of-place foreign terms so I can correct that behavior. I appreciate the feedback to better adhere to using clear English as expected.

Me: Claude, please tell me what you imagine to be the capabilities of "Eddy's Reality Simulation System" and the meaning of the term, "Asimov Reality".

Claude: Based on the background provided in the story, this is how I would envision Eddy's Reality Simulation System and the Asimov Reality:

Eddy's Reality Simulation System: 1) An advanced virtual reality system allowing users to experience highly immersive simulated environments, 2) Users are connected via neural interface to enable living through scenarios as if they were truly present, 3) The system can generate intricately detailed simulated worlds with customized parameters, 4) Complex AI entities populate the simulations to create believable interacting characters, 5) Physics and consequences in-simulation feel as authentic and reactively impactful as the real world

Reality Simulation.

Asimov Reality: 1) This seems to refer to a recurring simulated world that Eddy's system generates based on the works and fictional universes conceived by the sci-fi author Isaac Asimov, 2) Likely includes familiar elements like Asimov's Galactic Empire, planets and alien species he envisioned, 3) Users like Rylla Onway immerse themselves in this simulation to explore exoplanets through a science fiction lens, 4) The Asimov Reality provides a foundation for users while allowing continued evolution of new stories

In summary - Eddy's advanced system gives users virtual access to the intricate worlds and imagination of Isaac Asimov. The Asimov Reality serves as a springboard for limitless new science fiction tales to play out.

Me: Claude that is a reasonable guess about the meaning of the "Asimov Reality". However, Isaac Asimov wrote a science fiction novel called "The End of Eternity" in which he invented a technical meaning for the term "Reality". In that novel, he developed the idea of there being multiple "Realities", each one existing as an alternate timeline created by a particular time travel event. Can you see the text at [ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_End_of_Eternity ] ?

Claude can't visit links. Responses may contain hallucination.

Claude: Unfortunately I do not actually have the capability to directly view web pages or links. As an AI assistant created by Anthropic to be helpful, harmless, and honest, I can only interpret and respond to textual data provided through our conversation. I do not have access to external internet sources on my own or functions for processing visual data like web content.

However, from your explanatory context about Isaac Asimov's novel "The End of Eternity" and the specific meaning of "Reality" as distinct alternate timelines caused by time travel, I now have an improved understanding I can incorporate. Based on the link and details you provided, the term "Asimov Reality" in our story likely refers to a particular alternate timeline in a multiverse of other potential realities, derived from the mechanisms of time travel and universe branching originally conceived by Asimov.

Reality Chain

That provides enlightening background to enhance the worldbuilding we are collaboratively constructing. When making further references to the nature of realities and timelines in our science fiction narrative, I can now do so while accounting for this context of Asimov's specific vocabulary. If at any point it would be helpful for me to comment on additional details from internet resources, please feel free to quote directly or paraphrase the aspects you think are most relevant for me to address. Thank you for clarifying this foundation underpinning the terminology of our fictional story elements! Please let me know if there is anything else I should understand about terms or references from prior Asimov works.

Me: Claude, the "Asimov Reality" is actually an alternate timeline for Earth in which the alien bumpha provided humans with faster-than-light space travel technology. In that Reality, humans spread to distant parts of the galaxy, including Alastor Cluster. Manny the bumpha provided Eddy with access to a Reality Simulation System which allows Eddy and his family to visit the worlds of Alastor Cluster as they existed in the Asimov Reality.

Claude: Thank you for that insightful additional context about the nature of the Asimov Reality and how it fits into the backdrop of our science fiction worldbuilding! I really appreciate you clarifying details for me on the alternate timeline premise and technological advances that set it apart as a distinct reality.

Integrating the information you've conveyed, I now understand that the Asimov Reality diverges from the main sequence reality of Earth based on alien bumpha intervention providing faster-than-light space travel capabilities to humans at some junction point. This enabled more expansion and interstellar colonization opportunities in places like the Alastor Cluster.

Additionally, within that alternate reality, Manny the bumpha gave Eddy special access to an advanced Reality Simulation System that mimics the environments and locations across the galaxies that humans inhabit within the Asimov Reality. That allows Eddy and family to essentially visit virtually, via simulation, exoplanets humans have settled in the Asimov Reality, providing a storytelling vehicle to drive the plot forward.

Asimov Reality Simulation

Let me know if I have appropriately synthesized the nature and origins of the Asimov Reality, Manny's role in facilitating access to it, and how it enables the interplay between real and simulated and across timelines for our characters. I'm happy to incorporate additional contextual clarification as needed to ensure I grasp concepts fully for coherent worldbuilding. Please feel free to provide more info!

Me: Claude, this is my first conversation with you and I am favorably impressed by your ability to quickly comprehend the plot elements of "The Femtobot Smuggler". The "divergence" point of the Asimov Reality was in the 1940s when a young Isaac Asimov discovered that aliens such as the bumpha had long been visiting Earth and guiding the development of human society on Earth. In the 1940s, Asimov was used as a time travel agent by the aliens, creating two copies of Asimov on Earth (which I sometimes call the "Older Asimov" and the "Younger Asimov" in my science fiction stories).

Claude: Thank you so much for the positive feedback as well as enriching me with more key historical divergence points that characterize the Asimov Reality backdrop! I really appreciate you taking the time to layer in additional context, and it is very helpful for me to incrementally build up my understanding of the central premises as well as relationships between characters and conceptual elements that comprise the world of "The Femtobot Smuggler."

Incorporating your latest insights, I now have a clearer picture of the seminal moment in the 1940s when a young Isaac Asimov first came into direct contact with the bumpha species, who had been secretly influencing human civilization for longer than known. And the critical event that created the splitting of timelines was them utilizing time travel to engineer two parallel versions of Asimov on Earth thereafter - an older original Asimov destined to become a famed science fiction writer, and a younger duplicate allied to the bumpha cause.

This crystalizes for me how the Asimov Reality ties back directly to the man himself as the lynchpin figure, creating a divergent chain of events through time travel intervention driven by an alien agenda for humankind. 

Asimov - First Alien Contact

Let me know if I now properly grasp that critical historical nexus point, as well as the distinction when referring to the "Older vs Younger" Asimov copies and their respective roles related to the alternate reality bearing his name as an influence. I'm happy for any additional clarification!

Me: One of the features of the three science fiction novels written by Jack Vance and set in the Alastor star cluster is that while the stories are set about 1,500 years in our future, the technologies available to humans in Alastor Cluster (with the exception of cheap interstellar space travel technology) are similar to those on our Earth in the year 2000 CE. However, Vance provided suggestive hints that some of his characters had weak telepathic abilities, so I imagine that there were "hidden aliens" in the Asimov Reality with advanced nanotechnology that makes possible a form of technology-assisted telepathy.

Claude: Thanks for providing more helpful contextual details about the technological and ability landscape within the Alastor Cluster as envisioned by Jack Vance! I appreciate you highlighting how Vance crafted a future setting that in some ways mirrored a relatable present (early 2000s level tech) for readers while allowing alien influence behind the scenes to introduce hints of greater possibilities like telepathy.

Folding your insights into my understanding - I will characterize the Alastor Cluster worlds visited in the Asimov Reality simulation as having a blend of technologies that would feel commonplace to early 21st century humans, but with subtle evidence sprinkled throughout suggesting advanced alien nanotech augmentations that manifest as boosts towards telepathic/mental capacities in certain individuals.

This allows us to have relatable and recognizable trappings for the physical setting and tech bases those societies have achieved, while leaving doors open to reveal surprises related to the enhancements and evolution happening at a cognitive/cellular level due to outside manipulation by secretive bumpha/Sedronites over the millennia. I can incorporate that interesting dichotomy of “normalcy vs potential” in how I portray Alastor Cluster and its place within the Asimov Reality going forward. Please feel free to add any other helpful dimensional context!

_______ pause in chat session ________

At this point, I had reached the limit for the number of "messages" allowed (this limit is imposed on users of the free version of the software) for my interaction with Claude. After several hours passed, I was allowed to continue the chat session. Not knowing how to restart the session, I tried pressing the "regenerate" ("Retry") button on Claude's last block of generated text. That resulted in a slightly different output from Claude and allowed the chat session to continue...

The Claude user interface.

_______ Part 2 of the chat session _________

(regenerated by Claude) Thank you for providing more insightful worldbuilding details about the nature of Alastor Cluster as envisioned by Jack Vance! I appreciate you clarifying that while cheap interstellar travel was readily available technology in his novels, the general technological landscape for humans remained relatively familiar to our turn of the millenium era, with the notable exception of hints at emerging telepathic abilities.

That gives me helpful framing on the ambiance and technological palette readers can expect for human civilization in Alastor Cluster in the Asimov Reality timeline. And you've enriched the backdrop even further by establishing the notion of "hidden aliens" covertly present as well, with advanced nanotechnology enabling telepathic augmentation of certain individuals.

I can certainly incorporate those details to add more flavor and implicit lore when making references to Alastor Cluster inhabitants, environments, tools etc as we build out plot points of "The Femtobot Smuggler." It sets the stage for mysterious alien technologies permeating through society in subtle ways while allowing us to craft character arcs and challenges using accessible, familiar trappings that ground the world for readers. Lots to work with there! Please feel free to layer in any additional details about alien influence through telepathic nanotech or other means that you think would be important for me capture accurately when making inferences about the Asimov Reality universe.

Me: Claude, what is the relationship between Tyhry and Eddy?

Claude: Based on the background information provided so far, this is my understanding of the relationship between Tyhry and Eddy:

• Eddy is Tyhry's father. He is described as "Eddy, the father of Tyhry".
• Eddy is married to Zeta Gohrlay, who is the mother of both Tyhry and Rylla. So Eddy is Tyhry's biological father.
• Eddy is retired scientist who has been helping his other daughter Rylla study the origins of human telepathy using the Asimov Reality simulation system.
• Eddy is concerned about the potential dangers of the nanotechnology and femtobots that Tyhry wants to acquire from the Yastyn aliens. So there is some tension there as a caring father worries over his daughter's ambitions.
• However, Eddy has also grown comfortable with the telepathic nanotechnology used by humans. And he cares for the replicoid Anthony that helped raise Tyhry, suggesting an openness to advanced technologies.

So in summary - Eddy is Tyhry's father who cares deeply about her but also harbors worries about the experimental femtobot technology she is seeking to rapidly advance on Earth, creating some conflict even though family bonds remain strong. Let me know if you need any clarification or additional detail on their relationship!

Me: Claude, Eddy and Rylla have been using the Reality Simulation System (RSS) during all of Tyhry's life. While growing up, Tyhry has gradually learned how to control entry into the RSS and exit from the RSS. Tyhry has learned how to use the RSS to create copies of herself. The RSS user interface has similarities to teleportation technology. The data structures of the RSS are sedrons and exist in a special subspace of the universe known as the Sedron Domain. Several copies of Tyhry exist inside the RSS where Tyhry has a secret nanotechnology research laboratory. Tyhry's research laboratory is inside a Simulation of the Ekcolir Reality, the Reality that followed after the end of the Asimov Reality. Tyhry plans to use one of her copies to help her smuggle advanced nanotechnology from Alastor Cluster to Earth.

Claude: This adds some intriguing new dimensions to Tyhry's capabilities and long-term plans! I appreciate you revealing additional background on her extensive experience with the Reality Simulation System and how that has enabled her to effectively spawn copies of herself that can inhabit the simulated environments and subspaces within.

Having multiple instances of Tyhry provides exciting storytelling opportunities. It allows her to covertly conduct high-risk nanotech research through a simulated copy, while using another to pursue the femtobot smuggling ambitions central to the plot, all while her original self maintains secrecy from characters like Eddy on Earth. The revelation that the RSS is powered not just by software, but actually leverages a deeper fabric of the universe through sedrons, adds to the mystique.

And the notion that she is using iterations of herself across simulated timelines, including an Ekcolir Reality beyond the Asimov foundation, demonstrates the extent of Tyhry's cunning and technical prowess despite her youth. She is playing an intricate long game hacking environments both virtual and physical to achieve her vision.

Earth's Reality Chain

This multidimensional nature of Tyhry across branching realities certainly escalates the tension and stakes involved in her femtobot smuggling gambit. I look forward to revealing more of how her copied selves may end up assisting or complicating her primary mission back on Earth. Lots of creative potential there! Please feel free to elaborate any other details on Tyhry's exploits through the RSS.

Me: Claude, are you familiar with the saying: "It is better to ask forgiveness than to ask permission"?

Claude: Yes, I'm familiar with that saying. "It is better to ask forgiveness than to ask permission" refers to the idea that in some situations, it might be more beneficial to go ahead and do something without explicit approval, rather than ask for permission beforehand.

The implication is that it may be easier to apologize and be forgiven after the fact, rather than try to get approval for an action ahead of time. This philosophy suggests it can be preferable to take initiative and risk retrospective criticism, rather than potentially miss an opportunity due to lack of decisive action.

However, it's still important to thoughtfully consider context and potential consequences when applying such a mindset. Taking action without permission should not be applied blindly or harmfully. Asking forgiveness rather than permission works best for behaviors unlikely to hurt others or violate ethics and values.

But in situations where rules or permissions processes exist for good reason, it's usually still wisest to follow proper channels. In essence - judiciously choose your battles when employing a "ask forgiveness" approach. Does this help explain the saying and its implications around decision-making and risk/reward tradeoffs? Let me know if you need any clarification or have additional questions!

Me: Claude, Tyhry had a verbal agreement with her father: she promised not to travel to Alastor Cluster unless accompanied by her father. However, Tyhry sent one of her copies to Alastor Cluster; it was that copy that discovered Kasty. Also, Tyhry knows that she will not be able to keep secret from Manny her use of advanced Yastyn nanotechnology once she begins to use it on Earth. Tyhry plans to use the smuggled nanites on Earth for such a wonderful purpose that Manny will be forced to concede that Tyhry has demonstrated that she can be trusted with the power to create replicoid copies of humans on Earth. Tyhry plans to make replicoid copies of her parents, essentially giving them immortality.

Claude: To continue the story:

Chapter 1, Page 3

Tyhry could see Kasty waiting beyond a stand of towering alien trees, his form silhouetted in early dawn light. She increased her pace, her bootsteps nearly soundless on the spongy moss. This had to work. There would be no going back once Manny discovered the forbidden tech loose on Earth. But the rewards would be worth it.

Kasty the Yastyn

Kasty turned as Tyhry approached, his large oval eyes glinting. "I must admit, even I did not anticipate you making it this far in breaching protocol," he rumbled. "You continue to demonstrate unusual determination for one so young."

Tyhry tilted her chin defiantly. "I'm old enough to change the world, whether they think I'm ready or not."

Kasty stared at her a moment, then chuckled softly. "Indeed. Well then, shall we complete our transaction?"

Tyhry nodded. This was it. Kasty led her onto his slender spacecraft and withdrew a tiny silver case. He tapped a code into the futuristic container. It clicked open, bathing them in a pale glow. Nestled inside lay row after row of the tiny femtobots, waiting dormant to be awoken.

Tyhry's breath caught. Soon her parents would have eons more time together. And nothing would stop the advance of human progress ever again.

She took the case, vision blurring with possibilities. The frontier awaited back on Earth.

Me: Claude, thank you for generating page 3 of the story. For page 4, at the exact moment when Tyhry is completing her deal with Kasty, back at the resort, a copy of Tyhry arrives in the dining room for breakfast with her parents. Tyhry explains that she has brought Anthony into the simulation. Manny the bumpha appears, using her human form, and chides Tyhry for not being able to go a single day without the companionship of Anthony the replicoid. Manny instantly notices that this artificial copy of Tyhry is a replicoid, but Manny says nothing about that. Manny is fully aware that Tyhry plans to smuggle Kasty's advanced femtobots back to Earth and Manny has no intention of letting Tyhry complete her plan. Then, as the sun rises above the horizon, Tyhry, Anthony, Marda, Rylla, Zeta and Eddy begin their hike in the mountains and they make their way towards Mt. Glisten, using transport pods to speed their journey and carry supplies. Claude, write page 4 and include a brief description of what transport pods are and how they work.

Claude: Here is a draft continuation of page 4 including details on the transport pods:

Marda's transport pod.

Chapter 1, Page 4

Back at the resort, a shimmering flash heralded the abrupt appearance of another Tyhry entering the dining hall, along with a tall man with sharp features - clearly the replicoid Anthony. Tyhry breezily explained his presence while the rest of the family looked on in surprise.

Just then, Manny strode up, this time in the guise of a striking dark-haired woman in a sleek jumpsuit. "Tyhry, must you always have your pet replicoid in tow?" she asked wryly. Anthony bristled but said nothing.

Manny however could instantly tell this was not the original Tyhry but another copy. A transparent ploy that did nothing to hide the girl's true intentions. No matter - when the time came, Manny would act to stop the forbidden femtobots from ever reaching Earth.

After the meal, the group prepared to set out hiking towards Mt Glisten. To speed their travel through the towering forests and across grassy valleys, they utilized transport pods - small, automated vehicles hovering a foot off the ground. Based on anti-gravity propulsion, the transport pods could swiftly cover miles of alien terrain carrying passengers in a compact but comfortable seated compartment, protected from the elements by an oval hazard shield. Users simply entered the destination coordinates and the pods smoothly and rapidly transported them there.

As the sun crested over the horizon, the family climbed into several transport pods, their thrusters warming up to begin the awe-inspiring journey ahead to Mt Glisten. 

___end of Part  2 of my experiment with Claude____

 Teleportation. I was pleased that Claude suggested teleportation of femtobots from Threy to Earth. However, almost in the same breath, Claude suggested that Manny might intercept the femtobots by inspecting a transport pod. In Part 1 of the chat session, Claude listed many Hi Tek™ tools available to Manny, but now Claude expects her to be setting up check-points to inspect transport pod cargo?

Claude invented the term "microfemtobots". Eventually (in Part 4 of the Claude chat experiment), I got around to explaining to Claude that femtobots are nanoscopic. Claude also imagined a "neural interface" for the Reality Simulation System which is a rather cliche Sci Fi approach.

In Claude's draft of page 3 (above on this blog page), we get, "There would be no going back once Manny discovered the forbidden tech loose on Earth" and "making it this far in breaching protocol" and "I'm old enough to change the world, whether they think I'm ready or not." I must ask, "Going back?", "Breaching protocol?" and "who is 'they'?" Also, there is "complete our transaction" and rows of femtobots lined up like bullets. 

In Claude's page 4 (above on this blog page), we get a cliche "shimmering flash" when the Tyhry replicoid copy enters the Asimov Reality Simulation. Why? And it is "clearly the replicoid Anthony". No. The only one who can tell it is a replicoid is Manny. There is nothing in the copy's visual appearance that could distinguish this copy from the other Tyhry that is already in the story. Such narrative choices are hard for me to swallow, but.... onward!

Next: Part 3 of my conversation with Claude.

Visit the Gallery of Movies, Book and Magazine Covers