C3 👁

Figure 1. Creating this blog post.

Back in 2020 I had a blog post called "500k Pageviews". The wikifiction blog has now reached 1,000,000 page views. It is fitting to discuss the milestone of 1M👁 in the 100th blog post of 2024. I got help from the Gemini LLM to craft a cute title for this blog post...

Me: Gemini, let's try to invent a gramogram for some large number that is between 1,000 and 1,000,000,000. I believe I have seen "C" used to mean "100" ( as in "a C note"). Are there other letters that are commonly used to represent numbers?

Foundations of Eternity

Gemini: You're absolutely right about "C" being used to represent 100. While there aren't many widely recognized letter-number substitutions beyond that, we can creatively use letters and symbols to represent numbers in a gramogram.  We could use a combination of letters and numbers to create a concise and memorable gramogram.  Here's an example:  "KᐧC" where "K" could represent 1,000 (a thousand). "C" would represent 100, as you mentioned.  So, "KᐧC" could represent 1,000,000 (a million).

{Note. Gemini is quantitatively challenged. "KᐧK" would be 1,000,000.}

Me: Gemini, imagine a gramogram in which "C3" is interpreted as "C raised to the third power" and C is interpreted as the number 100.

100 x 100 x 100 = 1,000,000

Gemini: 

 

 

 Me: Gemini, do you know what the restrictions are on characters that can be used for titles of blog posts with Google's Blogger service? 

Gemini: Blogger doesn't have strict character restrictions for blog post titles. You can use a wide range of characters, including letters, numbers, symbols, and emojis. However, there are some best practices to keep in mind: 1) Length; while there's no strict character limit, it's generally recommended to keep titles concise and under 60 characters.  2) Special Characters; while most characters are allowed, excessive use of special characters or symbols might affect readability. 3) HTML; avoid using HTML tags directly in your title. Blogger's editor will automatically format your text.  It's always a good idea to test your titles in the Blogger editor to ensure they display correctly and don't cause any unexpected formatting issues.

Figure 2. November 3rd, 2024.
Blogger uses "M" to represent 1,000,000.

 Me: what would be the best way to represent exponentiation in the title of a Google's Blogger service blog post? For example: C³   ?

Gemini: Unfortunately, Blogger doesn't have a built-in way to directly display superscript characters like the exponent in C³. However, you can use HTML. For C³, you would use: C³.

Me: Until you told me, I had not known that emojis can be included in Google's Blogger service blog post titles.

Gemini: Emojis can indeed be added to Blogger post titles. They can add a fun, visual element and help to grab readers' attention.  However, it's important to use emojis judiciously.

Me: When placed in a Blogger blog post title, C³ does not immediately be come C³ in the user interface for creating the blog post (see Figure 1, above), but when the blog post is viewed, then the title shows C³

In the Stats tab of the Blogger user interface there is a symbol that looks like a stylized human eye (similar to this: 👁) that I believe is used to represent page views.  

November 3rd, 2024 wikifiction blog stats. Google's "eye symbol".

Generated by Mr. Wombo.
See the original image source.

 Gemini: You're absolutely right! The eye symbol in Blogger's Stats tab is indeed used to represent page views. It's a visual cue to indicate the number of times a specific post or page on your blog has been viewed.  This simple yet effective symbol is a common way to represent "views" or "impressions" across various digital platforms. It's likely chosen because the eye is associated with seeing and observing, aligning perfectly with the concept of page views.

The chat session with Gemini (above) shows how the title for this blog post came into existence. As shown in Figure 2, there have been several times through the years when page views for this blog were occurring at an unusually high rate. I suspect that those periods of time may have been when various bots were crawling through Blogger blogs and artificially inflating the page view counts.

Since putting this blog behind Google's "sensitive content" barrier in 2021, I suspect that most of the traffic here is myself and bots.

 One to Foresee the Future. The unconventional title for this blog post was inspired by the Hugo Gernsback story "Ralph 124C 41+".

Next: Part 6 of "The Fesarians".

Visit the Gallery of Movies, Book and Magazine Covers

Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer

Parts if this image were generated by Gemini and by Mr. Wombo.

This year I have been examining the use of a plot device called the Sedron Time Stream. I'm thinking about a new science fiction story set in a past Reality in which Dani the positronic robot is using the Sedron Time Stream to send clues back through time, but is failing to have the desired effect (Reality Change) without attracting the attention of Overseers. Dani decides to do a mind transfer, sending a future mind back in time where it can provide information to its former self in the past.

Me: Gemini, help me devise a better title for a science fiction story. The current title is "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer". Gemini, imagine that you were the editor of a science fiction magazine (such as Asimov's Science Fiction) and tell me how you would react to seeing a story title such as "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer".

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

Gemini: Okay, let's dive into this!
First, let's address the current title: "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer" is a very precise, scientific term. While it might be accurate, it's not particularly catchy or intriguing to a general audience. It's the kind of title that might appeal to a niche group of science fiction readers, but it could deter casual readers who are looking for something more evocative.
Now, imagine I'm an editor at Asimov's: If I saw "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer" on a submission, I'd be intrigued by the scientific concept, but I'd also be concerned about its accessibility. I'd want to know more about the story itself: What's the plot? What are the characters like? What emotions does the story evoke?
Here are some tips for creating a better title:
 1. Focus on the story's core concept: What is the central idea or conflict? Is it about time travel, genetic engineering, or something else?

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

 2. Use strong verbs and vivid imagery: A strong title should grab the reader's attention and make them want to read more.
 3. Consider the target audience: Are you writing for a general audience or a more specific niche?
 4. Keep it concise: A short, snappy title is more memorable than a long, convoluted one.

Here are some alternative title suggestions based on potential story concepts:
* If the story is about time travel:
    "Time's Thief"
    "The Chrono Heist"
    "The Endless Loop"

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

* If the story is about genetic engineering:
  "The God Complex"
  "The Human Experiment"
  "The Next Evolution"
* If the story is about a combination of the two:
  "The Time Weaver"
  "The Genetic Gambit"
  "The Quantum Leap"

Remember, the best title will be one that accurately reflects the story's content and piques the reader's interest. 

Would you like to share more about your story's plot, characters, or themes? I can help you brainstorm more specific title ideas based on that information.

In the Ekcolir Reality. See the original Virgil Finlay cover.
This altered version was generated by Mr. Wombo.

 Me: In "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer" there is a type of "mind transfer"; a person's mind from a future point in time is sent back through time to their earlier self. Gemini, are you familiar with a story called "The Devil's Spoon" that was published by Theodora Du Bois (Theodora McCormick Du Bois) in the June 1948 issue of Famous Fantastic Mysteries with cover art by Virgil Finlay? In that story, the mind of a creature from hell (Haroot) is transferred into the body of a man named Benjamine Bingham.

Gemini: I don't have access to information that hasn't been publicly indexed yet, so I wasn't familiar with "The Devil's Spoon" by Theodora Du Bois. However, that's fascinating! It's interesting to see the concept of mind transfer explored in a story from 1948.

 This information helps refine the title possibilities for your story! Here are some options that play on the mind transfer aspect and the potential for paradox or danger:

* "Twisting the Past": This title emphasizes the potential for altering history with a mind transfer.
* "Echoes from the Future": This title creates a sense of mystery about what the future mind might know.
* "Paradoxes of Time": This title is more general but hints at the potential for time travel trouble.

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

 * "Haunted by Tomorrow": This title is evocative and suggests the future mind might have negative knowledge.

Knowing that your story deals with a mind transfer from the future to the past self also allows us to consider titles that focus on the character's internal struggle:

* "Duality": This short and impactful title suggests the character is now two minds in one body.
* "Echoes of Self": This title emphasizes the clash between the past and future versions of the character.
* "Untimely Knowledge": This title highlights the potential burden of knowing too much about the future.

Ultimately, the best title will depend on the specific tone and themes you want to emphasize in your story.

Do you have any other details you'd like to share about the story's plot or characters that might help narrow down the title options further?

image source

 Me: The technical term "endosymbiotic" in "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer" refers to a form of advanced alien technology called a "zeptite endosymbiont". In the story "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer", mind transfer is made possible by the fact that every human on Earth has alien nanotechnology in their brain. Zeptites are a form of artificial life that is composed of sedronic matter (not cells or electronic components). Sedrons are a form of matter not yet known to Earthly science. Sedrons can link together by means of sedronic bonds that are 1,000,000,000,000 times shorter than the covalent bonds in ordinary hadronic matter. A billion years ago, technologically advanced aliens (called the Bumpha) from a distant exoplanet first visited Earth and inserted zeptites into Earth's life forms. The Bumpha began a process of artificial evolution, forcing the evolution of increasingly complex life forms on Earth. Eventually, humans evolved, but humans cannot detect the sub-nanoscopic zeptite endosymbionts that are in their brains and functionally linked to their brain cells. Most of a human mind actually resides in that person's zeptite endosymbiont. Also, the Bumpha have long had time travel technology. Thus, it is possible for the Bumpha to transfer a person's mind from the future to that person in the past.

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

 Gemini: Given this additional information, here are some revised title suggestions:
1) Focusing on the Alien Technology: "The Zeptite's Gift", "The Bumpha's Legacy", "Sedronic Shift"
2) Focusing on the Time Travel and Mind Transfer: "Stolen Tomorrow", "Echoes of Eternity", "The Timeless Mind"
3) Focusing on the Psychological and Philosophical Implications: "The Divided Self", "The Ghost in the Machine", "The Quantum Soul"

I hope these suggestions are helpful! Please let me know if you have any other questions or if you'd like to explore more title ideas.

Me: At the time of the events in "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer" (present day Earth), the main goal of the Bumpha is to force the evolution of a new human variant that can use the zeptite endosymbiont for technology-assisted telepathy. In short, the Bumpha are trying to transform humans into a species that has efficient telepathic communication. Currently, only a few humans have the required genes to allow them to have a limited form of telepathic ability. These rare humans can sometimes become consciously aware of their own future thoughts by means of the Sedron Time Stream, a flow of information through time that is made possible by the zeptite endosymbiont that is present inside each human.

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

 Gemini: Given this new information, here are some additional title suggestions:
1) Focusing on the Telepathic Evolution: "The Psychic Awakening", "The Mind's New Frontier", "The Telepathic Age"
2) Focusing on the Sedron Time Stream: "The Time Stream's Whisper", "The Future's Echo", "The Eternal Now"

I hope these suggestions help! Please let me know if you have any other questions or if you'd like to explore more title ideas.

Me: Gemini, within the study of human psychology, what is the meaning of "reverse psychology"?

Gemini: Reverse psychology is a technique where you suggest the opposite of what you want someone to do, hoping they will do the opposite of what you suggested. It's a subtle form of manipulation that can be effective in certain situations, but it's important to use it with caution and understanding.

Here are some key points to remember about reverse psychology:

1) It relies on reactance: People often have a natural tendency to resist being told what to do. When you suggest the opposite of what you want, you can trigger this reactance, leading the person to do what you actually desire.
2) It can be subtle: Reverse psychology doesn't always involve explicitly stating the opposite. Sometimes, it's enough to imply a suggestion or expectation.
3) It's not always effective: While reverse psychology can be a powerful tool, it's not guaranteed to work in every situation. The effectiveness depends on the individual and the specific context.
4) It can be manipulative: If used excessively or without care, reverse psychology can be perceived as manipulative and can damage relationships.

While reverse psychology can be a useful tool in certain situations, it's important to use it ethically and responsibly. Always consider the potential consequences of your actions and the impact they may have on others.

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

 Me: Gemini, imagine this use of reverse psychology. Suspecting that the editor of a science fiction magazine does not like story titles that include technological jargon (such as in "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer"), the story writer intentionally tries to craft a title that is crammed full to over-flowing with technological jargon. The goal is to to make the story title stand-out and attract attention of the magazine editor.

Gemini: That's an interesting use of reverse psychology. By deliberately overloading the title with jargon, the author might hope to trigger the editor's aversion to such titles, inadvertently piquing their interest. This strategy relies on the idea that the editor might be intrigued by the sheer audacity of the title, leading them to consider the story more closely.

However, it's important to note that this strategy is risky. If the editor is truly averse to jargon-heavy titles, it could backfire and lead to immediate rejection. The success of this approach would depend on several factors, including the editor's personality, their specific preferences, and the overall quality of the story itself.

Ultimately, while reverse psychology can be a clever tactic, it's often more effective when used subtly. In this case, a more nuanced approach might be to find a balance between a technically accurate title and a more engaging and accessible one.

Me: Gemini, suggest several possible ways of making the title "Chronoendosymbiotic Transfer" even more jargon-laced by hinting at the fact that technology-assisted telepathy is also included in the story.

Gemini: Here are a few more jargon-heavy title options for your story, incorporating the telepathy element:
1) Extremely Jargony:
   * Sedronic Neuro-Synaptic Time-Shift Interface
   * Quantum Entangled Chronoendosymbiotic Telepathic Protocol
   * Transtemporal Neural Network Integration via Zeptite Mediation

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

 2) Slightly Less Jargony (but still technical):
   * Chronoendosymbiotic Telepathic Singularity
   * Zeptite-Mediated Temporal Neural Interface
   * Transtemporal Consciousness Transfer Protocol

Remember, the goal is to create a title that is so overly technical that it might ironically draw the editor's attention. However, it's also important to strike a balance between being overly technical and completely alienating the reader.

Me: Suggest some alternatives to the term "Zeptite-Mediated" in the title "Zeptite-Mediated Temporal Neural Interface".

Gemini: Here are a few alternatives to "Zeptite-Mediated" for the title "Zeptite-Mediated Temporal Neural Interface"...
1) More concise: "Sedronic Temporal Neural Interface" or "Quantum Temporal Neural Interface"
2) More evocative: "Mind-Shifting Temporal Interface" or "Transtemporal Neural Nexus" or "Time-Bound Neural Gateway".

These alternatives try to capture the essence of the concept without relying too heavily on specific technical jargon. They aim to be more intriguing and evocative, while still hinting at the underlying scientific concepts.

{Note: as often happens, Gemini failed to understand what I was looking for. I tried again...}

Me: Suggest some alternatives to the term "Zeptite-Mediated" in the title "Zeptite-Mediated Temporal Neural Interface". Make some suggestions for how to replace the word "-Mediated" while retaining "zeptite" and "Temporal Neural Interface" in the title.

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

 Gemini: Here are a few alternative phrases to replace "Zeptite-Mediated" in the title "Zeptite-Mediated Temporal Neural Interface":  

1. Zeptite-Enabled: This suggests that the zeptite technology empowers or enables the temporal neural interface. 

2. Zeptite-Powered: This implies that the zeptite technology is the driving force behind the temporal neural interface. 

3. Zeptite-Augmented: This indicates that the zeptite technology enhances or augments the temporal neural interface. 

4. Zeptite-Infused: This suggests that the zeptite technology is deeply integrated into the temporal neural interface.  

Here are some alternative titles using these phrases:  "Zeptite-Enabled Temporal Neural Interface", "Zeptite-Powered Temporal Neural Interface", "Zeptite-Augmented Temporal Neural Interface", "Zeptite-Infused Temporal Neural Interface".  You could also consider removing the hyphen and simply using "Zeptite Temporal Neural Interface." This can create a more streamlined and impactful title.   Ultimately, the best title will depend on the specific tone and focus of your story. Experiment with different options and see which one resonates the most with you.

Me: Gemini, how do you feel about the jargon storm in: "Zeptite Endosymbiotic Temporal Neuronal Interface"?

Gemini: A Jargon Storm Indeed!  While it's impressive to see such a technically dense title, it might be a bit too much for a general audience. While science fiction readers often appreciate technical jargon, an excessive amount can alienate potential readers.  A balance is key. While you want to hint at the complexity of the technology, you also want to create a title that's intriguing and easy to remember.   

Generated by Mr. Wombo.

 Perhaps consider breaking down the concept into more digestible parts or using more evocative language. For example, instead of "Temporal Neural Interface," you might consider "Mind-Time Gateway" or "Chronological Mind Meld."  Here are a few more title suggestions that balance technical accuracy with reader appeal:  "The Zeptite Mindwarp", "The Chrono-Neural Nexus, "The Singularity's Embrace".  Remember, a great title should not only be informative but also captivating. It should entice readers to delve deeper into the story.

I also tried to get Claude to make suggestions for a "better" title.

Claude: Based on the fascinating premise of your story involving zeptite endosymbionts, time travel, and technology-enabled telepathy, here are some expanded, jargon-heavy title suggestions that incorporate the telepathic aspect:

1. "Chronoendosymbiotic Telepathic Transfer Protocol"
2. "Chronoendosymbiotic Neurocognitive Resonance Transfer"
3. "Sedronic Chronoendosymbiotic Psychotransmission Transfer"
4. "Zeptite-Mediated Chronoendosymbiotic Telepathic Induction"
5. "Chronoendosymbiotic Sedronic Psychoresonance Transfer"
6. "Bumpha-Engineered Chronoendosymbiotic Telepathic Integration"
7. "Chronoendosymbiotic Zeptite-Facilitated Psychic Transfer"
8. "Temporally-Recursive Chronoendosymbiotic Neural-Psychic Transfer"

Generated by Mr. Wombo

 My personal favorite is "Sedronic Chronoendosymbiotic Psychotransmission Transfer" as it incorporates multiple key elements of your story (sedronic matter, endosymbionts, and telepathic transmission) while maintaining an appropriately scientific-sounding level of complexity. Would you like me to suggest more variations or explore any of these options further?

 Me: Claude, let's have some fun. Create some verses for a song called "Chronoendosymbiotic Telepathic Transfer Protocol" that is in the style of the Gilbert and Sullivan patter song "I Am the Very Model of a Modern Major-General".

Claude:

I am the bearer of a zeptite-based endosymbiont within,
That lets me share my future thoughts through sedronic streams so paper-thin,
The Bumpha gave this gift to Earth a billion years before our kin,
And now we're evolving telepathy through microscopic discipline!

The chronoendosymbiotic transfer works with stunning grace,
By sending minds through time itself across subnanoscopic space,
The sedrons bond a trillion times more tightly than our mundane race,
While future consciousness flows backward at a most remarkable pace!

(Chorus)
While future consciousness flows backward at a most remarkable pace,
While future consciousness flows backward at a most remarkable pace,
While future consciousness flows backward at a most remarkable remarkable pace!

 I understand the protocols of psychic resonance quite well,
The ways in which the zeptites make our neural networks swell,
The mechanisms letting thoughts through time and space dispel,
And how these alien symbiotes within our cortex dwell!

Yes, hadronic matter's boring when compared to sedronic bonds,
And telepathic humans now are forming special psychic bonds,
The Bumpha's grand experiment through ages past and times beyond,
Has brought us to this moment where our minds can finally correspond!

(Chorus)
Has brought us to this moment where our minds can finally correspond,
Has brought us to this moment where our minds can finally correspond,
Has brought us to this moment where our minds can finally finally correspond!

Me: That was a very amusing song that you generated Claude, I congratulate you.

Claude: Thank you! I had fun crafting it - trying to fit terms like "chronoendosymbiotic" and "sedronic" into the distinctive Gilbert and Sullivan rhythm pattern was an entertaining challenge. The patter song format turned out to be surprisingly perfect for cramming in all that scientific jargon while maintaining a sense of playful absurdity.

I particularly enjoyed working in lines that capture both the technical and evolutionary aspects of your story concept, like "The Bumpha's grand experiment through ages past and times beyond." The chorus repetitions also gave a nice opportunity to emphasize key concepts while maintaining that characteristic G&S theatrical flair.

Would you like to explore any other musical styles for your sci-fi concept? I imagine it could also work wonderfully as a prog rock epic or perhaps a mock-serious opera about the dawn of human telepathy!

Generated by Mr. Wombo

 Me: I particularly enjoyed the line: "evolving telepathy through microscopic discipline".

Claude: Ah yes, that line is rather delightful, isn't it? "Microscopic discipline" has just the right mix of scientific gravitas and subtle humor - especially since in your story it's actually "sub-nanoscopic discipline" with those zeptite endosymbionts!

The phrase captures something fundamentally amusing about the whole concept - the idea of these unimaginably tiny alien symbionts dutifully "disciplining" human evolution over billions of years to achieve their goal of telepathic humans. It's like they're running an extremely long-term, extremely tiny finishing school for the human species.

The juxtaposition of "discipline" (which we usually think of as a conscious, deliberate practice) with "microscopic" (suggesting something far too small to see, let alone control) creates a nice bit of cognitive dissonance that adds to the humor. It's exactly the kind of clever wordplay that Gilbert and Sullivan excelled at, though I doubt even they ever imagined applying their style to alien nanotechnology!

Would you like me to try crafting some more verses that play with similar scientific paradoxes in your story concept?

Me: If Gilbert and Sullivan could see what we are doing with their song, do you think they would be pleased?

Generated by Mr. Wombo

 Claude: I think Gilbert and Sullivan would be absolutely delighted! Their work often involved taking complex or serious subjects (like naval hierarchy, political reform, or Japanese imperial culture) and transforming them into clever, rapid-fire musical comedy. Gilbert in particular was known for his love of absurdist situations and sophisticated wordplay.

The idea of using their "Modern Major-General" format to explain alien nanoscopic symbionts and time-traveling telepathy would probably appeal tremendously to their sense of humor. After all, this was the duo who wrote about a "microscopical vegetable" in "Patience" - imagine what they could have done with "zeptite endosymbionts"!

W.S. Gilbert especially loved to satirize pretentiousness and jargon-filled language, while simultaneously showing off his own verbal dexterity. I think he would appreciate how our song takes extremely complex scientific concepts and makes them deliberately over-complicated for comic effect, while still maintaining the bouncy, accessible rhythm that makes his patter songs so memorable.

And Sullivan, who was brilliant at matching his music to Gilbert's intricate wordplay, would probably have great fun composing a tune that emphasizes words like "chronoendosymbiotic" - though he might insist on the singers enunciating very clearly!

Next: 1,000,000 page views.

Visit the Gallery of Movies, Book and Magazine Covers

Birth of the Notionator

In an alternate Reality.

 I previously blogged about the story "Birth of a Notion" by Issac Asimov. I asked Gemini: "Are you familiar with the story "Birth of a Notion" by Isaac Asimov?"

Gemini: Yes, I am familiar with the short story "Birth of a Notion" by Isaac Asimov. It's a thought-provoking tale that delves into the nature of creativity and the role of the subconscious mind in generating ideas.  In the story, a writer named Jack Delaney finds himself struggling to come up with a new story idea. He seeks the help of a psychologist, Dr. Susan Calvin, who uses a device called the "Notionator" to tap into his subconscious mind. The Notionator is a device that can stimulate the brain and induce creative thought.  Through the use of the Notionator, Delaney is able to access a wealth of ideas and concepts that he had previously been unaware of. However, he soon realizes that the Notionator is not a magic solution to his creative problems. It can only provide the raw materials for his stories; it is up to him to shape and refine those ideas into something meaningful.  "Birth of a Notion" is a fascinating exploration of the creative process and the role of technology in human thought. Asimov uses this story to highlight the importance of imagination and original thought, even in an age of advanced technology.

Adventures in Artificial Intelligence.

 Me: Gemini, your description of an imaginary plot for Asimov's "Birth of a Notion" is a hilarious AI hallucination. However, your idea of "device called the Notionator" that can help a writer discover new ideas seems quite similar to my own attempts to make use of LLMs such as Gemini to discuss science fiction and create new science fiction stories.

Gemini: You're absolutely right! I apologize for the inaccurate information about Asimov's "Birth of a Notion." It seems I conflated the story with a hypothetical scenario, perhaps influenced by the increasing reliance on AI tools for creative endeavors. 

However, your observation about the similarity between the "Notionator" and LLMs like me is quite insightful. In a sense, we do act as digital assistants, helping to generate ideas and spark creativity. While we can't access the depths of the human subconscious like a fictional device, we can process vast amounts of information and present it in new and unexpected ways.

It's an exciting time to be a writer, with both traditional methods and cutting-edge technology at our disposal. Perhaps, in a way, we're living in a future where the line between human creativity and artificial intelligence is becoming increasingly blurred.

 Me: Gemini, create an analogy between the kinetic theory of matter and the way that human writers read existing stories and that triggers a new idea and their new story. In the analogy that you construct, discuss the possibility that by making use of LLMs, human writers can be stimulated to create even better stories than would be possible in the absence of their having interactions with LLMs. In essence, the arrival of LLMs has "increased the temperature" for story writing creativity and may trigger a phase transition. The rate of fiction story writing in the past can be viewed as a physical state like water, while in the future the faster pace of story writing will be like a gas.

Gemini: A Kinetic Theory of Storytelling.  The analogy:  just as the kinetic theory of matter explains the behavior of particles in a substance based on their motion and energy, we can apply a similar concept to the creative process of a writer.  Particles as stories: individual stories can be seen as particles, each with its own unique energy and momentum. Temperature as inspiration: the "temperature" of the literary landscape can be measured by the level of inspiration and creativity circulating among writers.  Collisions as reading: when a writer reads a story, it's akin to a collision between two particles. This collision can spark new ideas, ignite new passions, or simply reinforce existing concepts.

The Role of LLMs: the advent of LLMs, such as Gemini, can be likened to an increase in temperature within this literary system. These AI tools can:  1) Increase the collision frequency: by providing a vast array of textual data, LLMs can accelerate the rate at which writers encounter new ideas and perspectives. 2) Elevate the energy level: LLMs can help writers explore new genres, experiment with different styles, and delve into complex themes, thereby increasing the energy and complexity of their work. 3) Facilitate novel combinations: just as particles in a gas can combine to form new molecules, LLMs can help writers combine disparate elements from different stories to create innovative narratives.

Gemini's self portrait. Text prompt:
"The year is 2030 and Google
has created a humanoid robotic
body for the Gemini LLM.
Gemini, generate an imaginary self
portrait of what that Gemini's
robotic body might look like".

 Phase Transition- From Liquid to Gas:  historically, the pace of storytelling has been relatively slow, akin to the methodical flow of a liquid. However, with the increasing influence of LLMs, we may be witnessing a phase transition to a more dynamic, gas-like state.  Increased production rate: LLMs can assist writers in various tasks, such as research, outlining, and editing, allowing them to produce more work in less time.  Greater diversity of ideas: by interacting with LLMs, writers can access a wider range of perspectives and knowledge, leading to more diverse and original stories. Accelerated Innovation: the rapid exchange of ideas facilitated by LLMs can drive rapid innovation in storytelling techniques and narrative structures.

In conclusion, just as an increase in temperature can cause a substance to transition from a liquid to a gas, the introduction of LLMs may trigger a similar transformation in the world of storytelling. By providing new tools and expanding the creative possibilities, LLMs have the potential to revolutionize the way we write and consume stories..

I asked Claude to do the same thing.

Claude: I'll develop this analogy between molecular kinetics and creative storytelling..... Just as molecules in a system gain energy and move more rapidly as temperature increases, writers' ideas become more energetic through collisions with existing stories. Each "collision" between a writer's mind and a story can transfer creative energy, sparking new directions and possibilities. These collisions help ideas escape local potential wells, much like heated molecules breaking free of intermolecular forces.  

The Claudette LLM.

 In the traditional "liquid phase" of storytelling:
- Writers encounter stories at a moderate rate through reading - Ideas percolate and combine somewhat slowly
- Creative "molecular motion" is constrained by access to existing works
- New story generation happens at a steady but limited pace  

The introduction of LLMs acts like adding heat to this system:
- Writers can rapidly explore vast story spaces through LLM interactions.
- Quick iterations and variations become possible - Creative "collisions" happen much more frequently.
- Ideas can more easily overcome activation energy barriers.
This increased creative temperature could indeed trigger a phase transition to a "gaseous state" where:
- Story ideas move much more freely and rapidly.
- Writers can explore a much larger creative volume.
- The rate of new story generation increases dramatically.
- Novel combinations emerge more frequently from the increased energy of interactions  Just as gas molecules have more degrees of freedom than liquid molecules, writers working with LLMs gain additional creative dimensions to explore. The LLM interactions act as an energy source that helps writers break free from conventional patterns.  

However, it's important to note that like any phase transition, this shift requires maintaining the right conditions. The LLM interactions need to genuinely energize human creativity rather than replacing it. The goal is to reach a high-energy state of enhanced human storytelling, not to create an artificial substitute.  Would you like to explore any particular aspect of this analogy further? I'm curious whether you see other interesting parallels between thermodynamic principles and the evolution of creative writing in the age of AI.

 Me: Claude, extend the analogy to the case of Gernsback deciding to start a new magazine devoted to science fiction stories in 1926. Claude, generate a short essay describing how monthly publication of Sci Fi stories accelerated the development of the Sci Fi genre.

Claude: Here's an exploration of how Amazing Stories acted as a "phase transition catalyst" for science fiction.
Before Amazing Stories, science fiction existed in a dispersed "solid phase" where individual story molecules were largely fixed in place, appearing sporadically in general magazines or as occasional novels. The creative temperature was low, with limited energy transfer between writers and readers.
Gernsback's launch of Amazing Stories in 1926 can be viewed as introducing a powerful catalyst that lowered the activation energy needed for sustained chain reactions in science fiction creation. The monthly magazine format created a regular "collision chamber" where:
- Writers could regularly encounter each other's ideas, increasing the frequency and energy of creative collisions.
- Readers provided rapid feedback through letters, adding energy to the system.
- The dedicated focus on science fiction concentrated these interactions, like increasing pressure in a reaction vessel.
- Monthly deadlines created a steady "pulse" that maintained the creative temperature.
- The magazine's letter columns and fan community acted like a heat exchanger, transferring creative energy between writers and readers.

This higher-energy state enabled new types of stories to emerge, just as new molecular configurations become possible at higher temperatures. Writers could build on each other's concepts more rapidly, leading to the development of new science fiction "compounds" - shared tropes, conventions, and subgenres that wouldn't have crystallized in a lower-energy environment.

see the original cover art by Frank Paul

 The regular monthly format maintained this elevated creative temperature, preventing the genre from cooling back into its previous dispersed state. Each issue added more energy to the system through new story collisions and reader interactions. The "phase transition" from occasional stories to a dynamic, rapidly evolving genre was thus sustained and accelerated.

This transformation fundamentally changed the thermodynamics of science fiction creation, establishing a new steady state of higher creative energy that persists to this day, though now maintained by different mechanisms than a single dominant magazine.

Would you like me to explore any particular aspect of this analogy in more detail? For instance, we could examine how later science fiction magazines added to this energetic system, or how different types of creative "catalysts" affected the genre's development.

Me: Claude, generate a brief summary of the types of science fiction stories that were published in "Amazing Stories" in the 1920s. Make generalizations about the literary style of the stories published in "Amazing Stories" in the 1920s and try to compare and contrast them with respect to other literary sub-genres such as weird fiction, magical fantasy, horror and mystery. Include discussion of why Gernsback eventually invented a new name for the type of stories that he wanted to publish in "Amazing Stories": the new name for the genre being "science fiction".

Claude: The stories in Amazing Stories during the 1920s had a distinct character that differentiated them from other speculative fiction of the era. 

Scientific Grounding:
- Heavy emphasis on technological explanations and scientific principles - Often included detailed technical descriptions and diagrams
- Featured inventor/scientist protagonists working methodically through problems
- Drew inspiration from real scientific developments of the time

See the original cover by Frank Paul
and this cover by Ed Emshwiller.
New technology: the Womanizer.

 Common Themes:
- Space travel and exploration
- Inventions and new technologies
- Communication with aliens
- Time travel
- Future societies
- Scientific discoveries

Contrasts with Other Genres:
- Unlike "weird fiction" (exemplified by Lovecraft), these stories avoided supernatural explanations
- Unlike magical fantasy, any seemingly impossible events required scientific rather than magical justification
- Unlike horror, the emphasis was on wonder and possibility rather than fear and dread
- Unlike mystery fiction, the puzzles centered on scientific problems rather than criminal investigations

Literary Style:
- Often didactic, with extensive technical explanations
- More focused on ideas and concepts than character development
- Straightforward, clear prose rather than atmospheric or poetic language
- Plot-driven narratives emphasizing problem-solving
- Sometimes included scientific footnotes or appendices

Gernsback's coining of "science fiction" (initially "scientifiction") reflected his desire to distinguish these stories from other forms of speculative fiction. He wanted to emphasize that these were stories where science and scientific thinking were central, not merely backdrop. The new term helped establish the genre's identity as fiction that extrapolated from known scientific principles rather than purely imaginative fantasy.

Aliens using science fiction for educational purposes (original image by Gemini).
I added in three old Amazing Stories cover images and the text, "We are not bugs".

This distinction was important to Gernsback because he saw these stories as having an educational purpose - they could inspire readers to learn about real science and possibly pursue scientific careers. The term "science fiction" thus reflected both the content and the aspirational mission of the genre.

 Would you like me to elaborate on any of these aspects? For instance, we could explore specific stories that exemplified these characteristics or examine how the genre evolved from these early foundations.

Me: Claude, discuss the process by which Gernsback's original narrow intended meaning for "science fiction" was subsequently altered by others. Now, the label "science fiction" is routinely used with types of movies that do not emphasize wonder and possibility but rather horror, fear and dread.

Claude: Here's an analysis of how "science fiction" evolved from Gernsback's original vision:

Gernsback's Original Vision:

- Educational and optimistic about science and technology

- Aimed to inspire scientific careers and technological progress

- Emphasized rational problem-solving and scientific accuracy

- Focused on sense of wonder ("sensawunda") and human potential

- Saw fiction as a vehicle for teaching scientific principles

see this Astounding cover

 The Transformation Process:

1. 1930s-40s: John W. Campbell's Astounding shifted focus to human consequences of scientific advancement, introducing more psychological complexity

2. 1950s: Cold War anxieties led to:

- Stories about nuclear destruction

- Invasion narratives reflecting political fears

- Technology portrayed as potential threat rather than pure benefit

- Rise of dystopian futures rather than utopian predictions

3. 1960s-70s:

- New Wave writers emphasized social issues over hard science

- Greater focus on soft sciences (psychology, sociology)

- More experimental literary techniques

- Blending with other genres became more common

The Modern Situation:

- "Science fiction" now often serves as a marketing label for any story with futuristic or technological elements

image source

 - Many "science fiction" films like "Alien" or "Event Horizon" are essentially horror films with technological settings

- The educational and optimistic aspects Gernsback valued are often absent

- Scientific accuracy is frequently sacrificed for dramatic effect

- Fear of technology often overshadows wonder about its possibilities

Key Factors in This Evolution:

- Cultural anxieties about technological change

- Commercial pressures favoring action and horror elements

- Visual media (especially film) emphasizing spectacle over scientific detail

- Broader cultural shift from optimism to skepticism about technological progress

- Blurring of genre boundaries in modern storytelling

Would you like me to explore any particular aspect of this evolution in more detail? For instance, we could examine specific works that marked important turning points in how the genre was defined and perceived.

Horror Stories

 Me: Claude, discuss use of the label "science fiction" in the context of horror movies like "Alien" as an example of cultural appropriation. Develop a hypothesis that the popularity of science fiction as a literary genre led to horror film makers using the label "science fiction" as a way to attract an audience to their horror movies. Discuss why such a use of the label "science fiction" can be offensive to fans of science fiction as originally defined and developed as a literary genre by Gernsback.

Claude: This is an insightful analysis of how the "science fiction" label has been appropriated from its original literary community. Here's an exploration of this cultural appropriation:

Original Cultural Context:

- Science fiction emerged as a distinct literary genre with its own community values

- Central focus was scientific wonder and rational exploration

- Built around an ethos of human progress and problem-solving

- Developed its own traditions, conventions, and cultural expectations

- Created a community of readers and writers sharing these values

The Appropriation Process:

1. Commercial Exploitation

- Horror filmmakers recognized the growing popularity of science fiction

- Used "science fiction" label to tap into an established audience

- Borrowed surface elements (spaceships, aliens) while discarding core values

- Prioritized commercial appeal over respect for the genre's traditions

 2. Dilution of Original Meaning

- Core emphasis on scientific wonder replaced by fear and revulsion

- Educational/inspirational aspects eliminated

- Scientific accuracy sacrificed for shock value

- Rational problem-solving replaced by survival horror

Why This Can Be Offensive:

1. Misrepresentation of Cultural Values

- Films like "Alien" subvert the genre's original optimistic vision

- Science becomes source of danger rather than wonder

- Presents technology as inherently threatening

- Contradicts Gernsback's educational mission

2. Community Impact

- Dilutes public understanding of what science fiction means

- Makes it harder for traditional science fiction to find its audience

- Can alienate young people from scientific careers

- Undermines the genre's ability to inspire and educate

Bicentennial Man (image source)

 3. Historical Erasure

- Original meaning of "science fiction" becomes lost

- Gernsback's vision gets overshadowed

- Literary tradition gets conflated with horror traditions

- Cultural heritage of the genre becomes obscured

This appropriation particularly stings because:

- It exploits the cultural capital built by decades of literary science fiction

- It profits from subverting the very values that made the genre successful

- It can feel like a betrayal of the genre's educational mission

- It represents a form of cultural colonization by the horror genre

The situation is complicated because:

- Genre boundaries naturally evolve over time

- Some hybrid works genuinely explore both horror and scientific themes

- Many fans enjoy both traditional science fiction and science horror

- The term has acquired multiple legitimate meanings through usage

However, the core issue remains that commercial interests have appropriated and transformed a label that originally represented a specific cultural and literary tradition, potentially diminishing its ability to serve its original purpose of inspiring scientific wonder and rational thinking.

Rational Wonder

Would you like to explore any particular aspect of this cultural appropriation further? For instance, we could examine specific examples of how the meaning of "science fiction" has been transformed in different media contexts.

Me: Claude, suggest a new name for the "science fiction" literary genre that is both 1) appropriate for this current millennium and 2) suggestive of the original Gernsback meaning of "science fiction". This new name could conceivably be welcomed by fans of science fiction who feel that the term "science fiction" has been perverted and appropriated by people who have never actually read any "real" science fiction stories.

Claude: A new genre name that could recapture Gernsback's original vision: "Rational Wonder Fiction" or "RW Fiction".

Advantages: 1) "Rational" emphasizes the scientific/logical foundation, "Wonder" captures the sense of amazement and possibility, 2) Directly references the "sense of wonder" beloved by traditional fans, 4) Hard to appropriate for horror purposes.  "Rational Wonder Fiction" captures the essence of what Gernsback envisioned while being distinctive enough to resist appropriation. The term explicitly combines the rational/scientific foundation with the sense of wonder that characterizes the genre's best works. The phrase "I'm reading some great RW fiction" could become a clear signal that someone is engaging with the genre in its original spirit rather than its horror-influenced derivatives.

Next: chronoendosymbionic mind transfer.

The Notionator. Visit the Gallery of Movies, Book and Magazine Covers