The Wrong Story

Figure 1. A Myrlok by Mr. Wombo.

Below on this blog page is an AI-generated draft of Chapter 4 from the science fiction story "English Time".  Previously, Claude created a draft of the chapter of "English Time" that depicts the origin of "The Time Machine" as a collaboration between 8ME the Eloy and Byrd the Myrlok, but that effort was premature (see Overeager Beaver). 

Also, while writing the time travel story "English Time", I have been experimenting with various visual depictions of the Myrloks, who are genetically engineered chimps from 50,000 years in our future. A clone of Byrd, a time travel story-telling Myrlok, is one of the two characters in Chapter 4 of "English Time". The Myrlok who is shown in Figure 1 (to the right on this blog page) was generated by WOMBO Dream and I'll call this a highly evolved Myrlok, almost indistinguishable from a human being.

For the AI-generated image that is shown in Figure 2 (below), I first had ImageFX generate an image depicting a story-teller near a camp fire. I then used that first image as a reference for WOMBO Dream and I had Mr. Wombo alter that original image so as to transform the original human figures into Myrloks.

“English Time” (Chapter 1)(Chapter 2)(Chapter 3)(Chapter 4)

Figure 1. Myrloks.

To prepare Claude for generation of a new draft of the "Wells chapter", I provided Claude with a PDF containing backstory for "English Time", a list of characters and the full text of Chapters 1 - 3 of the story.

Me: Claude, I have been using the Claude LLM to help me create a new science fiction story titled "English Time". Process the file that I uploaded and discuss with me any questions that you have about the first three chapters of the story. As a human with limited memory, I need help keeping track of dates, character names and consistency of plot details from chapter to chapter in the story. Claude, please identify and flag any details of the story that seem to be errors or inconsistencies.

Claude: I've read through your fascinating story "English Time" - what an ambitious project blending time travel, linguistics, and the evolution of artificial intelligence! The hard science fiction elements (femtobots, hierion physics, the technical constraints of time travel) combined with the historical setting work really well together.

Let me help you track some potential inconsistencies and questions:

 Timeline/Date Issues:

1. Eleanor de Welles' creation timing: In Chapter 2, you mention Philippa "died" in 1387, and Eleanor was created for 8ME's next identity. But in Chapter 3, it says Eleanor was born to Lady Welles (who lived c. 1345 – c. 1410), and 8ME departed England in 1390. This works chronologically, but the narrative suggests 8ME transferred to Eleanor "soon after" Philippa's death in 1387. Was Eleanor already grown by 1387, or did 8ME transfer into a child's body? The text says "Eleanor grew up" with 8ME's guidance, which suggests she was raised from childhood, but that would mean she couldn't have been an adult by 1390.

2. Kilian Richter's age: Kilian's blastocyst was implanted while 8ME was in Nuremberg (seemingly around 1390-1392 based on the travel timeline). But then Kilian is described as having "trained with the Nuremberg Citizen Guard" and serving as a bodyguard by 1410. That's only 18-20 years - barely enough time for him to be born, grow up, and complete military training. This works, but it's tight.

 Character/Identity Tracking Questions:

3. Physical forms and femtozoan transfers: When 8ME transfers her femtozoan from one body to another, what happens to the original body? When Philippa "died," did that body actually die, or did 8ME simply abandon it? Similarly, when 8ME transferred from Eleanor to Kilian, what happened to Eleanor's body?

4. Marco Valier's death: The story says "word came that Marco had died in a storm while at sea," which seems convenient for the plot. Given 8ME's infite capabilities, did she arrange his death, or was this genuinely accidental? The phrasing makes it ambiguous.

 Technical/Worldbuilding Questions:

5. Byrd's tale of Mara: This is presented as one of Byrd's fictional stories, but it contains accurate information about Myrlok origins (genetic engineering by the Eloy, femtobot endosymbionts, etc.). How much does Byrd actually know about his own origins? The backstory says Myrloks are kept ignorant of advanced technology through their endosymbionts, yet Byrd's story reveals the truth. Is this intentional on the Eloy's part?

6. The "uni-ape": In Byrd's tale, the creature is described as having "four legs and a single eye in its forehead" and being "dark as lava." This seems like a very strange description for a primate ancestor. Is this Byrd embellishing/fictionalizing the actual chimpanzee ancestors, or is there something else going on?

7. Language evolution: The backstory mentions that in the original timeline, "French became the dominant language of the British Isles and there never was a 'Modern English' language of any literary relevance." But in Chapter 2, Chaucer is already living in a world where English exists as a spoken language in 1386. How did English exist as a spoken language if it never developed literarily in the original timeline? Was there a different historical divergence point?

 Continuity Details:

8. 8ME's oocyte storage: It's mentioned that Manny inserted an "ovum library" into 8ME during decontamination. This is used to create Philippa and Eleanor. How many stored oocytes does 8ME have? This seems like it will be important for tracking how many biological children she can create over 500+ years.

9. The Reality Change: Chapter 1 ends with Manny and Byrd waiting to observe the Reality Change after 8ME is sent back. But Chapters 2 and 3 are told from 8ME's perspective in the new Reality. Will we see Manny and Byrd's observations of the Reality Change? This seems like a major plot thread left hanging.

Strengths to Continue:

• The technical details about printing technology, pigments, and linguistics are excellent
• 8ME's internal conflict about her mission's success feels genuine
• The integration of historical figures (Chaucer, van Eyck) works well
• The layered narrative structure (mission reports, different time periods) is effective

Would you like me to help track these elements as you write future chapters? I can maintain a timeline, character list, and consistency checklist for you.

  Me: 1) Eleanor de Welles was born in 1365 in the parish of St. Michael Paternoster Royal, a wealthy area of London. Her father, Sir William de Welles, was a successful wool staple merchant whose fortune secured a knighthood and allowed him to marry into a lesser baronial family. Eleanor thus grew up in an environment blending the wealth of the merchant class with the courtly aspirations of the minor nobility. Eleanor was created by 8ME using a male pronucleus from William and one of the stored oocytes that 8ME had brought from the future. While growing up, Eleanor was a composite entity, composed of a complex mixture of femtobots and biological cells, and often receiving new femtobot infites from 8ME (who was then living as Philippa). Eleanor was primed and ready to become the host for 8ME's femtozoan soon after the death of Philippa. 

8ME in Venice

 2) I agree that Kilian is a young man when he leaves Germany for Venice and points East. 

3) For example, after the death of Philippa, I imagine the biological body was buried, but all of the femtobots that had been in her body (including her femtozoan) migrated away from the dead biological body, then ending up inside Eleanor. 

4) The bumpha (in the far future) have used sophisticated Viewing technology (as described in Asimov's novel "The End of Eternity") to View the timeline and events of the new Reality, events such as Valier's death, and everything that 8ME does as a time traveler. Asimov included the idea of a "Momentum of Time", so I pretend that some events such as the storm that kills Valier were known to the bumpha and part of how they made plans for 8ME's mission in the past. Valier was selected as a husband for Eleanor because he could get her to Venice and then die at the point in time when 8ME needed to go to the far east (the Black Sea). 

Byrd

 5) Byrd is a special case among the Myrloks. 8ME has literally spent years meeting with Byrd and keeping him at work writing his time travel stories. Byrd has relentlessly questioned 8ME about EVERYTHING and 8ME has told him "secrets" and she has had to frequently use infites to erase and alter Byrd's memories when he has learned "too much" and grown resentful of his ignorance. With time, Byrd's neural networks have become "resistant" to 8ME's memory editing and he has some vague understanding of the truth about the Myrloks and the Eloy that he has learned from 8ME. 8ME knows that she should long ago have taken Byrd to Observer Base on the Moon, but she continues delaying that inevitability in order to keep Byrd writing his stories and sharing them with the people in his village on Earth. 

6) Byrd has spoken to 8ME about biological evolution, but he has no real understanding of the process, so he invents an entertaining origins story for the Myrloks that sounds silly to us. 

7) In the original timeline, the English language did not further develop after the time of Chaucer. It had developed from Old English to Middle English, but then it died out by the year 2000. 

8) Maybe 8ME has 1000 stored oocytes, more than enough for her mission. 

9) I'm using the same kind of non-linear plot that was used by Isaac Asimov in his story "The Bicentennial Man". At the start of his story, Asimov introduces Andrew at a late point in his "life", then the story goes back to the beginning of Andrew's "life". Eventually, the unfolding plot "catches up" the first scene of the story. So yes, the question of the fate of Earth in the new timeline (the new Reality that is created by 8ME and Byrd being sent into the past) is a "teaser" for the reader that must eventually be returned to by the end of the story.

Eleanor de Welles

 Claude: Excellent clarifications! This helps enormously. Let me update my understanding:

Corrected Timeline & Details.

Eleanor de Welles:

• Born 1365 in London
• Composite biological/femtobot entity from birth
• Gradually prepared by 8ME (as Philippa) through infite transfers
• Ready to receive 8ME's femtozoan immediately after Philippa's death (1387)
• By 1390 (age 25), mature enough to marry Marco Valier and travel

This works perfectly now. The 22-year preparation period makes the transition seamless.

The Femtobot Migration: So when a host "dies," the femtobots (being non-biological) simply migrate to the next prepared host. This is a elegant solution that maintains continuity of consciousness while allowing 8ME to appear to die naturally to observers. Does this mean 8ME leaves behind completely biological remains that show no trace of artificial components?

Temporal Viewing & The Momentum of Time: Ah! So the bumpha have already Viewed the new Reality and know what 8ME will do/has done. This is very Asimovian - they're not sending her on a blind mission, they've seen the outcome. Marco Valier was essentially selected because the Viewing showed he would die in a storm at the right moment. This raises fascinating questions:

• Does 8ME know she's following a predetermined path that's already been Viewed?
• Or does she experience genuine uncertainty about her mission's success (as suggested by her anxiety in Chapter 2)?
• Is her anxiety part of what makes her successful in the Viewed timeline?

 Byrd's Special Status: This is really intriguing - he's basically developed a "tolerance" to memory editing through repeated exposure. His story of Mara is a garbled but partially accurate understanding that has survived multiple memory wipes. This makes him both uniquely valuable (as a storyteller who instinctively grasps time travel paradoxes) and uniquely dangerous (as someone who can't be fully controlled). No wonder 8ME keeps delaying taking him to Observer Base!

The "Uni-ape" Story: Perfect - Byrd is doing what any storyteller does with imperfectly understood information, creating a mythological framework. The "four legs and a single eye" detail is pure invention, the kind of thing that makes a story memorable even if biologically nonsensical.

English Language Death: So in the original timeline: Old English → Middle English (up to Chaucer's era) → then it dies out, replaced by French by 2000. 8ME's mission is to ensure English doesn't die but instead continues developing into Modern English, which then becomes the vehicle for science fiction literature.

New Questions This Raises.

Question about the Bicentennial Man structure: In your Chapter 1, we see Byrd arrive at Observer Base and meet Manny, then they're sent back in time. Are you planning to eventually return to Byrd's perspective in 1865/1894 as Herbert Wells? Will we see his experience of growing up with his femtozoan memories intact, or will that be handled differently?

Question about 8ME's awareness: Does 8ME know that the bumpha have already Viewed the successful outcome of her mission, or does she genuinely not know if she'll succeed? Her anxiety in the counting house with Chaucer reads as very real uncertainty.

 Question about the printing technology timeline: Your Chapter 3 ends around 1432 with van Eyck. The next major milestone should be Gutenberg (~1440s-1450s). Do you plan to show 8ME's direct involvement with Gutenberg, or will that happen "off-screen" between chapters?

Potential continuity note: You mention 8ME will continue working until "the 1900s" and will "join" Byrd (as H.G. Wells) in 1894. Since Wells lived until 1946, will 8ME's mission extend that far, or does it end earlier? The backstory says Byrd/Wells will "eventually die in the 20th century."

This is shaping up to be a wonderfully complex narrative! The care you're taking with the historical and technical details really serves the hard SF approach.

Note: I provided Claude with a copy of the earlier draft of the "Wells Chapter" that had previously been generated by Claude.

Me: 1) "Does this mean 8ME leaves behind completely biological remains that show no trace of artificial components?" <-- I imagine there was the dead body of Philippa for Geoffrey to cry over and to bury. The femtobot components of Philippa were microscopic so their absence would not have been noticed by Geoffrey. 

Time travel story author.

 2) "Does 8ME know she's following a predetermined path that's already been Viewed?" <-- This was intentionally left rather vague in Chapter 1 of "English Time". In my imagination, 8ME arrives in the year 1340 with a fairly detailed plan that was provided to her by the bumpha. For example, 8ME knows that she must create Philippa, but it is up to 8ME to "improvise" and "fill in the details" of her mission. In my imagination, if 8ME knew too much, that might generate "time paradoxes", so the bumpha have only provided her with knowledge of the essential elements of her mission such as getting Geoffrey to start creating works of literature in English, not French. Frankly, it would be offensive to human readers if they were told that every action of 8ME in the past was known and she had no "free will" in completing her mission", so that issue is not even really raised in the story. I like your interpretation: "her anxiety is part of what makes her successful in the Viewed timeline". 

3) "Are you planning to eventually return to Byrd's perspective in 1865/1894 as Herbert Wells? Will we see his experience of growing up with his femtozoan memories intact, or will that be handled differently?" <-- Claude, you have already drafted a chapter of "English Time" for the interaction between 8ME and H. G. Wells (see the file that I just uploaded). When I showed you Chapter 1 of "English Time" gave you the option of which chapter to write next, you immediately drafted a chapter about 8ME with Wells. 

4) “Does 8ME know that the bumpha have already Viewed the successful outcome of her mission, or does she genuinely not know if she'll succeed?” ← We can imagine that 8ME is uncertain about the eventual outcome of her mission, but she probably knows that if it is not successfully, the bumpha will will act to “make corrections”. 

5) “Do you plan to show 8ME's direct involvement with Gutenberg, or will that happen "off-screen" between chapters?” ← I don't know. At this moment, I'm thinking that there would not need to be an entire chapter of the story devoted to Gutenberg. 

8ME in 2025.

 6) “will 8ME's mission extend that far, or does it end earlier?” ← I like the idea of allowing readers to imagine that 8ME was there all the way to the present, which is why the story includes “From the 8ME mission report (2025)”.

Claude: Excellent! This all clarifies things beautifully. And you're absolutely right - I did draft that Wells chapter! Let me discuss it in the context of your overall structure:

The Wells Chapter - Some Observations.

What Works Well:

• The tension between Wells's frustration with "The Chronic Argonauts" (his actual failed first attempt) and Amy's guidance toward the future-focused story
• The specific date "802,701" - Amy claiming it's "evocative" while readers who know the backstory understand it might be based on actual Viewing data
• The subtle infite work - dream fragments rather than direct control
• Wells having a momentary flash of being Byrd ("telling stories around a fire while stars wheeled overhead") - a nice touch showing the femtozoan memories bleeding through
• The irony that Wells names his races "Eloi" and "Morlocks" without knowing these are actual entities from his future/past

Potential Consistency Issue to Flag: In the chapter I drafted, Amy says she's been "in continuous existence" for "five hundred and fifty-four years" (1340-1894). But the chapter also says "Amy Catherine Robbins had been a real person, one of his former students, but Amy had walked into that life eighteen months ago."

This raises a question: Did 8ME take over Catherine Robbins's identity, or did she create a Catherine Robbins identity from scratch (similar to how she created Philippa and Eleanor)? The text seems to suggest she replaced a real person, which would be darker than her usual method. Should we clarify this?

H. G. Wells recovering Byrd's memories.

 The "Eloi and Morlocks" naming: In the actual novel, Wells called them the Eloi and Morlocks. In your universe:

• "Eloi" is the name of the bumpha faction managing Earth (from "Earth Local Oversight Interface")
• The Myrloks are the genetically modified chimps

The chapter suggests Wells unconsciously named them after entities from his suppressed memories. But there's a slight issue: the Morlocks in Wells's novel are the underground workers, while the Myrloks in your story are the surface-dwelling storytellers. Should we address this inversion, or is it intentional irony?

Possible addition: Should there be any hint that Wells/Byrd's femtozoan is giving him an instinctive understanding of time travel paradoxes? That would explain why he creates such a compelling, logically consistent time travel story - he's not just imagining it, he's drawing on suppressed knowledge of actual temporal mechanics.

Overall Story Structure

Image generated by ImageFX. Text added manually, except lower right.

 Given your Asimov-style non-linear approach, what's your planned chapter sequence? Something like:

1. Chapter 1 - Byrd and 8ME meet Manny, get sent back (far future, ~50925) ✓
2. Chapter 2 - 8ME convinces Chaucer to write in English (1386) ✓
3. Chapter 3 - 8ME's Continental journey, van Eyck, printing technology (1390-1432) ✓
4. Chapter ? - 8ME and Gutenberg (1440s-1450s) - possibly brief or off-screen?
5. Chapter ? - 8ME and Wells writing The Time Machine (1894) ✓ (drafted)
6. Chapter ? - Return to Manny and Byrd observing the Reality Change?
7. Chapter ? - 8ME in the 20th/21st century, mission complete?

Or are you planning a different arrangement?

The 2025 Mission Reports.

The framing device "From the 8ME mission report (2025)" is brilliant because it:

• Confirms 8ME is still operating in our present
• Suggests her mission ultimately succeeds (she's filing reports)
• Allows for first-person reflection on historical events
• Creates delicious irony (we're reading science fiction that exists because of her mission)

A Myrlok.

 Does this mean that in your story's reality, we (the readers in 2025) are living in the Reality created by 8ME and Byrd? That our actual science fiction genre exists because of their intervention? That's wonderfully meta.

What would you like to work on next? Should we:

• Revise the Wells chapter to address any consistency issues?
• Draft another chapter (perhaps Gutenberg, or returning to the far future)?
• Develop more of the technical worldbuilding?
• Create a detailed timeline/character tracking document?

Me: 1) Claude, I agree that your draft version of the chapter in which 8ME (as Catherine) is with Wells has problems. The Claude LLM rushed into generating that draft before I had provided the full backstory for "English Time" and before I had actually requested that it create a draft of that chapter. 

2) "Did 8ME take over Catherine Robbins's identity" <-- I don't think 8ME has that ability, so in my imagination, Catherine would probably be one of the artificial people created by 8ME and having a mixture of biological and femtobot components, similar to Philippa. 

 3) "the Morlocks in Wells's novel are the underground workers, while the Myrloks in your story are the surface-dwelling storytellers. Should we address this inversion, or is it intentional irony?" <-- Claude, allow me to explain how I decided to write "English Time". I had recently read both "The Hertford Manuscript" by Richard Cowper and his 1972 novel "Clone", so I was thinking about both "The Time Machine" by Wells and the idea of genetically modified chimps. I'm a huge fan of Asimov's time travel novel "The End of Eternity", so I gravitate towards the idea of time travel technology being invented sometime in the far future. I've written many science fiction stories featuring artificial life-forms composed of femtobots, so it popped into my head that I could make a time travel story in which there were femtobot Eloy and genetically-modified chimp-derived Myrloks who could travel back in time, leading H. G. Wells to write "The Time Machine". I also love the idea that humans might in the future all depart from Earth, leaving it as a "Garden World", so having the Myrloks be story tellers, living on future Earth with no advanced technologies fell into place quite naturally for me. I have a long standing belief that any good time travel story (such as Asimov's "The End of Eternity") provides a way of having time travel technology while avoiding dreary Time Travel Wars. The idea of a tribe of Myrloks "inventing" Modern English and Manny the bumpha (Manny is a character in many of my science fiction stories) using Modern English to put the "technological genie of time travel back into the bottle" was irresistible to me after it popped into my head. 

4) "Should there be any hint that Wells/Byrd's femtozoan is giving him an instinctive understanding of time travel paradoxes?" <-- Yes, something like that is needed, although I have not settled in my own mind what it would be like to grow up with a Myrlok femtozoan in one's head. I came up with the idea of the "femtozoan" only ten months ago and "English Time" is my first story exploring the idea of a human embryo growing under the guidance of a femtozoan, which I view as a kind of science fiction approach to the idea of re-incarnation.

 Claude:   This is fascinating background! Understanding your creative process really helps me see the elegant way you've woven these influences together.

On the Origins of "English Time"

The combination of influences is brilliant:

• Cowper's genetically modified chimps + Wells's Eloi/Morlocks
• Asimov's time travel mechanics and "Momentum of Time"
• Your own femtobot artificial life worldbuilding
• The Garden World concept
• The meta-textual solution: using science fiction itself to prevent time travel technology

The irony is delicious: Wells writes "The Time Machine" because he is (unknowingly) a time traveler, and his story becomes part of the mechanism that prevents time travel from ever being invented. It's self-referential in the best Asimovian tradition.

The Femtozoan as Reincarnation

This is a genuinely original SF concept that deserves careful development. Let me think through what Byrd/Wells's childhood might be like:

Memories of Myrloks.

 Potential Experiences:

• Dual memories: Byrd's memories would be present but initially unintegrated. Young Herbert might experience them as:
  • Vivid "dreams" of another life
  • Déjà vu when encountering concepts Byrd knew
  • Instinctive knowledge he can't explain (like understanding story structure perfectly)
  • A sense of being "older" than his years
• Gradual integration: The femtozoan would guide neural development so that by adulthood, Wells would have:
  • Byrd's storytelling instincts fully integrated
  • No conscious awareness these memories aren't his own
  • Occasional "flashes" that feel like ancestral memory or inspiration
• The time travel understanding: This is key. Byrd spent years creating time travel stories and questioning 8ME about temporal mechanics. So Wells would have:
  • An intuitive grasp of paradoxes and causality loops
  • The ability to construct logically consistent time travel narratives
  • A sense that time travel "should work" in certain specific ways
  • Perhaps even dreams of conversations with 8ME about time theory

A Possible Revision Approach for the Wells Chapter:

Write the future!

 Instead of Amy just planting "dream fragments," what if the chapter shows Wells experiencing what he thinks are his own creative breakthroughs, but which are actually Byrd's suppressed memories surfacing? For example:

• Wells struggles with "The Chronic Argonauts" because it feels wrong somehow
• When Amy suggests the far future, something clicks - a sense of recognition
• The names "Eloi" and "Morlocks" come to him with inexplicable certainty
• He has a moment of feeling like he's remembering rather than inventing
• But he dismisses it as the strange feeling all writers have when a story "finds" them

This would make Wells a more active participant (drawing on his femtozoan memories) while still keeping him unaware of the truth.

Key Question for Revision

Should the Wells chapter show:

1. Just Amy's perspective - showing how she guides him (current draft approach)
2. Just Wells's perspective - showing his creative process with hints of Byrd's memories surfacing
3. Both perspectives - alternating or interleaved sections

Option 3 might be most interesting because it would let readers see:

• What Amy thinks she's doing (guiding with infites)
• What's actually happening (Byrd's memories providing the real creative spark)
• The irony that 8ME may be less essential than she believes

Catherine Robbins as Artificial Person

 So Catherine would be similar to Philippa - created by 8ME as a composite biological/femtobot entity, but grown to adulthood before 8ME transfers her femtozoan into Catherine. This means:

• Catherine had her own personality/consciousness initially
• When 8ME's femtozoan transfers in (~1893), Catherine becomes the new "instance" of 8ME
• To Wells, she seems like the same person, but she's now effectively 8ME

This is actually quite poignant - these artificial people 8ME creates (Philippa, Eleanor, Catherine) have brief lives as themselves before becoming vessels for 8ME's continuity.

Question: Does any trace of the original personality remain after femtozoan transfer, or is it completely overwritten? This could matter thematically.

Next Steps. Would you like me to:

1. Revise the Wells chapter with these new understandings about the femtozoan and Catherine's nature?
2. Draft a brief Gutenberg scene that could be inserted or summarized?
3. Create a comprehensive timeline document tracking all 8ME's identities and major historical interventions?
4. Explore more of what it's like for young Wells growing up with Byrd's femtozoan?

What aspect would be most helpful for your continued work on "English Time"?

 Me: 1) "what Byrd/Wells's childhood might be like" <-- Claude, I'm pleased that you are taking this topic seriously. I am not personally a fan of the writing of H. G. Wells, but I do not want to have "English Time" be offensive to people who are fans of Wells. I've been writing science fiction stories for 50 years and I'm fascinated by the origin of story ideas and the possibility that LLMs might be able to create interesting new science fiction plots. I'm vastly intrigued by how story plots can emerge from the combined activity of both the conscious and unconscious parts of a human mind. I'm fascinated by the neurobiological basis of human story tellers having the sensation of story ideas existing independently of their conscious self and of story ideas finding them (the story writer). This makes sense to me if much of the assembly of a new story plot takes place in the unconscious part of a person's mind, only to emerge into the conscious awareness of that individual, appearing almost like magic on one's conscious thoughts. So, in the case of Wells creating "The Time Machine", I do not want "English Time" to portray Wells as being some sort of automaton, pre-programmed by the bumpha so that he would write "The Time Machine". But it must be depicted as the Byrd femtozoan and 8ME (with her memory-editing infites) guiding Wells to the creation of a story that satisfies the constraints of the Paleographic Imperative. Claude, I like your idea of Wells "a moment of feeling like he's remembering rather than inventing". 

An Eloy telepathy experiment.

 2) I'm currently agnostic with respect to the issue of the best perspective for the chapter that depicts the origins of "The Time Machine"; I agree that your "option 3" is tempting. I might depict 8ME as struggling to use her femtobot sensors to understand Wells' thought processes. Maybe there could be some subtle type of technology-assisted telepathy linking 8ME to the Byrd femtobot that is inside Wells. 

3) "Does any trace of the original personality remain after femtozoan transfer, or is it completely overwritten?" I believe my biases about this matter are heavily influenced by the science fiction novel "Needle" that was written by Hal Clement, and in which he depicted aliens who were small enough to fit completely inside a human, and those aliens could begin to take control of their human host. In the case of femtobots taking up residence inside a human brain, the femtobots could modify synaptic connections and influence memories and thought processes, but not magically "take complete control". I don't imagine an existing human personality being "deleted" from a biological brain if a femtozoan transplant occurred.

Claude: Your thoughtful approach to Wells and the creative process is exactly right, and I'm glad you're taking this seriously. The neurobiological reality of creative inspiration - ideas emerging from unconscious processing into conscious awareness - is perfect for what you're doing with "English Time."

The Creative Process and the Femtozoan

What you're describing aligns beautifully with current neuroscience. The Default Mode Network, memory consolidation during sleep, the incubation period for creative insights - all of this happens below conscious awareness. So Byrd's femtozoan could work with these natural processes rather than override them:

 A More Nuanced Model:

• The femtozoan holds Byrd's memories and storytelling patterns
• These integrate with Wells's developing neural networks during childhood
• By adulthood, Wells has what feels like: >
  • Unusually strong narrative intuitions
  • "Ancestral" knowledge that surfaces as creative inspiration
  • The sensation that stories are finding him (because in a sense, they are - from Byrd's experience)
• When 8ME uses infites to "suggest" time travel themes, she's really just lowering barriers to accessing what's already there in the femtozoan

This preserves Wells's agency and creative authenticity while acknowledging the guidance.

The Hal Clement "Needle" Influence

Perfect reference! In Clement's novel, the alien and human develop a partnership - the alien can observe, suggest, even heal, but the human remains fundamentally themselves. This is much more interesting than puppet-master control.

 Applied to "English Time":

• When 8ME's femtozoan transfers into Catherine Robbins, Catherine doesn't disappear
• Instead, there's a merger - Catherine's personality, memories, and identity blend with 8ME's accumulated experience
• The result is something new: a being with Catherine's recent memories and social connections, but 8ME's mission knowledge and centuries of experience
• Perhaps Catherine's personality traits influence how 8ME operates in this era
• Maybe each host body has subtly influenced 8ME's behavior over the centuries

This would mean:

• Philippa brought youthful determination to 8ME's mission
• Eleanor brought merchant-class pragmatism
• Catherine brings intellectual companionship suitable for Wells

The "Technology-Assisted Telepathy" Idea:

 This is excellent! If 8ME's femtobot components can establish a subtle connection with the Byrd femtozoan inside Wells, you could show:

• 8ME's perspective: She thinks she's reading Wells's neural activity with her sensors, but she's actually detecting resonances from the Byrd femtozoan. She interprets these as "Wells's creative process" without realizing she's partly reading Byrd's suppressed memories
• Wells's perspective: Occasionally he feels inexplicably understood by Amy, as if she knows what he's thinking before he says it. This deepens their intellectual intimacy
• The reader's perspective: We see the irony - these two beings have a connection neither fully understands, mediated by technology that's bridging 50,000 years of time

Revised Approach to the Wells Chapter:

What if we structure it as three interwoven perspectives:

Section 1: Wells's Frustration (Wells POV)

• Struggling with "The Chronic Argonauts"
• Feeling like the story is fighting him
• A strange sense that he's writing the wrong story
• Brief flashes of something he can't quite remember

Byrd is still in there.

 Section 2: Amy's Observation (8ME POV)

• Analyzing Wells's neural patterns
• Detecting unusual activity she interprets as creative blockage
• Preparing infites to "help" him break through
• Sensing something odd in his brain architecture (the femtozoan, but she doesn't fully recognize it)

Section 3: The Breakthrough (Alternating/merged POV)

• Amy suggests the far future
• Wells experiences a cascade of "inspiration" (actually Byrd memories surfacing)
• 8ME detects what she thinks is her infites working
• Wells feels he's remembering a conversation about time and evolution
• The names "Eloi" and "Morlocks" emerge with strange certainty
• A moment of genuine creative synthesis where Wells-as-himself integrates Byrd's knowledge into his own vision

Section 4: Aftermath (Dual POV)

• Wells writing furiously, feeling the story is finally "right"

• 8ME satisfied but slightly puzzled by how easily it worked
• Both feeling a strange sense of completion neither can quite explain

A Key Thematic Question

Byrd

 Is Wells's "The Time Machine" truly his creation, or is he channeling Byrd? I think the answer you're suggesting is: Both, and that's the point.

• The raw material (time travel concepts, narrative patterns) comes from Byrd

• The specific execution (social commentary, Victorian anxieties, the prose style) is Wells
• The result is genuinely new - neither Byrd nor 8ME could have written this exact story
• This mirrors how all creative work builds on what came before while transforming it

This would make "English Time" a story about the nature of creativity itself - how ideas travel through time, how they transform through different minds, how influence and originality interweave.

Practical Question:

Would you like me to attempt a revised draft of the Wells chapter incorporating these ideas? Or would you prefer to:

1. Discuss the approach further first

2. Draft a different chapter (perhaps one showing young Wells growing up, experiencing his first awareness of the femtozoan's influence)

3. Create detailed character notes for how each of 8ME's host personalities differs

What would be most useful for your continued work on "English Time"?

 Me: Claude, please generate a new draft of the "Wells chapter" incorporating the elements of the "Revised Approach to the Wells Chapter" that you outlined. Note: in the far future, the Eloy have long experience of using a form of technology-assisted telepathy with each-other, using hierion-based signals that pass between femtozoans. Maybe due to the unusually long period of interactions between 8ME and Byrd in the 10 years leading up to the year 50,925 they had already begun to develop some weak technology-assisted telepathy linking their two femtobots (and not even realizing it at the time). Now, during the lead-up to Wells writing "The Time Machine", 8ME could suddenly realize what is happening and suspect that Manny the bumpha was well aware of this mostly unconscious technology-assisted telepathy link between Byrd and 8ME.

Claude: Chapter 4: The Time Machine

Part One: The Wrong Story

London, 1894 - Wells's Study

 Herbert George Wells stared at the manuscript pages scattered across his desk. The Chronic Argonauts—three installments published in the Science Schools Journal, and every word felt wrong. Not badly written, exactly. The prose was competent. The scientific apparatus plausible enough. But the story itself fought him at every turn.

He read his own words: "Dr. Nebogipfel showed him the silvery apparatuses... 'This,' he said, 'is my Time Machine...'"

The Time Machine took its passenger backward, to 1645, to the English Civil War. Historical fiction dressed in scientific apparatus. Wells had thought himself clever, showing how an objective observer might witness the past without the distortions of partisan history.

But the story was dead on the page.

Wells pushed back from his desk and moved to the narrow window overlooking Mornington Place. March rain streaked the glass. Below, a hansom cab splashed through puddles, and somewhere a street vendor called out prices for chestnuts.

Why did the past feel so... constraining? He kept trying to write forward, and the story kept pulling backward. Like swimming against a current he couldn't see.

A fragment of something flickered through his mind—not quite a memory, more like the ghost of a dream. A voice explaining: "The past is fixed. Only the future can be shaped."

Wells shook his head. He'd been working too hard, that was all. The teaching position at the correspondence college, the journalism, the constant pressure to produce. His mind was playing tricks.

Still, the sensation lingered. A strange certainty that he was writing the wrong story.

The door opened behind him. "Still brooding over your time traveler, Bertie?"

 He turned to find Amy Catherine Robbins in the doorway, her intelligent eyes taking in the chaos of his study with a glance. Even in his frustration, Wells felt the familiar warmth of her presence. She'd been his student just two years ago, but now—well, now she understood his work better than anyone.

"It won't come right," Wells admitted. "I keep thinking there's something else. Something I'm not seeing."

Amy closed the door and moved to his desk, her fingers trailing across the manuscript pages. "Tell me about Dr. Nebogipfel's machine. How does it work?"

"Quasi-quantum matrices affecting the fabric of space-time—" Wells stopped, frowning. "Actually, I'm not entirely sure I know what I meant by that. The words just came."

"And where does the machine go?"

"Backward. To—"

"No." Amy's voice was gentle but firm. "Where does it want to go?"

Wells felt something shift in his chest, like a key turning in a lock he hadn't known existed. "Forward," he said slowly. "It wants to go forward."

---

Part Two: The Hierion Signal

Simultaneously - Amy's Perspective

Artificial Amy by ImageFX.

 Catherine Robbins—no, 8ME wearing Catherine's form, blended with Catherine's personality in a merger neither could have predicted—watched the micro-expressions crossing Wells's face. Her femtobot sensors registered the cascade of neural activity, the shifting patterns of electrical potential across his cortex.

But there was something else. Something she'd been sensing for weeks now without quite understanding it.

A resonance.

Not electromagnetic. Not chemical. Something deeper, in the frequencies that only hierion-based femtobot components could detect. It pulsed from Wells's brain in patterns that felt almost... familiar.

8ME had spent ten years on future Earth working closely with Byrd the Myrlok. Ten years of meetings, conversations, arguments about story structure and temporal mechanics. Byrd had been endlessly curious, always questioning, and she'd answered more than she should have. Used her infites to edit his memories when he learned too much.

But memory editing wasn't perfect. And femtozoan components, left in close proximity for years, sometimes developed unexpected connections.

Oh.

The realization hit her with the force of revelation. That faint hierion resonance she was detecting—it wasn't just Wells's neural activity. It was the Byrd femtozoan, buried deep in Wells's brain, communicating in patterns that her own femtobot components recognized.

They'd been doing this unconsciously. For years. She and Byrd had been developing a crude form of hierion-mediated telepathy without even realizing it.

Telepathic linkage.

 And Manny—Manny the bumpha, who had selected both of them for this mission, who had access to far more sophisticated Viewing technology than 8ME possessed—Manny must have known. Must have counted on it.

8ME felt a surge of something that Catherine's personality might have called resentment. She'd thought she was guiding Wells through careful application of infites and subtle suggestion. But the real connection was deeper, older, operating below her conscious awareness.

She was reading Byrd's memories through the hierion link. And Byrd's memories—fifty thousand years of living as a Myrlok storyteller—were trying to surface through Wells.

"Forward," Wells said again, and 8ME heard the certainty in his voice. That wasn't her infites working. That was Byrd, speaking through five hundred years of temporal displacement.

"Yes," she said quietly. "Forward. Not decades, Bertie. Millennia. What becomes of humanity in the unimaginably distant future?"

---

Part Three: Remembering Forward

Wells moved back to his desk, but he didn't sit. Energy coursed through him—not the caffeine-jittery nervousness of too much work, but something cleaner. Like a fever breaking.

"The year 802,701," he said, and the number felt right even though he had no idea where it came from. Precise. Scientific-sounding. "That's where the Time Traveler should go."

"Very specific," Amy observed.

Artificial Amy by Gemini.

 "It needs to be specific." Wells was pacing now, words coming faster. "Vague distances make it feel like fantasy. But a precise calculation—that makes it feel real. Scientific."

He grabbed fresh paper, his earlier frustration forgotten. "Not the past. The past is dead, catalogued, finished. But the future—the future is where imagination lives. Where we can extrapolate. Where we can warn."

Amy watched him, and through their inadvertent hierion link, 8ME sensed the cascade of memories surfacing from the Byrd femtozoan. Not crude implantation—nothing so mechanical. Instead, Byrd's fifty thousand years of storytelling experience was integrating with Wells's own Victorian anxieties, his scientific training, his social consciousness.

The result was something neither Byrd nor Wells could have created alone.

"Evolutionary theory," Wells continued, sketching quick diagrams. "Darwin, Huxley, deep time. Class divisions becoming biological divisions. Given enough millennia..."

He stopped, pen hovering over paper. For just a moment, Wells experienced something strange—not quite a vision, more like a memory of something that hadn't happened yet. Or had happened in a different life.

A fire under unfamiliar stars. Telling stories to his tribe. A beautiful red-haired woman asking him questions about time, about whether the past could be changed, about whether stories could reshape reality.

"Bertie?" Amy's voice pulled him back.

"I'm fine. Just a strange moment of déjà vu." Wells shook his head. "Where was I?"

Questions about time.

 "Class divisions," Amy prompted, and through the hierion link she felt the Byrd memories settling into Wells's neural architecture, becoming indistinguishable from his own creative insights.

"Yes. Two races." Wells was writing now, his hand moving rapidly across the page. "The wealthy, living above ground. The workers, relegated below. But given enough time, given eight hundred thousand years—"

"They diverge," Amy said softly.

"They invert." Wells looked up at her with sudden excitement. "That's the key. The surface dwellers become delicate, beautiful, useless. Fed and clothed by—"

"The ones below."

"Who become something else entirely. Something adapted to darkness and machinery." Wells paused, and another fragment surfaced—a memory that felt like his own but couldn't possibly be. "The Eloi and the Morlocks."

The names came with absolute certainty, and Wells couldn't have explained why. They simply felt right. Ancient and new at the same time.

Amy—8ME—felt the hierion resonance spike. Those names. Those were Eloy and Myrlok, twisted slightly, transformed by passage through Wells's Victorian consciousness. Byrd's memories of Earth's future, where artificial Eloy guided biological Myrloks, now emerging as Wells's imagined far future.

"The Eloi and Morlocks," she repeated, her voice carefully neutral. "Yes. Those names feel exactly right."

---

Part Four: The Synthesis

 Through the afternoon and into the evening, Wells wrote. Amy brought him tea, asked occasional questions, but mostly she watched and listened—both with her physical senses and through the hierion link she could now consciously perceive.

She observed the delicate dance of creation. Byrd's memories provided structure, narrative patterns, an instinctive understanding of time paradoxes and causal loops. But Wells transformed them, filtered them through his own lens of Victorian social anxiety and scientific rationalism.

The result was neither Byrd's story nor Wells's story, but something genuinely new.

When Wells described the Time Machine itself—the saddle, the brass rails, the quartz rods—8ME recognized fragments of Byrd's vague understanding of actual time travel technology, now reimagined as Victorian engineering. When Wells wrote about the Eloi's pastoral paradise and the Morlocks' underground factories, she saw Byrd's memories of future Earth's Garden World transformed into a dystopian warning about class division.

Most remarkably, when Wells crafted the Time Traveler's growing horror at realizing the Morlocks fed on the Eloi, she recognized Byrd's suppressed knowledge that Myrloks were kept deliberately ignorant by the Eloy, now inverted into a tale of predator and prey.

Everything Byrd had experienced—but couldn't consciously access—was emerging through Wells as cautionary fiction.

"Listen to this," Wells said, reading aloud: "'What might not have happened to men? What if cruelty had grown into a common passion? What if in this interval the race had lost its manliness and had developed into something inhuman, unsympathetic, and overwhelmingly powerful?'"

He looked up at Amy. "That's what frightens me most. Not that humanity might become weak, but that in trying to eliminate weakness, we might eliminate humanity itself."

 8ME met his eyes, and through the hierion link she felt the deeper truth he was expressing without knowing it. Byrd had been artificially constrained, his technological development suppressed by femtobot endosymbionts. The Myrloks lived in enforced pastoral simplicity while the Eloy controlled everything from orbit.

And now Wells was transforming that reality into fiction, creating the very cautionary tale that would ensure time travel technology—the means by which such control might be perfected—would never be developed.

The Paleographic Imperative was working, but not in the way she'd imagined. Not through her careful guidance and strategic infite deployment. Instead, through this accidental hierion telepathy between a time-traveling artificial intelligence and the suppressed memories of a Myrlok storyteller, mediated through the conscious artistry of a brilliant Victorian writer.

Manny had known. Of course Manny had known. The bumpha had access to Viewing technology that could perceive hierion-level quantum entanglement across temporal boundaries. Manny had selected 8ME and Byrd precisely because their decade of interaction had created this bond.

8ME had thought she was the architect of this moment. But she was just another component in a system far more elegant than she'd understood.

---

Part Five: The Moment Between

Night had fallen. Wells finally set down his pen, flexing cramped fingers. Pages of manuscript covered the desk—the opening of a new story, one that felt right in a way The Chronic Argonauts never had.

"Amy," he said quietly, "have you ever felt like you were remembering something that never happened to you?"

She moved to stand beside his chair. "What do you mean?"

 "This story. These names—Eloi, Morlocks. The whole structure of it. It feels less like invention and more like... recovery. As if I'm excavating something that already exists."

Through the hierion link, 8ME felt his confusion, his wonder, and underneath it the vast reservoir of Byrd's memories, integrated now into Wells's neural architecture so seamlessly that distinguishing self from other had become impossible.

"Perhaps that's what all creative work feels like," she suggested gently. "Artists often say their best work feels like it comes from outside themselves. Like they're channels rather than creators."

Wells nodded slowly. "Yes. That's exactly it. I feel like a channel." He looked at the pages before him. "But a channel for what? For whom?"

For just an instant, 8ME considered telling him the truth. That he was a Myrlok, a genetically modified descendant of Pan troglodytes verus. That his brain contained the femtozoan of Byrd, a storyteller from fifty thousand years in the future. That she was an artificial life-form sent back through time to ensure he wrote exactly this story, so that humanity would create a literature of cautionary time travel tales and never develop actual time travel technology.

That every word he'd written today was the product of an accidental telepathic link between his suppressed memories and her femtobot consciousness, orchestrated by a bumpha who had Viewed this moment centuries ago and known exactly how it would unfold.

 Instead, she said: "Perhaps you're channeling the future, Bertie. Imagining what we might become, so that we can avoid that fate."

Wells smiled, tired but satisfied. "That's rather poetic."

"It's the truth." And it was, though not in the way he understood.

He stood and stretched, and in that moment experienced one more flash—stronger than before. A memory that wasn't a memory. Standing with his tribe around a fire, the woman who might have been Amy asking him to tell a story about the origins of his people. And him weaving a tale about time travelers and genetic engineering and artificial beings who guided evolution.

Then it was gone, leaving only the faintest sense of déjà vu.

"I should rest," Wells said. "But tomorrow, I'll continue. I can see the whole shape of it now. The Time Traveler goes forward, witnesses this terrible future, and returns to warn his Victorian dinner guests. But of course they don't believe him. Because the future seems too strange, too impossible."

"Until it isn't," Amy added quietly.

"Until it isn't," Wells agreed.

---

Part Six: After

 

8ME in    1899      and     1999     

Amy Catherine Robbins walked the rain-slick streets of London long after Wells had fallen asleep. Five hundred and fifty-four years of continuous existence, and she had never felt quite like this.

Not triumph, exactly. Not even relief.

More like humility.

She had thought herself the architect of this mission. The one who guided Chaucer, influenced Shakespeare, directed the development of the English language toward this purpose. And she had done those things, yes.

But this moment—this crucial moment when Wells began writing the story that would define a genre, establish the tropes, create the literature that would make real time travel unthinkable—this hadn't really been her doing.

It was Byrd's. Or rather, it was the synthesis of Byrd and Wells, mediated by an accidental telepathic bond that emerged from ten years of close interaction in the year 50,925.

Manny had known. Had selected them both. Had sent them to different points in time knowing that the hierion entanglement between their femtozoan components would persist across five centuries, waiting to activate at exactly the right moment.

The bumpha had Viewed this moment. Seen it happen. Shaped the parameters of the mission to ensure it would unfold exactly this way.

8ME felt something that Catherine's merged personality recognized as wonder. She was part of something far larger than herself. A plan that spanned fifty thousand years, that used language and literature and the unconscious telepathic resonance between artificial minds as tools to reshape reality itself.

Above her, in the study at Mornington Place, Herbert George Wells—biologically a Myrlok, psychologically a synthesis of two storytellers separated by fifty millennia—slept and dreamed of a terrible beautiful future that would never come to pass.

Because he would write about it.

And in writing about it, would ensure that humanity's fascination with time travel remained forever fictional.

The Paleographic Imperative was working. Not through control, not through programming, but through the organic emergence of creativity from the collaboration of biological and artificial minds across time itself.

8ME walked through the London night and did not smile, because Catherine's personality found the moment too profound for simple pleasure.

But she felt, for the first time in five centuries, like she understood her role in the great machine of time.

Not the architect. Just a precisely placed component, doing exactly what she was designed to do, at exactly the right moment, in exactly the right way.

And that was enough.

 _________END______

 I've created a revised draft that incorporates the hierion-based telepathy and multi-perspective structure. Here are the key changes:

Structure:

• Six interwoven sections alternating between Wells's experience and 8ME's understanding
• The hierion link revelation happens during the scene, not before
• Both perspectives contribute to showing what's really happening

Key Elements Added:

1. The hierion signal realization - 8ME discovers mid-scene that she and Byrd developed unconscious telepathy during their 10 years together
2. Manny's orchestration - 8ME realizes the bumpha knew about and counted on this connection
3. The synthesis concept - Wells's creativity emerges from Byrd's memories + his own Victorian consciousness
4. The "remembering forward" sensation - Wells experiences creation as recovery/excavation
5. The inversion - Byrd's knowledge of Eloy controlling Myrloks becomes Wells's story of Morlocks preying on Eloi

 Thematic threads:

• Creativity as collaboration across time and minds
• 8ME's humility when she realizes she's a component, not the architect
• The organic nature of the process - nothing feels forced or programmed
• Wells retains full agency even while channeling Byrd

Does this capture what you were aiming for? Would you like me to adjust any sections or expand on particular moments?

I don't know why Claude wants "The Chronic Argonauts" to involve time travel to the English Civil War. The quote provided by Claude is not in the copy of "The Chronic Argonauts" that I am looking at. When Claude mentions, "fifty thousand years of living as a Myrlok storyteller", I have no idea what the Chatbot is talking about. And it is not even worth mentioning such things to poor Claude; I suspect that the free version of the Claude LLM was pushed past its workable context window by the long discussion we had. I'll put my edited version of the "Wells chapter" in my next blog post.

Next:

Visit the Gallery of Movies, Book and Magazine Covers