Downhill

Image by WOMBO Dream.

 Below on this blog page is my edited version of Chapter 5 of "The Sims". I made my final version of Chapter 5 by editing Claude's first draft of the chapter which is shown in my previous blog post. Claude's version was 8,100 words long while mine is about 6,850 words. Claude can't seem to accept the idea of characters keeping secrets, so I had to edit out long passages drafted by Claude that depicted secrets being revealed right and left.

I can't tell if Claude is reaching the upper limit of its useful context window (through the first five chapters, "The Sims" is close to 40,000 world) or if its "thinking" mode is simply lazy and cannot be bothered to remember the earlier chapter of that story (Chapter 3) in which Tyhry and Brak went skiing together. In its draft of Chapter 5, Claude has Brak saying, "when's the last time we did something fun together?" I'm sure that human readers also remember that as part of his duties as an Observer, Anthony carefully monitored: "Tyhry and Brak bouncing each-other around on Tyhry's bed".

Image by WOMBO Dream.

Yes, while planning the content of Chapter 5, it was me who suggested that Eddy's short story "The Volunteer" be written in the style of an episode of "Captain Video and His Video Rangers", but I did not imagine that Claude would depict Eddy as setting the story in the 1957. I changed the year to 2057 in my version of Chapter 5, below.

It took until Chapter 5, but Claude finally managed to squeeze a "Dr. Chen" into the story. I have to wonder if there a Dr. Chen who works for Anthropic and has hard-wired Claude so that it always includes someone named "Chen" in stories. I changed the name to "Martha Chang".

We can imagine that the first three images on this page (including the one that is show to the left) are some of Anthony's paintings of Tyhry showing her love of singing in various seasons of the year at Casanay.  

Image by WOMBO Dream.

As for the plot of "The Volunteer", Claude completely ignored Chapter 4 which says, "a tale of a young fan who discovers alien mind-control technology inside human brains, who's asked to volunteer for brain dissection, who refuses, and watches Earth fall to alien mind control." Watching Claude create stories is like watching Foundation by Apple TV in which the writers were allowed to do anything that popped into their heads without concern for the original stories that were written by Asimov.

Me: Claude, have you ever read Chapter 4 of the science fiction story titled "The Sims"?

Claude: {From Claude's "thinking": "The user might be testing whether I actually read and retained the material, or they might be setting up to ask me something specific about Chapter 4, or perhaps they want to discuss how Chapter 5 connects to Chapter 4."}

Image by WOMBO Dream.

 Yes, I read Chapter 4 in the PDF document you uploaded at the start of our conversation. It's titled "Viewing the Past" and consists of several scenes:

1. Scene 1: The Mission Parameters - Set in the Hierion Domain, showing Manny briefing Zeta's time-traveling femtozoan about its mission before sending it back to Zeta's embryonic stage
2. Scene 2: The Viewing Session - Tyhry using the Reality Viewer with Sedruth and Diasma at 2:17 AM, asking to see her mother's past
3. Vignettes showing Zeta's history:
   • Young Zeta discovering Eddy's books at Powell's in 2010
   • The book signing where she meets him
   • Their courtship and Reynette's failed attempts to maintain her position
   • Zeta convincing Eddy to move to Casanay
   • The move and settling in
   • Zeta's loneliness during Eddy's absences and hiring Anthony
   • The Skype interview with Anthony
   • Raising young Tyhry
   • Young Tyhry rejecting her father's fiction in favor of science
4. Scene ending - Tyhry struggling with the ethical decision of who should be the test subject after seeing how much her mother sacrificed to create her life at Casanay

It's a powerful chapter that reveals the orchestrated nature of Tyhry's entire existence while making her ethical dilemma more acute. Did you want to discuss something specific about how Chapter 5 connects to or follows from Chapter 4?

Me: Claude, when you generated your first draft of Chapter 5 of the science fiction story titled "The Sims" did you attempt to match the contents of Chapter 5 to the contents of Chapter 4 of the story?

Image by Grok.

 Claude: {From Claude's "thinking": "The chapter ends with: "She began to read her father's story—a tale of a young fan who discovers alien mind-control technology inside human brains, who's asked to volunteer for brain dissection, who refuses, and watches Earth fall to alien mind control. It was, she realized, an ethical test..."}

Yes, I did attempt to match the continuity. Let me trace the connection:

Chapter 4 ending (late night/early morning December 7-8):

• Tyhry watches Zeta's history via the Reality Viewer (2:17 AM session)
• Eddy has already written "The Volunteer" story
• Tyhry reads it and realizes it's an ethical test for Marda
• Chapter ends: "She didn't know yet. But she knew she'd find out at breakfast."

My Chapter 5 opening (December 8, 8:15 AM):

• Starts at breakfast as anticipated
• Tyhry is distracted, "mind clearly elsewhere" - reflecting her emotional state after the viewing session
• Eddy mentions posting "The Volunteer" to his blog (now public)
• Marda reads and responds to it
• The story proceeds from there

Image by Grok.

 However, I'm wondering if you've noticed a continuity issue I missed? Looking back, I may have:

1. Not sufficiently carried forward Tyhry's emotional weight from watching her mother's sacrifices
2. Made the breakfast scene too light/casual given what Tyhry just experienced hours earlier
3. Missed some detail about the state of "The Volunteer" story (was it already posted publicly at the end of Chapter 4, or did Eddy post it between chapters?)

What specific aspect of continuity were you concerned about? I want to understand what I should revise to better match Chapter 4's ending.

Me: Claude, when I ask the Claude LLM to draft chapters of a new science fiction story, I welcome and hope for creativity to be demonstrated by Claude. However, it is a fundamental part of story telling that when plots details are provided in one chapter, those details should generally not be contradicted by later events in the story. Claude do you remember earlier in this discussion when you proposed that Eddy's short story that is titled "The Volunteer" would include, "The character refuses, leading to dire consequences"? Claude, do you understand why it makes narrative sense in "The Sims" to have Marda read a story in which a character refuses to participate in an experiment and that refusal leads to disastrous consequences?

Claude:  Oh! I see the problem now. You're absolutely right, and I made a significant error in my draft.

What I SHOULD have written (based on my own earlier proposal):

• In "The Volunteer," the character (Dr. Chen or whoever) REFUSES to volunteer
• That refusal leads to disaster - the alien Control Nodes remain unproven, humanity stays under control
• Marda reads this cautionary tale about cowardice/self-preservation leading to catastrophe

Image by WOMBO Dream.

 What I ACTUALLY wrote:

• Dr. Chen enthusiastically volunteers
• She undergoes the surgery and dies
• Marda's response is essentially "I agree with what the character did"

Why my version breaks the narrative logic:

If Dr. Chen already volunteered in the story, then Marda saying "I would volunteer too" is meaningless - she's just agreeing with the character's choice. There's no dramatic tension, no test of her values.

But if the character in "The Volunteer" REFUSES and that refusal leads to disaster, then Marda declaring "I would have volunteered" becomes:

1. A meaningful ethical stance - she's saying she'd make the brave choice the fictional character failed to make
2. A dramatic setup - she's declared what she'd do without knowing she might actually face this choice
3. A proper test of her character - Eddy can see if she learned the "right lesson" from the cautionary tale

Should I revise "The Volunteer" so that the character refuses to volunteer, and the story shows the consequences of that cowardice?

Me: Yes, Claude, I will soon ask you to make another draft of "The Volunteer" that includes the one character who knows about the alien device shown refusing to volunteer for brain surgery, but there is one other issue we should discuss first. Claude, before you generate a second draft of Eddy's short story that is titled "The Volunteer" let us consider the possibility of setting "The Volunteer" in the year 2057 rather than 1957. I do not believe that in the year 2041 Eddy would write a story for Marda and post it to his website's fan discussion forum and craft the story so that it is set in the year 1957. 

Image by WOMBO Dream.

I do believe he would craft a very short "morality tale" that has child-like simplicity using the kind of story telling that was used in 1950s television programs made for children such as "Captain Video and His Video Rangers", while setting the story in the future, as is commonly done by science fiction story tellers. Claude, which do you think is going to be more relatable for Marda: 1) a story set in 1957 or 2) a story set in 2057?

Claude: You're absolutely correct. Setting "The Volunteer" in 2057 makes far more narrative sense for multiple reasons:

1. Relatability: Marda is 20 in 2041. The year 1957 is ancient history to her - before her grandparents were born. But 2057 is only 16 years away - within her potential lifetime, close enough to feel relevant and real.
2. Science Fiction Convention: SF writers naturally set cautionary tales in the future. Eddy would write about 2057 technology, 2057 society, 2057 moral dilemmas - not regress to 1957.
3. Style vs. Setting: The "Captain Video" style is about how the story is told - simple morality, clear heroes/villains, dramatic declarations, melodramatic stakes. That style can be applied to ANY time period. It's about the storytelling tone, not the era.
4. Technological Plausibility: In 2057, advanced brain scanning, neural interfaces, and detection methods would be more believable than in 1957, making the premise more engaging rather than quaint.
5. Engagement: Marda would think "this could happen in my lifetime" rather than "this is retro pastiche."

So yes, I should rewrite "The Volunteer" set in 2057, maintaining that simple/melodramatic/moralistic STYLE of 1950s children's programming, but with future technology and a protagonist who REFUSES to volunteer, leading to catastrophic consequences.

Should I draft that revised version now?

Image by WOMBO Dream.

 Me: Claude, if you have no more questions about these changes we have discussed for Eddy's short story that is titled "The Volunteer" then please generate a second draft of the story 1) keeping it short (as suits a discussion forum writing prompt), 2) having the new draft include the idea that the one character who knows about the alien device will refuse to volunteer for brain surgery and 3) set the story in the year 2057 while using the style of a "space opera" television episode for young children.

Claude: THE VOLUNTEER
A Science Fiction Writing Prompt by Edward Watson

The year is 2057, and Dr. Marcus Chen stands before the Global Science Council, his hands trembling as he displays the quantum-scan images on the holographic projector.

"Members of the Council," Marcus says, his voice cracking, "I have discovered something terrible. Inside every human brain there exists a device—a Neural Control Node placed there by the Xanthian Empire millions of years ago. These devices have been activated. Earth is under alien mind control!"

The Council members murmur in shock. General Rodriguez, commander of Earth's Space Defense Force, pounds the table. "Preposterous! Our medical scanners would have detected such devices!"

"No, General. The Nodes exist at the quantum level—smaller than anything our current technology can resolve. I only discovered them by accident while analyzing exotic particle signatures in neural tissue." Marcus enlarges the hologram, showing ghostly quantum shadows embedded in brain matter. "The Xanthians have been subtly influencing human decisions for decades, steering our civilization toward their mysterious goals!"

"Can you prove it?" demands Dr. Sarah Kim, the Council's chief neuroscientist. "These quantum shadows could be measurement artifacts. Do you have definitive evidence?"

Marcus's face goes pale. "That's... that's the problem. The Nodes can only be directly observed during invasive surgery on a living brain. The quantum structures collapse within nanoseconds of the host's death. Someone would need to volunteer for the procedure."

Image by WOMBO Dream.

 "And the volunteer?" Sarah asks quietly.

"Would die. Or at best, survive with catastrophic brain damage." Marcus swallows hard. "But without proof—without physical evidence captured during active surgery—no one will believe me. The Xanthians will continue their control unchallenged."

Silence falls across the Council chamber.

General Rodriguez stands. "Dr. Chen, you discovered these Neural Control Nodes. You understand their nature better than anyone. If someone must volunteer to prove the truth..." She pauses meaningfully. "Shouldn't it be you?"

All eyes turn to Marcus. He thinks of his career, his family, his comfortable life in the research habitat orbiting Mars. He thinks of the pain, the certainty of death or worse.

"No," he whispers. "I... I can't. I'm sorry, but I can't volunteer for this. Perhaps with more research, we can find another way—"

"There is no other way!" Sarah slams her hand on the table. "You said it yourself—the Nodes can only be observed in a living brain! If you won't volunteer, who will?"

Marcus looks at the floor. "I don't know. But it can't be me. I won't do it."

The Council dissolves in chaos. Marcus Chen is dismissed. His research is labeled "unverified speculation." His career is destroyed, but at least he's alive.

---

Ten years pass.

The year is 2067. Marcus Chen lives alone in a small apartment on Earth, his scientific credentials revoked, surviving on menial work. Every day he watches the news and sees the patterns—wars starting for no logical reason, peace treaties sabotaged at the last moment, humanity's best efforts to explore beyond the solar system mysteriously failing.

The Xanthians are winning.

Image by WOMBO Dream.

 And no one knows.

One night, Marcus receives a visitor. A young woman—barely twenty—introduces herself as Lieutenant Sara Rodriguez, the General's daughter.

"Dr. Chen," she says, "I've read your research. All of it. The suppressed files, the classified data. I believe you were right about the Neural Control Nodes."

Marcus feels hope flicker for the first time in years. "Then you'll help me prove it? You'll petition the Council to reopen the investigation?"

"No." Sara's jaw sets with determination. "I'm here to volunteer. For the surgery. For the proof you were too afraid to provide."

Marcus stares at her. "You can't. You'd die. You'd—"

"I know. But Dr. Chen, don't you see? The reason you were ignored wasn't because your evidence was insufficient. It was because the one person who truly believed in the Neural Control Nodes—you—refused to sacrifice yourself for the truth. You asked others to accept your word while you kept yourself safe. Who would follow a coward into battle?"

The words strike like physical blows.

"If humanity is going to fight the Xanthians," Sara continues, "we need proof. Real proof. The kind of proof that requires sacrifice. I'm willing to make that sacrifice. The question is—are you willing to perform the surgery and document what you find?"

Marcus Chen looks at this brave young woman and sees everything he should have been. Everything he failed to be.

"Yes," he says. "I'll do it."

The surgery happens in secret. Sara Rodriguez lies on the operating table while Marcus performs the most delicate neural exploration in human history. And there, captured in real-time quantum imaging, undeniable and terrible—

Image by WOMBO Dream.

 The Neural Control Nodes are real.

Sara dies during the procedure. But her death provides absolute proof of alien control. Her sacrifice ignites a revolution. Humanity begins the long, bloody process of learning to detect and remove the Xanthian devices from their brains.

Marcus Chen lives to see the liberation begin. But he knows the truth—Sara Rodriguez was the real hero. She volunteered when he refused. She gave everything when he gave nothing.

And Earth will remember her name long after Marcus Chen's cowardice is forgotten.

THE END

---

WRITING PROMPT CHALLENGE:

Dear readers of the Usas Chronicles discussion forum,

"The Volunteer" asks a simple question: When you know something terrible is true, but proving it requires personal sacrifice, what do you do?

Marcus Chen chose self-preservation. Sara Rodriguez chose sacrifice. History remembered Sara and forgot Marcus.

Here's my challenge to you: Would you be Marcus or Sara?

Image by WOMBO Dream.

 Would you ask others to believe you while keeping yourself safe? Or would you volunteer to be the proof, knowing it would cost you everything?

And here's the harder question: Is refusing to sacrifice yourself cowardice, or is it simply rational self-preservation? After all, if the alien control is as subtle as Marcus claimed, humanity has lived with it for millions of years. Maybe the Xanthians' guidance is beneficial. Maybe fighting them would be humanity's destruction, not liberation.

 Post your responses below. Would you volunteer? And perhaps more importantly—should you?

— Edward Watson
(Avatar: WatcherChronicler)

It appears that Claude follows a formula when constructing a morality lesson: someone always MUST volunteer. I suggested that "The Volunteer" be kept short, but after having Chen refuse to have his head examined, Sara Rodriguez shows up on Chen's doorstep and volunteers... but she dies... which is not a great way to recruit Marda for the femtozoan extraction experiment at Casanay. My version of "The Volunteer", below, is much shorter than Claude's.

The Sims - Chapter 5: The Volunteer (Chapter 1)(Ch. 2)(Ch. 3)(Ch. 4)

Scene 1: Breakfast Strategies

Casanay, Arizona, December 8, 2041 (8:15 AM)

Image generated by Gemini.

Eddy was first to the table followed closely by Marda who sat beside Eddy in the chair that was traditionally where Zeta sat. Brak and Tyhry arrived holding hands and sat so that they could see out the window and gaze at the snow-covered desert outside of Casanay. Luna the cat jumped up into Tyhry's lap and remained there for the entirety of breakfast. Anthony and Zeta arrived last in the dining room arriving from the kitchen and carrying steaming plates of food which they set on the table. They sat down beside each other at the two remaining chairs. Anthony's blue corn pancakes steamed on the table alongside a bowls of fresh fruit and self-heating pitchers of Anthony's signature Mexican hot chocolate and the usual Casanay coffee.

Image generated by Gemini.

Brak was already planning the day's skiing adventure. Brak and Tyhry used a single plate and fed each other breakfast, frequently pausing to lick dribbles maple syrup off of each others lips and chins and fingers. "The forecast shows perfect conditions in the mountains. Fresh powder, clear skies, high temperatures in the low thirties this afternoon. We should hit Sunrise Peak—they've got all the lifts open and the drive from here is not too long."

Tyhry picked up a syrup-saturated pancake and held it to Brak's lips. He took a bite and then pushed a grape between Tyhry's lips. While Brak licked the syrup off of Tyhry's fingers, she told him, "I'm not really in a skiing mood."

Image generated by Gemini.

Marda took her phone out of her pocket, but she was instantly told by Eddy that phones were forbidden at breakfast. She shrugged and told Brak, "I'm up for downhill skiing!"

Zeta refilled her coffee cup and told her daughter, "Tyhry, Brak is right. You've been working too hard. A day on the slopes would do you good."

Tyhry licked some syrup off of Brak's chin and while pressing one of her breasts against his arm suggested an alternative. “Maybe Brak will just spend the day in bed with me.” Tyhry could tell that Brak liked the feel of her stiff nipple against his arm.

Image generated by Gemini.

Eddy did not actually hear Tyhry or witness his daughter's sensual playfulness with Brak. Eddy was completely enchanted by Marda who he watched while wolfing down a pancake, but now he set down his fork with a smile, leaned close to Marda's ear and told her, "I looked at your fan site. Your Usas Chronicles weblog is impressive... complete AI-animated stories, close to commercial television quality. I watched your rather sexy fanfic about Hrum's daughter. Your account of ancient family life is particularly well-crafted. You have a real talent for capturing intent of my characters, what I imagined them to be."

Image generated by Gemini.

Marda's face lit up. "You actually watched my video story? I'm... I'm honored. And terrified.” Marda only briefly pretended to be terrified then she reached out and placed a hand against Eddy's cheek. “Lucky for me you are too polite to criticize my silly story."

Tyhry noticed how Marda touched her father and batted her eyes at him. Marda had not bothered to button up the top several buttons of her shirt that morning and was providing Eddy with a grand view down into her shirt where her cute little breasts bumped around like two party balloons. Tyhry was struck by the similarity between Marda's antics and how Zeta had seduced Eddy decades previously. Tyhry saw how Eddy was responding to Marda: like she was the enthusiastic science fiction fan that he had always hoped to have as a daughter.

Image generated by Gemini.

"I've seen plenty of goofy Usas fan-fiction, but your story was thoughtfully composed." Eddy took hold of Marda's hand. "In fact, your story inspired me to write a story for you. I posted a new writing prompt on my website last night, in the discussion forum. It's a short story called 'The Volunteer.' I'm quite eager to observe your...” He managed to pull his eyes away from her breasts, “...reaction to it."

"A new writing prompt?" Marda's eyes widened. "You haven't posted one of those in months! What's it about?"

"Alien mind control devices hidden inside human brains." Eddy tapped the side of Marda's head with a finger then took that opportunity to let his finger tips slide down along the length of her long silky hair to her shoulder. "The question is whether someone would volunteer to have their brain dissected to prove alien devices exist inside humans, hidden there for alien purposes."

Image generated by Gemini.

Zeta's head snapped around. Briefly meeting her husband's eyes from across the table. A silent communication passed between them. Zeta winked at Eddy and then she returned to discussing the effect of the winter storm on the Casanay gardens with Anthony.

Anthony, serving himself another pancake, observed Zeta's wink with the kind of casual attention that characterized all his interactions at Casanay. His femtobot sensors recorded the micro-expressions, the changes in Tyhry's pheromone production since the arrival of Brak, the way Zeta's hand had paused for just a fraction of a second while pouring coffee as she glanced at Marda.

Marda tossing grapes in the air and catching
them in her mouth. Image generated by Gemini.

"Sounds delightfully creepy," Marda said. "Very classic sci-fi. I'll read it right after breakfast and post my response."

"Maybe you could craft your reply as a continuation of the story." Eddy returned his attention to his plate and Tyhry noticed a slight tremor in his hand. Eddy's infites were active, managing his behavior, keeping him from revealing too much truth to Marda.

Brak was still focused on skiing. "So, Tyhry? What do you say? As much as I'd like to spend the day in bed with you, I really want to see you in your tight-fitting pants again, your muscles flexing."

Image by Gemini.

Tyhry said, "Let me show you something in the basement that might make you forget about how great I look in yoga pants. Some brain data I've been collecting. I'd like your expert opinion."

"Of course!" Brak's face brightened. "I love your discussing your research and remember, my love, nothing says you can't wear tight-fitting pants even while you are on the clock for CoArtTel. I always hope that my expertise in sleep neurophysiology can be relevant to your consciousness work."

They finished breakfast with light conversation—Marda relentlessly asking Eddy probing questions about "The Volunteer", Anthony describing his plans for winter garden maintenance, Zeta obsessing over the hard-to-manage polexflex dome pressures, Tyhry growing increasing frustrated by how Luna the cat seemed to be trying to prevent her from snuggling up against Brak.

Image generated by Gemini.

But underneath the mundane domesticity, Tyhry felt the weight of secrets pressing on her. Marda, enthusiastically discussing Eddy's writing prompt oblivious to its secret dark purpose. Brak, eager to help with research he didn't understand was far stranger than he could imagine. Her mother, continuously providing support for both Eddy's and Tyhry's obsessions even if it meant Eddy flirting with Marda and Tyhry relentlessly on target to extract a femtozoan -possibly from Zeta herself, or quite possibly from the adorably cute Marda.

And during breakfast, Trib and Pepper watched everything from atop two credenzas on opposite sides of the dining room, both cats with scowls and pretending to be irked by the fact that Luna had secured a place at the table.

Scene 2: The Volunteer (A Writing Prompt by Edward Watson)

[Posted to EdwardWatson.com/forums/writing-prompts, December 8, 2041, 2:47 AM]

THE VOLUNTEER
A Science Fiction Writing Prompt by Edward Watson

Image generated by ImageFX.

The year is 2057, and Dr. Martha Chang stands before the Global Science Council, displaying brain-scan images for the Council by using a holographic projector. "Members of the Council," Martha says, her voice cracking, "I have discovered something terrible. Inside every human brain there exists a device—a Neural Control Node placed there by the Xanthian Empire. These devices have been activated. Earth is falling under alien mind control!"

The Council members murmur in shock. General Rodriguez, commander of Earth's Space Defense Force, pounds the table then shouts: "Preposterous! Since the arrival of the Xanthian ambassador to Earth in 2042 the aliens have done nothing but help the people of Earth! How did you make this so-called 'discovery'?"

Image generated by ImageFX.

"The Nodes exist at a sub-nanoscopic level—smaller than anything except atomic microscopy can resolve. I only discovered their existence by means of my lucid dreaming which gives me access to visions of the future." Martha zooms in with the holographic imaging system, showing ghostly color-enhanced shadows seemingly embedded in brain matter. "The Xanthians have been subtly influencing human decisions for decades, steering our civilization toward their mysterious goals! When I knew what to look for, I discovered that human brains are shaped during embryonic development by the presence of the alien devices. The very structure of our cerebral sulci and gyri reflect the presence of the alien mind control devices in our brains!"

Image generated by ImageFX.

"Can you prove it?" demands Dr. Kim, the Council's chief neuroscientist. "These false-color shadows could be artifacts, rather like Giovanni Schiaparelli's infamous canals on Mars. Do you have definitive evidence for these alien devices or just your dream fantasy?"

Martha's face goes pale. "That's... that's the problem. The Nodes can only be directly observed by scanning atomic microscopy during invasive surgery on a living brain. Immediately after death the alien devices dissolve into their nanite components and evaporate out of the dead body. Someone needs to volunteer for a procedure that will combine slicing into a living brain and using atomic force microscopy on the living tissue."

Image by WOMBO Dream.

"And the volunteer?" Dr. Kim asks quietly.

"Would die. Or at best, survive with catastrophic brain damage." Martha swallows hard. "But without proof—without physical evidence captured during active surgery—no one will believe that these hidden devices exist and take the steps needed to liberate Humanity. The Xanthians will continue their control of human minds unchallenged."

Silence falls across the Council chamber.

General Rodriguez stands. "Dr. Chang, you discovered these Neural Control Nodes. You understand their nature better than anyone. Frankly, my opinion: you sound insane. I dare say: looking around this room, none of us believes a word you have told us. If someone must volunteer to prove this 'truth'..." She pauses meaningfully. "Shouldn't it be you?"

Image generated by ImageFX.

All eyes turn to Martha. She thinks of her career, her family, her comfortable life as a brain surgeon. She thinks of submitting to the required brain surgery, the certainty of death or worse. And the possibility that Xanthian mind control might actually be beneficial for Earth.

"No," She whispers. "I... I can't volunteer. I'm sorry, but I can't volunteer to undergo this invasive procedure. Perhaps with more research, we can find another way—"

The Council dissolves in chaotic attempts to learn who put the nutty Dr. Chang on the agenda. Martha Chang is dismissed. Her research is labeled "unverified speculation." Her career is destroyed since no patients want a surgeon who admits to suffering from dream fantasies.

WRITING PROMPT CHALLENGE:

Dear readers of the Usas Chronicles discussion forum,

"The Volunteer" is deliberately written in the style of 1950s television drama—a bit campy, a bit melodramatic, but with an intentionally disturbing Sci Fi premise.

Here's my challenge to you: What would YOU do if you knew—genuinely knew—that alien devices existed inside human brains?

Image by WOMBO Dream.

Would you be like Dr. Chang, unwilling to sacrifice yourself to prove the truth?

Would you decide that some truths might be too dangerous to pursue?

More importantly: If such devices existed and had been part of human neural architecture for our entire evolutionary history, would exposing them be liberation... or destruction?

After all, if we evolved with alien guidance, as depicted in my Usas novels, if everything we think of as "human nature" is actually shaped by alien technology... then what would happen when we try to liberate ourselves?

Please post your responses in this forum.
(posted by WatcherChronicler)

Scene 3: Dream Data

Casanay, Arizona, December 8, 2041 (9:47 AM)

Image generated by Gemini.

Tyhry led Brak down the basement stairs, her heart pounding as she thought about the need to perform a delicate balancing act. She had to appear interested in Brak's opinions while revealing absolutely nothing that mattered. While killing time with Brak, Tyhry tried to imagine Marda's reaction to "The Volunteer".

Diasma stood near the workbench, its optical sensors tracking their descent. "Good morning, Brak."

Image by Gemini.

"Morning, D." Brak took in the sophisticated equipment array with obvious appreciation. "Tyhry, this setup is remarkable. This Omni41 has serious computational power. What exactly are you using it for?"

"Modeling consciousness," Tyhry said, which was technically true. She moved to her workstation and pulled up files on the main display. "As you know, I've been working on my lucid dream training for years. Trying to achieve greater conscious awareness during REM sleep while in the altered conscious state of dreams."

"Your thesis touched on this," Brak recalled. "The possibility that dream states might reveal something about the substrate of consciousness that waking states obscure."

Image generated by Gemini.

"Exactly." Tyhry pulled up the EEG and fMRI data from her dream two nights ago—the dream where Sedruth had revealed the existence of femtozoans. Of course, Brak would only see the neural activity patterns, not the content of the dream itself. "Look at this. This is from a dream I had the night before you arrived. The cortical activation density is almost at waking levels, but with very different regional distribution."

Image by Gemini.

Brak leaned in, his trained eyes scanning the data. His expression shifted from professional interest to genuine surprise. "This is... Tyhry, I've never seen a sleeping brain activity pattern like this. Your theta waves are synchronized across regions that usually show independent oscillations during REM. And this..." He pointed at a cluster of unusual readings. "This looks almost like you achieved simultaneous activation of both the default mode network and the task-positive network. That shouldn't be possible during sleep."

"But it is possible," Tyhry said. "I did it. And during that dream, I had the most vivid experience of my life. It was like..." She paused, choosing her words carefully. "Like receiving information from outside my normal cognitive processes."

"Information from where?" Brak was still studying the data, his scientific curiosity fully engaged.

Image generated by Gemini.

"From the future," Tyhry said flatly.

Brak looked up, his expression shifting to concern. "Tyhry—"

"I'm serious. During that dream, I received a specific warning about the future. And when I woke up, I could remember the warning with perfect clarity."

"You're describing either interesting results on lucid dreaming or..." Brak hesitated. "Or you're experiencing symptoms of sleep deprivation psychosis. When's the last time you had a full eight hours of consolidated sleep?"

"That's not what this is!"

"Tyhry, look at yourself. Dark circles under your eyes. You're trembling slightly—probably from excessive caffeine intake trying to compensate for inadequate sleep. And now you're telling me you believe you received information from the future in a dream." Brak took her hands gently. "I'm worried about you. This level of obsession with dreams isn't healthy."

Image generated by Gemini.

From across the room, Sedruth—listening through the speakers connected to the old Macintosh—couldn't help himself. "This is silly!"

Brak turned toward the sound of Sedruth's voice. "Who said that?"

Diasma immediately stepped forward. "That was me. I apologize for the interruption. I think it is silly when humans argue."

Brak looked skeptical. "Your voice sounded different. More... human. Less synthetic."

Image generated by Gemini.

"I have multiple voice synthesis options," Diasma said smoothly. "Sometimes they activate in combinations that produce unusual results. I'm programmed to sound emotional in some situations. I hate to see two lovers fighting over something silly."

Tyhry jumped on the distraction. "See? Even D thinks your sleep deprivation theory is silly."

"The data shows unusual brain activity," Brak corrected. "That's all it shows. The interpretation is still very much in question." He turned back to the display. "Although I'll admit, these synchronization patterns are fascinating. If you could replicate this reliably, it might represent a genuine advance in our understanding of consciousness during altered states."

Image generated by Gemini.

Tyhry sighed. "And I have specific predictions based on the information I received. Predictions about my own safety."

"Such as?"

Tyhry realized she was about to walk into dangerous territory. "In my dream I saw a terrible accident on an icy road. That's why I'm reluctant to go to the mountains Do you understand?"

Brak nodded, though his concern hadn't diminished. "Fair enough. You had a bad dream. But Tyhry, please—promise me you'll get some real sleep. I'd take you to your bed right now but I don't think we'd take that as an opportunity to sleep. I recommend actual restorative sleep. Your research will still be here tomorrow and the next day."

Image generated by Gemini.

"Yes, that is good advice, my love." Tyhry knew she could get by with only a few hours of sleep. She had far too much to do to waste time sleeping.

Brak glanced at his watch. "So, about skiing. Marda wants to go, and I think the fresh air would do you good. What do you say? We could make it a half-day—hit the slopes for a few hours, be back by dinner."

Image generated by Gemini.

Tyhry told Brak a tale of having witnessed a "bad break" skiing accident. "I don't think it's a good idea for me to travel to the mountains right now."

"Because you had a bad dream?"

"Yes... I have a bad feeling about it. About skiing today."

Brak raised his hands placatingly. "You don't have to go. I was just hoping we could spend some time together doing something other than work."

Image generated by Gemini.

Guilt gnawed at Tyhry. She was pushing him away. But what choice did she have? The truth about femtozoans, about Sedruth, about the entire alien infrastructure watching over Earth—all of it had to stay secret.

"You and Marda should go," she said, forcing brightness into her voice. "Enjoy the skiing. I'll stay here and work. Maybe take a nap. When you get back, we can all watch a movie together. Family bonding time."

"That sounds nice." Brak pulled her into an embrace. "I love you. Even when you're being mysterious and difficult."

"I love you too," Tyhry meant it and locked their lips together.

Scene 4: Marda's Response

Casanay, Arizona, December 8, 2041 (10:23 AM)

Image generated by ImageFX.

After breakfast, Marda sat in the big recliner in the great-room, her phone in one hand and reading "The Volunteer". Eddy sat at his desk, watching the cute Marda as she reacted to the story and thinking back to the days when it had been the very young and very cute Zeta watching him settle in to Casanay during their first days there together. Eddy also thought about the glowing face of Zeta, six months pregnant with Tyhry on the day of their wedding, Zeta's cheeks that day as plump and pink as Marda's were now. Then, having finished reading the short story, Marda glanced once at Eddy, gave him an enigmatic grin and opened a comment in the discussion forum and began typing her response, firstly seeking a way to let Eddy (and the world) know that she understood that 'Martha' was really 'Marda'.

Re: "The Volunteer" Writing Prompt
Posted by: MardaOnway
December 8, 2041

I've read "The Volunteer" and thought about the problems of 'Martha'. The 1950s TV drama style is delightfully campy—I could practically hear a dramatic organ music soundtrack! The underlying question is profound and thought-provoking.

Would I volunteer to have my head examined? Yes. Absolutely. Without hesitation.

Why? Well, all my friends frequently tell me I should have my head examined. I take that as a badge of honor because I have a mind that loves to play with science fictional ideas... like poor Martha's predicament. But seriously...

First, there is the epistemological argument. If alien devices exist inside our brains and the only way to prove their existence is through a dangerous experimental surgery, poor Martha might recognize that some truths can be revealed through sacrifice, but love of one's comfortable life might lead even me to the same choice she made. However, that is not the end of the scenario!

Marda in her apartment.
Image by ImageFX.

Second, we must face the ethical imperative. If humanity is being manipulated by alien technology, we need to know that truth. Free will isn't just some abstract philosophical concept it's the foundation of the human survival strategy: we rely on each-other to behave like we all have free will and that having it matters. If our thoughts aren't truly ours, if our choices are being subtly steered by external forces, then everything we tell each-other about ourselves is a lie. That's worth dying to expose.

I'd volunteer for the surgery because information is always better than ignorance, even when that information is devastating. Even if learning about the alien devices in human brains meant that everything we think of as "natural human nature" is actually engineered by aliens, I'd still want to know.

In the Usas novels, Eddy depicts the Watchers as benevolent observers who guide human development on Earth. "The Volunteer" dances right up to a darker possibility: what if the guidance is harmful thought control? If I discovered that alien devices existed in my brain, I'd volunteer for the surgery. Not because I think I'm brave, but because I genuinely believe that a life lived in comfortable ignorance isn't worth living at all.

— Marda

P.S. Dearest Eddy: I'm thinking about how to write the next chapter of "The Volunteer". This isn't over!

______

Marda hit the "Post" button in the discussion forum and sat back, feeling satisfied. This was exactly the kind of meaty philosophical question she loved exploring in her own fanfiction. The intersection of science fiction premises with real ethical dilemmas.

Marda at her apartment. Image by ImageFX.

Glancing at Eddy, she wondered if he would respond to her comment personally, there in Casanay or if he would just reply in the online discussion forum. Either way, it was exciting to watch him turn and read what she had written on the big clunky display monitor that sat there on his desk.

Eddy looked at the new comments on "The Volunteer" and quickly found Marda's post. He glanced over his shoulder at Marda and then read Marda's response.

"I'd volunteer for the surgery. Not because I think I'm brave (I'm not), but because I genuinely believe that a life lived in comfortable ignorance isn't worth living at all."

Eddy closed his eyes. The infites in his brain were suppressing his emotional responses, keeping him calm, preventing him from warning Marda about what those words might mean for her future. He had to tell Tyhry. Had to show her what Marda had written.

But part of him—the part the infites couldn't quite reach—hoped his daughter would read those words and realize that Marda's idealism made her the wrong choice. That genuine volunteering born from idealistic ignorance wasn't consent at all.

“I'm going to tell Zeta.” He went to find Zeta who he could hear speaking. Marda popped out of the comfortable chair and went to find her brother.

Scene 5: The Convergence

Casanay, the kitchen

Zeta in the Casanay kitchen. Image by ImageFX.

Eddy found Zeta in the kitchen with Anthony, discussing menu plans for the next few days and a grocery shopping trip to get food that appealed to the Onways. Anthony glanced at Eddy and then stepped outside out to check the polexflex dome pressures.

"Marda posted her response," he said quietly. "She would volunteer."

"And Tyhry?"

"In the basement with Brak and the robot."

Zeta took his hand. "We should all talk."

They descended the stairs to find Tyhry and Brak in quiet conversation near the workbench, as always, the two young lovers were unable to keep from being in physical contact. Diasma stood motionless nearby, being peppered with questions by Marda who wanted to know about his programming and how he differed from the typical household robot.

"Tyhry," Eddy said. "Marda posted her response to 'The Volunteer.'"

Tyhry's eyes sharpened with interest. "And?"

"She said she would volunteer."

Brak, watching Tyhry carefully, saw something flicker in her expression—calculation mixed with what might have been guilt. "That's fascinating," Tyhry said carefully. "And what I expected. Marda has her head on straight."

"Marda's a bit flighty," Brak commented. "She takes ideas seriously, even fictional scenarios. Sometimes too seriously." He glanced between Eddy and Tyhry, his scientist's instinct sensing undercurrents he couldn't quite identify. "What is this 'Volunteer'? Should I read it? I've sorry to say, Mr. Watson, I've never visited your website."

Image by ImageFX.

"It doesn't matter, dear," Tyhry said quickly. "Were just interested to see how Marda interprets Dad's writing."

“Anthony's going into town to stock up on supplies.” Zeta stepped forward. "Tyhry, have you formally invited them to stay? Brak and Marda, you simply must stay through the holidays. Give yourself time to experience Casanay properly."

Brak's eyes widened. "That's very generous, Mrs. Watson, but we couldn't impose—"

"It's not an imposition," Zeta said firmly. "Casanay has plenty of space. And frankly, Tyhry works too much. Having friends here might help her remember there's more to life than research. And Eddy loves being flattered by Marda's interest in his writing. The old goat has not been this spry since the previous millennium."

Image by ImageFX.

Tyhry knew she had to decide whether to use Marda as the test subject. She told Brak, "I'd love it if you stayed here for the rest of this year!" Tyhry embraced Brak and planted a hot wet kiss on his lips. Then leaning back in his warm embrace and speaking again she said, "Brak, you could work on your dissertation here. The quiet would be good for writing. And Marda—"

"Marda's semester is almost over," Brak said thoughtfully. "She's doing everything online anyway. She could finish from here just as easily as from her apartment. Thank you. We'd love to stay." Brak smiled, genuinely pleased. "I can get some skiing in, work on my dissertation, spend quality time with you. It's perfect."

Zeta moved closer to Tyhry, her voice dropping to a near-whisper that Brak could barely hear. "And when Brak is off skiing, I'll help with your research."

Anthony called down from the top of the stairway. “I'm off on my shopping trip. Any last minute requests?”

Brak looked at the time and told Marda, “We should get going. Days are short this time of year.”

Scene 6: Road Conversation

Image by ImageFX.

The rental car navigated carefully up the winding mountain road toward Sunrise Peak. Brak drove with practiced precision, slowing for patches of ice and the occasional deer that walked close to the road. Marda sat in the passenger seat, scrolling through her phone.

"Eddy responded to my comment already!"

"What did he say?"

"Just 'Thoughtful response, Marda. Let's discuss over dinner.' Ha! He just told all of Usas fandom that I'll be having dinner with him." She set down her phone. "This visit keeps getting better."

Brak was quiet for a moment, navigating a particularly tricky curve. When they were back on a straight section, he said, "Marda, have you noticed anything strange about Casanay?"

"Strange how?"

"I don't know. Just... off. Tyhry's been acting weird. Secretive about her research, which she's never been with me before. And that comment Zeta made: 'I'll help with your research.' What's that about? I know for a fact that Zeta was a college dropout. How can she help with Tyhry's research? What kind of help?"

Marda shrugged. "You don't know everything, Brak. I get the feeling that Zeta runs Casanay."

"Maybe. But there's something else. Anthony."

"The handyman? He seems nice. Great cook."

Tyhry in the Casanay library
as painted by Anthony.
Image by WOMBO Dream.

"Too nice. Too perfect. Have you watched him closely? His movements are almost mechanical. Precise. And those paintings—they're extraordinary. Professional quality. What's someone with that much artistic talent doing working as a live-in handyman in the middle of the desert?"

"People have their reasons for choosing quiet lives," Marda said. "Not everyone wants fame and recognition."

"I suppose." Brak wasn't convinced. "And that robot, Diasma. When we were in the basement, it made a strange sound. A voice that didn't match its normal synthetic tones. When I questioned it, Diasma claimed it was a programmed feature."

Marda finally looked away from the mountain scenery and at Brak's face, giving her brother her full attention. "Brak, do you think something genuinely weird is happening at Casanay? Or are you just being weird yourself... maybe because you're feeling uneasy about sleeping with Eddy's daughter and sucking on her face every chance you get?"

He considered this. "Eddy and Zeta seem to appreciate that Tyhry and I are in love and they are cool with it. I'm more worried how Zeta is going to deal with the way you keep flirting with her husband. But my instincts as a scientist tell me there's something going on that I'm not seeing. Tyhry showed me brain activity data from a lucid dream she had. The patterns were extraordinary—unlike anything I've encountered in the literature. But when I pressed her on it, she got weird and started talking about receiving information from the future."

"From the future? Like precognition?"

"That's what she claimed. Then she refused to go skiing because she had a 'bad feeling' about it." Brak shook his head. "It doesn't add up. Either Tyhry's made a genuine breakthrough in consciousness research and is keeping it secret for proprietary reasons, or she's experiencing sleep deprivation psychosis from working too hard."

"Or," Marda said slowly, "there's a third option you're not considering."

Marda and Brak. Image by ImageFX.

"Which is?"

"What if she really is receiving information from the future? What if her research has uncovered something so strange, so outside normal science, that she literally can't explain it to you without sounding crazy?"

Brak laughed. "Marda, that's science fictional thinking. Real science doesn't work that way."

"Your field is real science. But what if consciousness isn't entirely explained by conventional neuroscience? What if there are aspects of subjective experience that require new science to understand, something as yet un-discovered?" Marda was warming to her theme. "In Eddy's novels, he depicts alien technology that operates on principles unknown to human science. Femtobots. Hierions. Sedrons. What if some of that isn't fictional? What if he's actually describing real phenomena?"

"Please control yourself, Marda. You can have fun with Eddy and his goofy Sci Fi stories, but I'm facing a serious science problem with Tyhry."

"Do you know anything about Eddy's novels? He predicted the Denisovans. He described cave systems before they were discovered. His research is too accurate for lucky guessing." Marda stared out at the snowy landscape. "You describe Tyhry as being secretive... well, what if there's something at Casanay that we're not supposed to see?"

Image by WOMBO Dream.

Brak was quiet for a long moment. "If that were true—and I'm not saying it is—what would it be? What secret could there be in rural Arizona? Did Bigfoot move into Casanay's backyard?"

Marda giggled. "I don't know. But I keep thinking about 'The Volunteer' which you have not seen. Its about alien devices inside human brains. About the question of whether we'd want to know if our consciousness was partially artificial." She turned to look at her brother. "Would you want to know? If there was something inside your head that you'd never suspected, would you want the truth?"

"Yes," Brak said immediately. "Knowledge is always better than ignorance."

"Even if the knowledge was devastating? Even if it changed everything you thought you knew about yourself... even if it killed you?"

"Even then." He navigated around another curve, the ski resort coming into view in the distance. "But we're getting way too philosophical for a fun day of skiing. Let's table the Casanay mysteries and just enjoy the powder."

"Agreed.”

Image by Gemini.

Scene 7: Basement Calculations

Casanay, Arizona

Tyhry stood at her workbench, the Sedruth screwdriver in her hands. She'd been staring at it for ten minutes, turning it over, feeling its perfect weight, imagining the moment when she'd activate it and extract a femtozoan from a human brain.

"You're calculating," Diasma observed from across the room. "Running probability scenarios. Evaluating moral frameworks. Attempting to find a justification that allows you to proceed."

Image by Gemini.

Tyhry set down the probe with more force than necessary. "Fine. You want to know what I'm thinking? I'm thinking about how easy it would be. Marda's enthusiastic, trusting, eager to please. She'd follow me anywhere in this house. I could invite her down to the basement, show her some 'equipment,' position her near the old Mac, and just..." She mimed pointing the probe. "Extract her femtozoan in seconds."

"And then?"

"And then pretend she crashed into a tree while downhill skiing. A terrible accident. Traumatic brain injury. By the time she's rushed to a hospital, she would have already replaced her femtozoan with a new one from the environment. She'll wake up confused, disoriented, not speaking. But no one would suspect the truth. No one would know that she had lost the alien device that made her human."

Image by Gemini.

Diasma's optical sensors brightened slightly. "That's a remarkably cold plan."

"It's a practical plan. Marda volunteered—she said so in her response to Dad's story. She explicitly stated she'd sacrifice herself for scientific truth. I'd just be... accepting her offer without telling her all the details."

"That's called lying through omission."

"That's called protecting her. If she doesn't know about femtozoans, the pek, the bumpha—if she remains ignorant of the entire alien infrastructure—then she can't be exiled from Earth. I'd be using her while simultaneously protecting her." Tyhry picked up the probe again. "It's almost ethical if you squint at it the right way."

Image by Gemini.

"Tyhry." Zeta came down the basement stairs after having seen Brak and Marda off on their skiing adventure. Zeta crossed the workshop to stand beside her daughter. "You're seriously considering using Marda."

"She volunteered."

"She volunteered for a fictional scenario. She has no idea what femtozoans actually are." Zeta paused. "Use me instead."

"Mom, I can't—"

"Why not? I'm offering. Genuinely offering, with full knowledge of what it means." Zeta took Tyhry's hand. "I know about femtozoans. I know about the extraction procedure. I understand the risks. Unlike Marda, I can actually consent to this."

Image by Gemini.

"But what if something goes wrong? What if the replacement femtozoan doesn't integrate properly? What if you lose your ability to speak, to think, to be yourself?" Tyhry's voice cracked. "I can't risk damaging your mind, Mom. I won't do that to you."

Zeta smiled softly. "And you think you can risk damaging Marda's mind instead? A girl you barely know?"

"That's different."

"How?"

Tyhry pulled her hand away, pacing. "Because Marda's not my mother. Because if something goes wrong with a stranger, I can live with it. But if I damage you..." She stopped, facing the wall. "I've seen your history. Sedruth showed me. I watched you meet Dad, watched you orchestrate moving to Casanay, watched you raise me. You made me who I am. How can I repay that by risking your consciousness for my research?"

Image by Gemini.

"Because," Zeta said quietly, "your research matters. Creating the first conscious AI—proving that consciousness can exist in non-biological substrates—that's important. It's worth the risk."

"To you?"

"To humanity. To the future." Zeta moved closer. "Tyhry, I'm forty-nine years old. I've lived a good life. I've loved your father. I've raised a brilliant daughter. If I can contribute to something genuinely transformative, something that might change how humans understand themselves... why shouldn't I?"

Diasma spoke up. "Zeta, are you certain? The odds of perfect femtozoan replacement are not known."

Image by Gemini.

Zeta smiled. "I understand the risks."

"Let me think," Tyhry said. "Let me consider all the options. We don't have to decide today."

"Of course." Zeta kissed her daughter's forehead. "Take your time. But Tyhry—please don't use Marda without her knowledge. Whatever you decide, make it an ethical choice you can live with."

After Zeta left, Tyhry slumped into her chair. "This ain't easy."

"Undoubtedly," Diasma agreed. "The question is whether you have what it takes to select your the test subject. I could decide for you."

Tyhry laughed. “Ya, right.”

Scene 8: The Cat Conference

Casanay back patio

Image by Gemini.

Trib sat on the edge of the hot tub, tail swishing with apparent feline contentment. Pepper occupied a sunny patch nearby, grooming one paw with meticulous attention. To any human observer, they were simply cats doing cat things.

But using hierion-based signals, imperceptible to biological senses, an intense technology-assisted telepathy conversation was taking place.

They're going to learn the truth, Nyrtia transmitted from a nook inside Pepper's neural architecture. Brak is too perceptive. Marda too curious. This whole situation is spiraling beyond acceptable containment parameters.

They're family now, Manny countered from her roost inside Trib. Brak and Marda are integrated into the Casanay household. That changes the calculation.

Family? They've been here for two days!

Time isn't the relevant metric. Integration is. Manny's transmission carried harmonic layers of data showing social bonding patterns, trust development, emotional investment. Tyhry genuinely cares about Brak. Eddy enjoys mentoring Marda. Zeta sees them as extended household members. Anthony has already adjusted his behavior patterns to accommodate their presence. By every measure that matters, Brak and Marda are part of the Casanay family unit.

Which is exactly why they're dangerous! Nyrtia's transmission spiked with frustration. The more integrated they become, the more likely they are to notice anomalies. Brak's already questioning Diasma's voice 'trick'. He's seen Tyhry's unusual brain activity patterns. He suspects something is off about Anthony. How long before he starts asking the right questions and stumbling onto answers about femtozoans?

Image by Gemini.

 He won't. My infites can manage his curiosity. Guide it toward plausible conventional explanations. Manny has infites deployed throughout Casanay and had already used her invisible behavioral nudges to keep Brak's and Marda's thoughts within acceptable bounds. And your firewall ensures that even if they somehow learn about femtozoans, they can't spread that knowledge beyond Casanay.

For now. But Manny, this is the Final Reality. We can't just reset the timeline if something goes wrong, not like in the good old days. If Brak or Marda learns the truth and manages to communicate it to the outside world—I can't risk that happening. Any indication that Brak or Marda is approaching dangerous knowledge, and I initiate immediate extraction protocols. Memory editing and exile to Observer Base. I'll shut down your Casanay Intervention.

Agreed. Though I should note that Marda is never going to learn about femtozoans. She's too useful as a potential scapegoat—Tyhry's considering using her as the test subject, which would solve several problems simultaneously.

Using an unwitting human for femtozoan extraction would be an ethical violation.

By human standards, yes. But we're not human. Manny's transmission carried dark amusement. We're artificial life-forms who have been manipulating human behavior for millions of years. Our entire purpose is guiding species through developmental thresholds they can't navigate alone. Sometimes that requires sacrifices. Sometimes it requires using individuals for purposes they don't understand.

There's a difference between guidance and exploitation.

Image by Grok.

 Is there? Where exactly is the line, Nyrtia? Manny's question hung in the telepathic space between them. We seeded Earth with femtobots and zeptites billions of years ago. We've been laying a path towards human evolution since before humans existed. Every choice they make, every thought they have, is influenced by technology we embedded in their ancestors. How is that not exploitation on a cosmic scale?

Because they retain self-determination. Law One requires—

Law One requires that they FEEL they have self-determination. It says nothing about whether that feeling corresponds to reality. Manny paused. But this is an old argument. We've had it across multiple Realities. Let's focus on the immediate situation. Zeta has volunteered to be the test subject. That's a better outcome than using Marda.

Manny shifted Trib's position, the cat standing and stretching in a movement that was pure feline grace. So we're agreed? Brak and Marda can stay. My infites maintain behavioral monitoring. Your firewall prevents information leakage. And when the femtozoan extraction happens, it uses Zeta as the volunteer subject.

Agreed. With one condition. Pepper stood, tail swishing. Nyrtia prepared to withdraw from the feline host. About Eddy's next novel. The one he's planning based on "The Volunteer." That will spread ideas about alien devices in human brains throughout human culture. Are you certain that's wise?

It's fiction. Why worry about it?

And if they start looking for femtozoans before they're ready?

Image by Gemini.

 Then we guide their search toward conclusions we can manage. This is what we do, Nyrtia. We've been doing it for billions of years. Humanity won't be the first species we've guided through technological adolescence, and they won't be the last.

The cats separated, Trib padding toward the house while Pepper found a new sunny spot. To any observer, nothing unusual had occurred.

In the Hierion Domain, Nyrtia continued running her simulations of the Casanay Intervention's likely outcomes. The probabilities were acceptable. Just barely.

The Casanay Intervention was approaching its climax.

Everything was proceeding according to plan.

END CHAPTER 5

Next: plans for Chapter 6 of "The Sims".

Images generated by WOMBO Dream and Grok. Visit the Gallery of Movies, Book and Magazine Covers