The Mönch Paradox

Manny the bumpha uses the pek
Overseer of Earth as her tool to
alter Earth's timeline.

In my previous blog post I consulted with Claude concerning ideas for a new science fiction story titled "Mystery of Mönch Mountain". The story begins (see Chapter 1, below) with Eddy Watson using his Reality Simulation System to explore the origins of the science fiction literary genre.

Mystery of Mönch Mountain

Eddy arrived late in the Casanay dining room. Zeta and Tyhry were waiting patiently for him and discussing the fact that Eddy was particularly distracted by his most recent historical research. Eddy sat at the table and announced, "I just watched Nyrtia meet with Hugo Gernsback!"

Zeta picked up her fork and waved it towards her husband and asked, "When were you?"

Eddy already had a bite of his dinner in his mouth, but he did not let that deter him from replying, "Nineteen twenty seven."

Tyhry had been secretly using Eddy's Reality Simulation System for the past three years, using it to learn about advanced technologies from the Ekcolir Reality. When with her father, she always tried to act as if she knew very little about the workings of the Reality Simulation System that Eddy had received as a gift from Manny the bumpha. She'd never told her parents that Manny was teaching her how to program femtobots, but it seemed only a matter of time before they noticed since Tyhry could not resist artificially enhancing the appearance of her hair with the hair nanites she had programmed. She asked, "Why were you in 1927?" She really wanted to know which specific past Reality Eddy had visited.

Eddy explained, "I suspect that Manny helped begin Earth's science fiction genre. Hugo Gernsback and his magazine, 'Amazing Stories' seemed an obvious place in Time to look for evidence of alien Intervention into the origins and development of science fiction."

image source

Zeta mused, "I thought you were committed to using Isaac Asimov as your guide to the history of science fiction. He was only seven in 1927."

"Asimov was among the first kids to grow up fully immersed in science fiction." After another bite of food and confirming that both Zeta and Tyhry seemed to be waiting, he continued, "Nyrtia was disguised as a science fiction story writer named Willhamena Heidrun Gray."

Tyhry giggled and suggested, "Her name was 'Gray', like in 'gray alien'?"

Eddy smiled and nodded, "Nyrtia was well aware of H. G. Wells predicting that future humans might be hairless, gray-skinned humanoids with oversized heads and large eyes. She was obviously having a bit of fun when she met with Gernsback."

There was a family rule against electronic devices at the Watson dining room table, but Zeta was not above subverting the rules of the house. She was wearing a microphone and an ear bud that was buried deep under her thick hair. She asked, "What kind of a name is Heidrun?" Claude was listening through that microphone and told Zeta, "The name Heidrun means 'bright rune,' 'clear secret,' or 'honorable mystery'. It has old Old Norse linguistic roots". Zeta decided that 'Heidrun' was just the kind of obscure name that a pek would use while visiting Earth.

Eddy chuckled. "I had to look it up. I suppose Nyrtia was using that fake name as a way to say that she was secretly an alien in human form. In any case, from what I saw, it was quite clear that Gernsback enjoyed having a cute young woman in his office." Eddy was now looking directly at Tyhry.

Tyhry had been learning from Manny how to use her femtobot endosymbiont to study and learn the mind patterns of her parents. Now, Tyhry suspected that she could sense the direction of Eddy's thoughts. "You want me to visit Gernsback?"

image source

Eddy nodded. "I've introduced myself to Gernsback a half dozen times and in every case he quickly dismisses me as a nut who can't tell the difference between reality and science fiction."

Zeta giggled. "I suppose you immediately tell Gernsback you are a visitor from the future."

"Yes, I do. Why play games?"

Zeta sighed. She had long experience with Eddy's cluelessness and stubbornness. "You've proved that honesty is not the best policy."

Tyhry proposed, "If you sent me to talk to Gernsback in 1927, I'd first hand him a story as a submission to 'Amazing Stories'.

"That is exactly the strategy that Nyrtia used. And Nyrtia's story ended up getting published under the pen name Will H. Gray."

Tyhry complained, "Gernsback made Willhamena publish under the name 'Will'?"

Eddy shrugged. "I only just made the connection between Nyrtia and the little-known Will H. Gray who published three stories in 'Amazing Stories'. Tyhry, I need you to investigate this. Why are the pek messing with the science fiction genre?"

Tyhry was thrilled to be offered the opportunity to openly use the Reality Simulation System without having to sneak behind her father's back. However, she did not want to seem too eager. "What's the point? Who cares about some obscure writer from the 1920s?"

"That's not the point at all! I want to know why the pek Overseer of Earth was submitting science fiction stories to 'Amazing Stories' magazine."

Zeta asked Eddy, "Have you tried asking Nyrtia or Manny?"

Eddy sighed and slowly shook his head. "I have not heard from Manny for years. I only just found Nyrtia on Earth in 1927. I'll have to think about how to approach her... or have Tyhry do it. If she's willing."

"I suppose you'd expect me to wear those ugly clothes that were 'in fashion' in the 1920s." Tyhry briefly stuck out her tongue.

Zeta suggested to Tyhry, "Maybe you should just go into the Simulation System dressed as yourself." Zeta was joking. As usual, Tyhry was wearing her pajamas around the house.

Tyhry continued to pretend that she was reluctant to do this favor for her father. "I don't know if I want to meet either Gernsback or Nyrtia. What's in it for me?"

Zeta told Tyhry, "It sounds like your father is finally trusting you to use the Reality Simulator without his supervision." Zeta knew her daughter as a wild force of nature who chafed at all restrictions imposed by her parents. "I can't believe you would pass up such an opportunity."

Pretending not to know, Tyhry asked, "If I'm not with dad, how will I exit from the Simulation?"

Eddy admitted the truth, "Tyhry, I told you that only I can control the Simulation System, but that was a white lie. I did not want you using it without me being there with you. Zeta is right... you are no longer a child. I think you can use the Simulation System yourself, but I'd still like to go along with you to 1927."

Trying to sound hurt, Tyhry told Eddy, "Dad, I wish you trusted me enough to not lie to me."

"When you were still a little kid, I did not want you to be traumatized by things that could happen to you inside a Simulation. You've matured during the past few years and I think you are ready for this now." Eddy added, "But if you are not willing to help me, I'll fall back on your mother."

Zeta suggested, "Maybe Tyhry and I should both go into the Simulation."

Tyhry immediately agreed to her mother's proposal, "That is a great idea."

Eddy asked, "Why can't I go, too?"

Tyhry replied, "I want you here at home and using the Viewer Mode of the Simulation System. If I get into trouble, you can pause the Simulation and pull me out."

Eddy asked suspiciously, "What kind of trouble are you planning to get into?"

"Oh, who knows? I might just punch Nyrtia in the nose." Tyhry laughed. "Watch... you'll see."

"Don't go looking for trouble. I just want some information about the past." Eddy looked at Zeta and said, "I've created a monster."

Zeta smiled calmly and told Eddy, "I'm sure it will take Tyhry a bit of practice before she can find ways to get into as much trouble as you do while inside a Simulation."

__

First thing, Tyhry insisted on visiting New York City in 1926 in order to familiarize herself with the target environment. Also, she spent many hours using the Viewer Mode to look for evidence that Manny the bumpha had preceded Nyrtia to the offices of 'Amazing Stories', but no such evidence was found. Tyhry decided that she was not surprised since there were many tricks the bumpha could use to control a human being's behavior, some of which would not be visible upon Viewing. Tyhry decided that the first person she wanted to speak to in 1927 was Nyrtia the pek. Eddy used the Reality Simulation System's Viewer Mode to show Tyhry exactly where Nyrtia materialized before entering into the building in New York City that housed the offices where 'Amazing Stories' and Gernsback's other magazines were put together. Eddy said, "Watching Nyrtia assemble her femtobot components into the form of a woman was what first told me Willhamena was a pek agent."

Tyhry meets Nyrtia in 1927.

Tyhry's plan was simple. "Mom, you can wait in the restaurant for me. Get us a table. I'll intercept Nyrtia on the street and bring her to you. You'll take the lead in our interrogation of Nyrtia. Try to get her to explain why she presented the face of Willhamena to Gernsback and I'll listen carefully for clues as to what Nyrtia is trying to accomplish on Earth in 1927."

Eddy was looking at the clothing worn by his wife and daughter, "I can have the Simulation System dress you appropriately for New York City in 1927."

Tyhry shook her head. "No, mom and I have selected these clothes so that we will be dressed like Willhamena, using clothing that clashes with 1927 fashion norms. I want Nyrtia to take me seriously from the very first moment she sees me. I wish I could take my phone into the Simulation... that would quickly prove I'm from the future."

Eddy explained, "Remember, Nyrtia will be picking up data flowing from you femtobot endosymbiont. She'll instantly know that you do not fit into 1927."

Tyhry was counting on her ability to use programmable femtobots to ensure that Nyrtia would speak to her. "Yes. If I play my cards right, Nyrtia will drop her plan to chat with Gernsback and she'll be intrigued by my sudden appearance in 1927. She'll have to speak to me."

Eddy warned his daughter, "No matter what you are planning right now, Nyrtia will surprise you."

"Good. Then this should be fun." First Zeta then Tyhry passed through the invisible portal that gave access to the Simulation System. They entered into the Simulation, appearing inside the quiet confines of a narrow stairwell that was just off the busy sidewalk. Using his old computer which had been modified by Manny, Eddy watched as Zeta emerged from the door that led to the stairwell and went into the restaurant. Next, Tyhry stepped out on the sidewalk and positioned herself right in front of Nyrtia as she approached the entrance to the building that held Gernsback's office.

Nyrtia stopped walking and looked into Tyhry's eyes. Tyhry tried to sound calm as she said, "Hello, Nyrtia. We are inside a Simulation of this Reality. I'm here doing historical research." Tyhry took Nyrtia's arm. "Let's get off the street."

Nyrtia allowed herself to be guided by Tyhry to a nearby restaurant. She'd had plenty of prior experience using bumpha Simulations as a way to spend quality time with Manny. She asked Tyhry, "You are from 2027?"

"I am. As is my mother." Tyhry then tried an experiment. Without speaking, Tyhry asked Nyrtia: Can you pick up this technology-assisted telepathy channel?

Tyhry felt the reply come back from Nyrtia: Of course. But a girl from 2027 should not be familiar with telepathy.

Inside the restaurant, Tyhry saw her own reflection in a mirror and realized that Eddy had programmed the Simulator to alter her physical appearance, adding several years to Tyhry's appearance. Tyhry introduced Nyrtia and Zeta. Zeta quickly launched into her own conversation with Nyrtia, asking questions about the Willhamena Heidrun Gray identity that Nyrtia had created for herself on Earth.

The three women ordered lunch. While Zeta and Nyrtia spoke about the life of Willhamena Heidrun Gray, with occasional spoken comments from Tyhry, Nyrtia simultaneously carried on a telepathic conversation with Nyrtia.

Nyrtia told Zeta about her pleasant childhood growing up in New Hampshire and reading the fiction of Jules Verne and H.G. Wells. Nyrtia also showed Zeta the manuscript copy of her science fiction story titled "The Star of Love".

In their silent conversation, Tyhry asked Nyrtia: Why are you writing science fiction stories for Hugo?

Nyrtia replied to Tyhry's question with a question: Why do you want to know?

In the future, we want to understand the origins of the science fiction genre. Nyrtia shrugged. Tyhry added: It was quite a shock to us when we discovered a pek providing Hugo with science fiction stories.

Nyrtia told Tyhry: I'm seeing what is in your memories. She asked: Your father writes scientifiction stories for Manny?

Yes, in my time, my father is writing stories about past Realities with the help of Manny.

Amazing. Manny gave Eddy access to a bumpha Simulation System. Nyrtia was looking deeper into Tyhry's memories. Manny is teaching you about femtobot programming?

Yes, but so far I only know a few toy programs, like how to control hair nanites. Tyhry showed off by briefly making her silky nanite-generated hair move like it was dancing in a wind.

Nyrtia shook her head in wonder. And in the future, all that illegal technology transfer is allowed. Amazing.

Well, your agent, Anthony, lives in our house and keeps an eye on us. Nothing that I learn about alien technology spreads beyond Casanay.

 But your father publishes stories about Manny and also me."

 And nobody believes that those stories written by my father are anything but fiction.

Well, I look forward to meeting your father in the future. And learning why he is allowed to study the history of Earth using bumpha technology. Nyrtia tried to imagine the circumstances under which she would allow such a thing.

Tyhry pressed her question which Nyrtia had never answered. Why visit Hugo and submit 'The Star of Love' for publication in 'Amazing Stories'?

Nyrtia tried to make Tyhry understand why the Overseer of Earth would visit the editor of a goofy fiction magazine. That story is just a way to get in through the door. Hugo recently received a letter from a scientist in Europe, which tells about the bumpha making contact with that scientist. I have to stop Hugo from mentioning that amazing tale in the pages of 'Amazing Stories'.

I see. And what is the name of that scientist? Tyhry was thinking about her father who had briefly worked as a biologist before 'retiring' and becoming a full-time writer. Tyhry knew that she could pop both herself and Zeta out of this Simulation, but she was determined to push her luck with Nyrtia until Eddy would feel the need to extract her from this Simulation run.

Nyrtia seemed to be ignoring Tyhry's question. Tyhry found herself thinking about Nyrtia at work on Earth, trying to influence the timeline of human society by getting Hugo Gernsback to publish a science fiction story written by Nyrtia herself. It seemed absurd.

Having familiarized herself with Tyhry's mind pattern, Nyrtia was now efficiently following Tyhry's thoughts. Tyhry, I wrote 'The Star of Love' as bait for Gernsback, as a way to get close to him so that I could take control of his thought processes. I'm not interested in actually getting 'The Star of Love' into print.

Now, examining the data that continually flowed out of Tyhry's femtobot endosymbiont, it was clear to Nyrtia what Tyhry was trying to accomplish. Nyrtia was not sure that she should tell Tyhry everything she wanted to know. Nyrtia tried to estimate how information about her actions on Earth might be interpreted by Eddy in the future. Nyrtia admitted, I'm not at all sure I want my methods being published by you father.

At the same time, Nyrtia was telling Zeta, "If you must know, I'm using my Willhamena costume to get close to Hugo and prevent him from telling his readers about the bumpha."

Suddenly speaking out loud herself, Tyhry told Nyrtia, "My father is watching us right now. I think you just told us what he was hoping I could learn from you. Now that he knows you are trying to prevent mention of the bumpha from being published in 'Amazing Stories', dad could pull us out of here at any time."

Nyrtia laughed and continued communicating with Tyhry telepathically. So, your father sent you here because he does not get along with me.

Tyhry nodded to Nyrtia and then switched back to using technology-assisted telepathy. When he tries to speak to you, you are too distracted by the fact that in the future he is allowed to publish novels that mention the pek and bumpha. But you and I can make a deal. In the future, in my time, Manny is teaching me how to use telepathy. What you tell me now via telepathy, I will not share with Eddy."

Nyrtia laughed loudly in a way that disrupted the spoken conversation she was having with Zeta.

Zeta asked Nyrtia, "What is so funny?"

Nyrtia replied to Zeta, "You made me think of a funny event from my younger days."

Tyhry Viewing a Simulation run with Eddy.

Zeta said, "Oh, you remind me. Tell me about your middle name. I've never met a 'Heidrun'." Nyrtia began telling Zeta a convoluted explanation of how she had been named and her middle name selected in honor of an aunt.

In their telepathic conversation, Tyhry repeated her question: Who is the scientist in Europe who wrote a letter to Gernsback with information about the bumpha?

Nyrtia was sure that Tyhry and Eddy could find the answer to that question, if they tried, but Nyrtia was both charmed and alarmed by this girl from the future. Nyrtia decided to send a swarm of memory-control femtobots into Tyhry's brain, nanites that would prevent her from ever speaking about von Salis to her father. 

With that adjustment made to Tyhry's mind, Nyrtia told Tyhry: His name is Gubert von Salis. Hugo obliquely mentioned Gubert in his January editorial for 'Amazing Stories' and Gubert was provoked into responding to that provocation.

Interesting. Well, I'll soon be speaking to Hugo. Tyhry thought about the idea of using the Simulation System to visit Europe. Maybe I also need to meet von Salis.

Nyrtia told Tyhry: I'd take you to Hugo right now, but you caused me to miss my appointment with him.

Tyhry was now thinking about how best to approach Gernsback. She asked Nyrtia, How did you craft your story, 'The Star of Love'? Did you model it after Gernsback's own writing?

 Tyhry, I am fascinated by the people of Earth in general and scientifiction fans in particular. Nyrtia reached out and placed one of her hands on Tyhry's arm. Fan reactions to Gernsback's scientifiction are diverse. Some human reactions to the idea of extraterrestrial beings are useful to me and my efforts to prevent the bumpha from secretly providing dangerous advanced technologies to the people of Earth. I created 'The Star of Love' as a warning.

Tyhry nodded slowly. So it is the pek who pushed speculative fiction in the direction of xenophobia. I should have known.

Nyrtia asked, "Why are you trying to blame me for a natural human reaction to the unknown?

Tyhry was now going for it; trying to see how far she could push the Overseer of Earth. Nyrtia, in the future my father has written many science fiction stories about you. What I think I know about you comes from my father's stories.

Nyrtia giggled. And you think I am an evil force working counter to your chum, Manny.

Yes, I suppose that is the way of it. You don't help the people of Earth. You hold us down.

I see in your thoughts that you know about the Rules of Intervention. Nyrtia asked Tyhry: Do you not understand how deploying advanced alien technology on Earth could damage your primitive species?

Tyhry gave a delicate shrug of her shoulders and pushed away Nyrtia's hand from where it rested on her arm. All I know is that Manny trusts me to use programmed femtobots. In contrast, you don't even want me to know the name of the scientist from Europe who you don't want writing a letter to Gernsback. I don't like how you are messing with the science fiction genre.

Nyrtia giggled. I see in your mind that 'scientifiction' will soon be replaced by 'science fiction', a term that is a silly contradiction of terms.

It is clear that you can't see the future that is rushing at you. Tell me, Nyrtia, what is it like knowing that the bumpha defeated you pek in the Time Travel War?

Manny has claimed victory? Strange, now that the War is over and time travel is now impossible. I'm quite pleased that Manny can no longer alter the timeline.

Tyhry was aware that Manny could still send sedrons back through time. Tyrhy had been trying not to think about that, but now Nyrtia could see the truth in Tyhry's mind. Nyrtia said to Zeta, "So that is the strange pattern in your mind. You are host to a zeptozoan."

Zeta was familiar with the term 'zeptozoan' from Eddy's stories. Now she seriously considered the idea that she was, herself, a host for a zeptozoan. "Are you telling me or asking me?" 

Nyrtia laughed. "Such a strange family that Manny has constructed, and only a hundred years in the future. I'd never have imagined."

For a moment, Tyhry feared that Nyrtia would tell her mother about Tyhry's developing telepathic abilities, but Nyrtia stood up and said, "It was nice chatting." Nyrtia turned and walked out of the restaurant.

Zeta asked Tyhry, "Do you think it is true? I'm a host for a zeptozoan?"

Now Tyhry stood up and briefly thought about paying the bill for their lunch. She found that she was carrying a large amount of cash. She put a ten dollar bill on the table and then led Zeta out of the restaurant and onto the busy sidewalk outside. Manny had long ago told Tyhry about the existence of the zeptozoan inside Zeta, an agent for Manny that guided Zeta's actions. Tyhry wanted to say nothing about that.

Following Tyhry down the street , Zeta asked, "Do you intend to visit Gernsback?"

"Not now. I suppose we should plan how to best approach him."

Zeta nodded. "I'd like to discuss zeptozoans with your father." Just then, Eddy ended the Simulation run and both Zeta and Tyhry returned to the great room of Casanay, arriving there close to Eddy as if arriving by teleportation.

Eddy and Zeta hugged and she asked him, "Do you think it is true?"

Eddy told Zeta, "I've often wondered what makes you so special, my love." Now Tyhry could sense in Eddy's mind that he had also been told by Manny about the presence of a zeptozoan inside Zeta's brain, influencing her actions. "The next time we see Manny we will have to ask her."

Tyhry commented, "I'm not waiting around for Manny to show up. I now know when to look for our next clue in this mystery." She told Eddy, "Show me the mail room where letters addressed to Gernsback's magazines are opened."

Using the Reality Viewer built into his computer, it did not take Eddy long to find the correct room, not far from Genrsback's own office. As they watched, a young woman opened letters from a seemingly endless pile of mail. Eddy asked Tyhry, "You are looking for a letter from someone in particular?"

Tyhry was looking for the letter from von Salis, but she did not want to reveal that she already knew his name. "Show me how to scan this up and down the timeline". Tyhry already knew how do such a temporal scan using the Viewer Mode of the Reality Simulation System, but she was pretending to not be familiar with the fine points of using the device. Soon she had found the letter from von Salis, but she said nothing to Eddy about that. Later, when Eddy was busy and away from his computer, Tyhry would return to the Viewer and read the letter.

End Chapter 1.    Jump to: Chapter 2.

Food platter placement by Flow.

Chapter 1 of "Mystery of Mönch Mountain" (above on this page) came out to be 4,000 words long and has images that were mostly generated by Google's Flow. When I asked Flow to make a table in a New York City restaurant for Tyhry, Zeta and Nyrtia (wearing her 'Willhamena' disguise), Flow instantly sat them at a very small table. Then when I tried to have Flow illustrate a waiter placing a platter of food on that small table, the results were amusing (see the image to the left ←). The platter of food just got placed in the center of the table, seemingly balanced on top of the rest of the dishes. Upon my first request, Flow moved the platter right in front of Tyhry. With some effort, I was able to get Flow to put the platter of food on the empty side of the table.

Next: Plans for Chapter 2 of "Mystery of Mönch Mountain".

Images by Leonardo. Visit the Gallery of Movies, Book and Magazine Covers

Star Light

Image generated by Flow.

 In Hugo Gernsback's editorial at the start of the January 1927 issue of 'Amazing Stories', two scientists, Dr. Kolster and Dr. Deesalis, are described as being astronomers who recently discovered "extraordinary rays of light", far stronger than that of x-rays, coming from some stars. Just for story writing fun, let's take Hugo Gernsback's mention of Dr. Kolster and Dr. Deesalis seriously and invent a new science fiction story in which Kolster and Deesalis were studying cosmic rays (working in an observatory on Mönch Mountain) and they accidentally achieved First Contact with space aliens in November of 1926. However, the space aliens (called the 'pek') had long been studying Earth and human civilization and they wanted to continue to remain hidden from humans. All of the interactions of Kolhörster and von Salis with the pek were subsequently erased from history by the aliens.

I first suggested this plot for a new science fiction story titled "Mystery of Mönch Mountain" to Google's AI Mode, and that AI agent suggested that 'Kolster' and 'Deesalis' be depicted as using a temporary, custom-engineered research station below the summit of Mönch Mountain. In the text of the story, it is stated that there was real-world expedition to the Mönch research station in 1926, that was led by a German physicist Werner Kolhörster (whom Gernsback Americanized/altered to "Dr. Kolster") and his Swiss collaborator Gubert von Salis (Gernsback's "Dr. Deesalis"). 

I then moved on to discuss this new story idea with Claude.

Image generated by Flow.

 Me: Claude, I suggest that this new science fiction story, the pek Overseer of Earth, using the name Willhamena Heidrun Gray, arrives in the New York office of Hugo Gernsback in November 1926 carrying a manuscript copy of a new science fiction story titled "The Star of Love", for submission to 'Amazing Stories' magazine. Eventually, Willhamena Heidrun Gray has three science fiction stories published in 'Amazing Stories' under the name Will H. Gray (the first of which is titled "The Star of Dead Love", as published in the May 1927 issue of 'Amazing Stories'). When Willhamena arrives in Gernsback's office, he is completing work on his editorial for the January 1927 issue of 'Amazing Stories'. Willhamena uses memory-editing femtobots to alter Gernsback's memories and thought processes. Under the influence of the pek Overseer, Gernsback "corrects" the names 'Kolhörster' and 'von Salis' to 'Kolster' and 'Deesalis' in the text of his editorial. When with Gernsback, Willhamena Heidrun Gray shapes her own femtobot components into the physical form of a human woman and is not recognized as being an alien pek.

Claude, what questions do you have about this new story idea?

Claude: This is a fun premise, and the Gernsback "error" gives you a built-in historical mystery. Here are my questions and a few notes, all in prose as you prefer.

Checking the history first. I should flag that I'm working from memory on the details of the 1926 Jungfraujoch/Mönch expedition and Gernsback's editorial, and I'd rather you verify than trust me. As I recall, Kolhörster did lead cosmic-ray measurements in the Jungfrau region in the 1920s, and the "von Salis" name is plausible as a Swiss collaborator, but I'm not certain of the exact dates, the site details, or the first name you've given (Gubert). Since you want the story to rest on real history, it may be worth checking the editorial text itself and a source on the 1926 expedition. I can search for these if you'd like. One related point: Gernsback's phrase "rays far stronger than x-rays" fits the cosmic ray story well, but in 1926 the nature of these rays was still debated (Millikan's "birth cries of atoms" versus other interpretations), which could be useful texture.

Image generated by AI Mode.

 Questions about the pek and the contact event

1. How did the contact happen physically? Did Kolhörster's electroscopes or ionization chambers register a pattern in the radiation that wasn't natural, or did the pek deliberately modulate a cosmic-ray-like flux because they were watching for exactly this instrument sensitivity? Hard SF readers will want a mechanism that makes the "accident" plausible.
2. How do the pek communicate with a human instrument in 1926? Is it a signal that Kolhörster and von Salis had to decode, and if so, what is the pek's information carrier (charged particles, gamma photons, something stranger)?
3. Where are the pek relative to Earth? Is the Overseer's base in the solar system, aboard a distant craft, or in a star system whose radiation reaches us? This affects how the signal could arrive in 1926.
4. Why did the pek decide erasing the contact was better than leaving it? Since they want to remain hidden, what is their underlying ethic or policy? Given your preference that aliens aren't villains, I'm assuming they are protective or non-interventionist rather than sinister. Is that right?

Questions about the erasure

5. How thorough is the erasure? Femtobots altering Gernsback's mind is one thing, but the expedition's logbooks, publications, and the memories of the two scientists, and anyone they spoke to, are another. Does the story want some residue to survive (the real-world oddities that make the mystery solvable), or is the erasure imperfect by design?
6. Do Kolhörster and von Salis remember anything? Do they have gaps, or were they replaced with plausible false memories? The real Kolhörster's later career might be an interesting thread to touch carefully.
7. What is the logic of the Gernsback name change? Why would an Overseer who wants to hide things deliberately plant a misspelled version in print? I'm guessing it's a controlled breadcrumb or a way to make the real names harder to search, but I don't want to assume.

Image generated by Flow.

 Questions about Willhamena Heidrun Gray

8. Why does she take the risk of publishing fiction at all? The Overseer physically walking into Gernsback's office is a strong choice. Is it an emotional need, a cultural study of humanity, a way of leaving a message, or is she shaping human thinking about aliens through the genre?
9. What is the relationship between "The Star of Love" and "The Star of Dead Love"? Is the title change something Gernsback did, something she did, or part of the in-story puzzle? Also, what are the three stories' roles in the plot?
10. How do femtobots form a human body convincingly? You'll want to decide whether she has to hold the shape continuously, how she eats or doesn't, and what would reveal her. Are there constraints on her (energy, range, time) that create tension?
11. How much does she alter Gernsback? Does she leave his judgment intact apart from the specific edits, and does she regret or reflect on using mind-editing on a man she admires?

Questions about the frame

12. Who is telling this story, and when? Is there a present-day researcher who notices the discrepancy between the real expedition and Gernsback's editorial, as the Google AI Mode suggestion implies with its in-text mention of the real expedition? That would make the mystery the title refers to.
13. Is the story set in 1926 only, or does it alternate with a modern investigation?
14. Does it connect to the Exodemic Fictional Universe, or is it a standalone?

Missing information I'd ask for. Could you share the exact wording of Gernsback's editorial passage about the two astronomers, and what the Google AI Mode text already says about the research station? That would help me avoid contradicting anything you've already drafted.

Which of these would you like to take up first?

Note: I provided Claude with a file describing some plot devices.

Image generated by Flow.

 Me: Claude, process and make use of the file I just uploaded which has some backstory information that can be used during the creation the new science fiction story "Mystery of Mönch Mountain".

Claude, let's assume that Manny the bumpha is at work on one of her long-range Interventions into the development of new technologies on Earth by humans. The text of "Mystery of Mönch Mountain" can imply that in a previous Reality, Gubert von Salis became involved in a Nazi Germany nuclear fission development program. The goal of Manny's "Mönch Intervention" is to prevent a nuclear war initiated by Germany and bring into existence a new Reality (possibly the world as we know it) in which Germany did not develop nuclear weapons. Manny decides to make use of the pek to change the course of the life of Gubert von Salis. Thus, the primitive equipment of Kolhörster and von Salis does not actually detect any evidence of aliens; Manny simply alters the historical timeline of Earth by making Gubert von Salis find out about Gernsback's January 'Amazing Stories' editorial in 1927. Gubert von Salis then sends a letter to Gernsback. Manny alters that (harmless) letter, making it include false information about apparent mysterious contact with space aliens. When Gernsback tries to publish in 'Amazing Stories' a second-hand account of that mysterious contact with space aliens, the pek Overseer of Earth takes action, completely altering the trajectory of the life of Gubert von Salis and that prevents development of an A bomb by Nazi Germany.

Claude: I've read the file. Here's how it fits, where I see tensions, and what I need from you.

How the backstory helps

 The document gives us a mechanism for why this Intervention works the way it does. In the Final Reality, hadrons and hierions can't travel backward in time, but sedrons still can. So Manny can't physically appear in 1926 (she can teleport sedrons but not hadrons, and her sentient spaceship is hadronic), but she can send information backward through the Sedron Time Stream. The pek Overseer, who has been on Earth continuously, is the natural hadron-world agent, which explains why Manny needs her. Also, humans carry zeptite endosymbionts that can interface with the Sedron Time Stream, so Manny could nudge von Salis toward the Gernsback editorial through his own endosymbionts, with no gadget visible in 1927. That is my inference from the document, so correct me if it doesn't match how you use these elements.

Tensions I'd flag

1. Final Reality versus a new Reality. The document says the Huaoshy's alteration of the Dimensional Structure ended time travel by positronic robots, and that Eddy, Rylla and Tyhry believed further Reality Changes were impossible. Your Mönch Intervention creates a new Reality, possibly ours. Is the Mönch Intervention happening within the Final Reality using only sedron information flow, or does it come from an earlier stage of the Reality Chain? That decides whether it needs "vast amounts of temporal energy" to overcome Temporal Momentum.

Image generated by Leonardo.

 2. Temporal Momentum and analogues. Because of the Bimanoid Interface, a von Salis analogue would exist in the new Reality. Is he a Fixed Point? If not, the story should say why altering his life is enough to prevent the bomb, rather than the Reality's momentum producing another physicist to fill the gap.

3. One man stopping the German bomb. Historically, many factors sank the German project, and I'd suggest verifying the details of Kolhörster's and von Salis's wartime roles. To make von Salis pivotal, Manny's Sedron Time Stream analysis could identify him as a single point of failure in the old Reality, for example because his precision radiation-detection work corrects an error that history's German physicists never fixed. Is that kind of hard-SF logic what you want, or do you prefer to leave his role vague?

4. The pek and the Rules of Intervention. The pek are described as conservative enforcers of the Rules, while the bumpha are the interventionists. Does Willhamena know she is serving Manny's plan, or does Manny manipulate her? A pek Overseer who believes she is protecting Law One (the appearance of self-determination) while unknowingly carrying out a bumpha Intervention would give you real character tension without making anyone evil.

5. The timeline of the editorial. The editorial appears before von Salis's letter, so the "Kolster/Deesalis" misnaming in November 1926 must already be part of the plan. Is it deliberate camouflage, so later claims of alien contact attach to garbled names and read as science fiction rather than fact? I like that: Willhamena's published stories would also make "aliens in Amazing Stories" a joke genre, which helps discredit von Salis's claims.

Questions I still need answered

Image generated by Flow.

 - How does Willhamena "completely alter the trajectory" of von Salis's life: femtobot edits to his mind, a physical relocation, a new career, or social engineering through others? Does he end up happy, or is that a cost Manny and the pek must weigh?
- Who is the "Mystery of Mönch Mountain" investigator? Eddy Watson viewing this Reality in the RSS would be a natural frame, since the document says he incorporates actual events from past Realities into his stories. But I'd rather you decide.
- Do Kolhörster's and von Salis's primitive instruments detect anything at all, or are the "mysterious signals" entirely invented by Manny's altered letter? You've implied the latter. If so, what real anomaly in the 1926 data gives her something to build on?
- I'd still like Gernsback's exact editorial wording, and your starting text from Google AI Mode, so I don't contradict either.

Which of these would you like to settle first?

Me: Claude, as always, many thanks for noting my errors in documents such as that backstory PDF.

(1) For the new story "Mystery of Mönch Mountain", let's assume that the events in the story all take place after the Huaoshy have altered the Dimensional Structure of the universe and all further time travel must involve the movement into the past of only sedrons and time travelers composed of sedronic matter.

(2) von Salis is not a Fixed Point and it is pretty easy to alter the course of his life.

(3) At this moment (before writing even one line of the story) my intuition suggests that nothing need be said explicitly in "Mystery of Mönch Mountain" about the precise role of von Salis in German fission research (we could call the whole German A-bomb topic a MacGuffin {https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacGuffin}). In crafting this silly science fiction story, I am trying to have fun with the idea of Gernsback and "Amazing Stories" getting caught up in one of Manny the bumpha's Interventions. The story is not really "about" von Salis and the text of the story could hint that the pek Overseer simply puts pek memory-altering femtobots into the brain of von Salis that prevent him from thinking seriously about space aliens. In a subsequent type of "butterfly effect", that small alteration to the mind of von Salis alters the trajectory of his life.

Image generated by Flow.

(4) Currently, while making early plans for "Mystery of Mönch Mountain", I'm thinking that, during the course of the story, the pek Overseer of Earth will come to suspect that Manny is crafting an Intervention into the course of Earth's historical timeline, but the two main concerns of the pek are (i) preventing the bumpha from transferring knowledge of advanced alien technology to Earthlings and (ii) avoiding any revealing of the existence of the pek and bumpha to Earthlings. For such stories, I like to pretend that Manny the bumpha helped Gernsback launch 'Amazing Stories' magazine and the whole science fiction genre as part of a bumpha plan to start preparing Earthlings for eventual contact with aliens.

(5)  "The Star of Dead Love" by Will H. Gray was an actual science fiction story published in the May 1927 issue of 'Amazing Stories' magazine. The story involves a First Contact event between a woman from Venus and a scientist on Earth, sometime around the year 1927. I'd like to depict "The Star of Love" as having been crafted by the pek Overseer of Earth and the text of that story being ruthlessly edited by Gernsback (under the direction of a time traveling zeptozoan from the future who is Manny's time travel agent for the "Mönch Intervention). Zeptozoans are advanced artificial life-forms physically composed of sedrons that can be sent back through time.

Claude, I like your suggestion of having Eddy Watson use his Reality Simulation System as a tool for investigation the early history of 'Amazing Stories' magazine. He might simply be curious about the identity of author "Will H. Gray" (in the real world, my own curiosity about the identity of Will H. Gray is what sent me down this entire rabbit hole) and Eddy just accidentally stumbles across the Willhamena and Gernsback meeting in New York.

January 1927 editorial.

The January 1927 editorial by Gernsback has one paragraph that includes: "two Swiss scientists, Dr. Kolster, and Dr. Deesalis, who have been living in a tent for the last few months, on the summit of Mönch Mountain, at an altitude of 13,465 feet, have found that a certain group of stars sends out extraordinary rays of light whose radio-active force is far stronger than that of X-rays."

Claude: Thanks for the editorial text and the five decisions. They tighten the plan a lot. Here is how I see it fitting together, with a few places where I think we need to decide something.

The editorial wording matters for the story. Gernsback says the scientists were living in a tent on the summit, at 13,465 feet. That conflicts with the Google AI Mode suggestion of a custom-engineered station below the summit. I'd go with Gernsback's wording, because the whole premise is that his text is the "error" the pek planted, and a tent on a summit also makes a better image of two men with primitive equipment. Two things are worth verifying. First, the real expedition may have worked from a hut or from the Jungfraujoch area rather than a tent on the summit, and Gernsback's account may be garbled in more than the names. If so, the discrepancies could be extra breadcrumbs for Eddy. Second, the editorial says "rays of light" and "radio-active force," which is not how a physicist would describe cosmic rays, and it attributes them to "a certain group of stars." That matches your plan: Gernsback's text is already wrong in ways that make real science sound like science fiction. I can search for the real expedition details and the editorial's cover date versus on-sale date if you'd like.

 Your decisions and what they imply

(1) and (2) fit well. With only sedrons going back, the zeptozoan is the right kind of agent. One question: the backstory says Manny herself is composed of zeptites and can teleport sedrons, so why does she need a zeptozoan as her time agent rather than going back herself? A good answer might be that she can't send a complex body back, or that she must stay in the present to run the Sedron Time Stream, or that the Rules of Intervention restrict her. Any of these would be fine, but the story should hint at one.

(3) I agree that leaving the A-bomb as a MacGuffin is the right call. It keeps the story light and lets readers who know history fill in the blank. One hard-SF wrinkle you may want to keep in the background: Temporal Momentum exists to damp out chaos between Realities, which works against a small nudge producing a large divergence. The simplest fix is that Manny's Sedron Time Stream analysis identified von Salis's mind as an unusually sensitive point, and that this is why she chose him. You don't need to explain it in the text, but it's worth knowing for consistency.

(4) The pek suspecting Manny is the best tension in the story. It also raises a sequencing question, because your first version had Manny altering von Salis's letter, and now the pek puts femtobots in his brain. Am I right that these fit together as follows? Manny's altered letter provokes the pek into acting, the pek's suppression of von Salis is the effect Manny wanted all along, and Manny foresaw this through the Sedron Time Stream. That makes the pek an unwitting instrument. Does Willhamena ever realize that, or does the story end with her still believing she protected Law One?

 (5) Having the pek write "The Star of Love" and the zeptozoan steer Gernsback's savage edits is an excellent source of conflict, since the two agents are effectively fighting over one manuscript. Two questions. What does the zeptozoan want from the edits, for example turning a story about alien contact into a tragedy so that it reads as pure fiction, or planting a specific idea? And does Willhamena know the editing is being steered by someone else, or does she just think Gernsback is a heavy-handed editor?

Questions I still need answered

- Which Reality is Eddy in when he views this? If the Mönch Intervention creates our Reality, is Eddy watching it from inside it, or from a later Reality, and does he notice anything odd about its history? That decides whether his discovery is a surprise or a confirmation.
- Where did Gernsback get his information about the two scientists? The story could use a real source such as a newspaper item or a letter, which gives the pek or the zeptozoan something concrete to tamper with.
- The editorial appeared before von Salis could possibly have seen it. Is it clear that the story's November 1926 meeting precedes both the editorial and the contact claims, so the misnaming is a deliberate "pre-edit"? If so, the zeptozoan and Willhamena must both have wanted it, so who proposed it?

Which of these would you like to settle first? If you tell me, I can start sketching a scene order (for example, opening with Eddy's discovery in the RSS and then cutting back to the office in November 1926).

Me:  Yes, Claude, this is also my view of the situation: "Manny's altered letter provokes the pek into acting, the pek's suppression of von Salis is the effect Manny wanted all along, and Manny foresaw this through the Sedron Time Stream. That makes the pek an unwitting instrument." 

Image generated by Flow.

"Does Willhamena ever realize that, or does the story end with her still believing she protected Law One?" <-- That is a great question, and the answer will be whatever leads to the most fun in the crafted story. At this moment, my intuition suggests that the pek Overseer will be quite upset by the faked version of the letter from von Salis to Gernsback that Manny crafts. That letter can mention the bumpha by name and imply that the bumpha have been in contact with von Salis, which is not true, but which is intended (by Manny) to greatly upset the pek Overseer, goading the Overseer to make an alteration to von Salis' thought processes.

"what does the zeptozoan want from the edits" <-- The zeptozoan will be trying to advance Manny's long-range objective of making humans less fearful of aliens. I'm still thinking about the original version of the story ("The Star of Love") that is crafted by the pek Overseer. It might depict the Venusians as being evil and threatening Earth. The zeptozoan (working through Gernsback) would alter that "first draft" of the story. In the actual story, "The Star of Dead Love" the Venusians are not depicted as threatening and the one Venusian woman who makes contact with the human scientist is dragged back to Venus at the end of the story. For "Mystery of Mönch Mountain", the pek Overseer can be depicted as having long suspected that Manny is manipulating Gernsback and so the pek Overseer is carefully monitoring what goes on at 'Amazing Stories' magazine. The pek Overseer is worried that Manny will try to slip information about advanced alien technology into 'Amazing Stories' magazine. The pek Overseer is constantly (and from the reader's perspective, comically) trying to decide if "wild story ideas" published in 'Amazing Stories' are hints from Manny that will lead Earthlings to dangerously accelerate the pace of technological advance on Earth.

"Which Reality is Eddy in?" <-- I've begun using "the Final Reality" rather loosely to refer to everything after the Huaoshy alter the Dimensional Structure of the universe. Let's say that Eddy suspects that he is in the Final Reality when he is using the Reality Simulation System to view the recorded history of past Realities. Eddy is not aware of the fact that Manny can still alter the timeline of Earth by sending her zeptozoan time travel agents into the past.

Image generated by Leonardo.

"Where did Gernsback get his information about the two scientists?" <-- I don't know. I assume he read about them in a news story or in some science-related journal. In my imagination, I assume that while writing his January editorial, Gernsback was simply thinking about "The Moon Pool" {https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/title.cgi?16333} which he was planning to re-publish in 'Amazing Stories' magazine. Thus, he took some conventional news item about cosmic ray research and began that paragraph I showed you in his January editorial with: "Who but an imaginative scientifiction writer would think of making actual use of starlight?" Gernsback was trying to invent for Sci Fi fans a bridge between a silly science fiction story by Abraham Grace Merritt and on-going scientific research. Gernsback changed the names of the two scientists because he did not want to put his creative fan-bait into the mouths of real scientists who might not be amused.

Claude: These decisions give the story a clear comic engine: two non-human agents, each sure the other is up to something, fighting over one magazine. Below are my reactions, one inconsistency I think you'll want to settle, and a few questions.

The inconsistency: who renames the scientists, and why? In your first outline, Willhamena used femtobots to make Gernsback "correct" the names, because the scientists had made contact and the pek were hiding it. Now nothing is detected in 1926, and you've given Gernsback his own plausible reason for changing the names: he didn't want to put his fan-bait into the mouths of real scientists. Both can be true, but they point to different stories. 

 In one, Gernsback acts innocently and history accepts his reason, so the misnaming is a harmless-looking quirk that Eddy later finds suspicious. In another, the misnaming is part of Manny's plan, because it gives von Salis a personal hook (he sees a garbled version of himself in print and is curious enough to write). And then there's what Willhamena is doing in his office. I'd suggest that Gernsback's own motive is the surface explanation, that the zeptozoan nudges him toward including the paragraph and the altered names for Manny's reasons, and that Willhamena is in the office for a different purpose (monitoring him). Does that match what you have in mind?

The forged letter naming the bumpha. This is a strong goad, but it has a logic problem the pek would notice. Von Salis could not know the word "bumpha," so the pek can tell at once that either he was really contacted or the letter was forged by someone who knows the term. To make the pek act on von Salis rather than on the real culprit, she must be unable to tell which. If she suspects Manny forged the letter, why does she alter von Salis instead of going after Manny? A plausible answer is that she cannot reach Manny at all (Manny stays in the Sedron Domain or in the future), so von Salis is the only lever she has, and the story can let her be a little ashamed of that. A second question is how the pek learns of the letter. Since she is already monitoring the magazine, the likeliest route is Gernsback's mail or Gernsback's mind, which also gives you a scene where she reads it in his office.

The pek's evil-Venusians draft. This fits your no-evil-aliens rule well, because the evil Venusians are the pek's human-style propaganda inside the story and get rewritten into something gentler. It also creates a clean symmetry. The pek want humans to fear aliens, since that discourages contact and protects the Rules of Intervention, while Manny wants humans to fear them less. So the two sides fight over the tone of a single manuscript. I'd also suggest that Willhamena's three published stories are a defensive tactic: she keeps submitting pek-vetted ideas so Manny has fewer chances to slip something in. Is that her reasoning, or is she writing for some other reason (curiosity, vanity)?

 Eddy and the RSS. The Reality Simulation System draws on data stored in the Sedron Domain, and a zeptozoan is itself made of sedrons. So Eddy might notice an unexplained sedronic signature around Gernsback's office, which is a clue he can't interpret because he assumes no time travel is possible. Does the RSS record show the zeptozoan, or has Manny arranged to hide it? Also, if the Intervention is what produces the Reality Eddy is viewing, does the record change as he watches?

The Moon Pool. I can't verify that Gernsback was planning to reprint "The Moon Pool" at that time, nor that it was on his mind when he wrote the editorial. I also don't know whether the rest of the editorial mentions it. It's your story's imagination, so it can stay as Eddy's theory, but if you want the story to state it as fact I'd like to check first. Could you paste the surrounding editorial text, or shall I look for it? One small note on the passage: you quoted it as "Who but an imaginative scientifiction writer would think of making actual use of starlight?" but the image reads "Who, for instance, but an imaginative scientifiction writer, would think of making actual use of starlight? Absurd!" That "Absurd!" is a great detail for the pek's paranoia, because Gernsback is announcing the idea as absurd and then reporting that scientists are doing it.

Pek paranoia as a running gag. Her habit of judging every wild idea in the magazine could be a ledger of threat ratings, with her worrying about each story. If you want real examples, I'd check which stories ran in the issues between November 1926 and May 1927 before naming any, since I don't trust my memory on that.

Which would you like to settle first: the renaming question, how the pek learns of the letter, or Willhamena's reason for writing?

 Quick Turn-over of Ideas. At this point I ended the story planning session with Claude. Claude was right to notice that my thinking about the story arch had changed. I liked the idea of Gernsback creating the editorial on his own. The arrival of Willhamena can come later, after von Salis responds to the Editorial.

Next: a new science fiction story titled "Mystery of Mönch Mountain".

Visit the Gallery of Movies, Book and Magazine Covers